Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Tech Talk => Topic started by: Dave Head on April 23, 2011, 09:48:49 pm

Title: Aero resonator
Post by: Dave Head on April 23, 2011, 09:48:49 pm
These were not avail for awhile, seems to be back in stock. This is what I would install if I the my muffler needed replacement.
Aero-Turbine Resonated Performance Muffler 5050L (http://www.xtremediesel.com/aero-turbineresonatedperformancemuffler5050l.aspx)
Then for the exhaust wrap...
Thermo Tec Exhaust Insulating Graphite Black Wrap #11023 (http://www.xtremediesel.com/thermotecexhaustinsulatinggraphiteblackwrap11023.aspx)

Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: wa_desert_rat on January 30, 2012, 05:08:41 pm
These were not avail for awhile, seems to be back in stock. This is what I would install if I the my muffler needed replacement.
Aero-Turbine Resonated Performance Muffler 5050L (http://www.xtremediesel.com/aero-turbineresonatedperformancemuffler5050l.aspx)
Then for the exhaust wrap...
Thermo Tec Exhaust Insulating Graphite Black Wrap #11023 (http://www.xtremediesel.com/thermotecexhaustinsulatinggraphiteblackwrap11023.aspx)

The link you Dave Head provided (above) again lists the Aero Resonator as "discontinued". I found a couple other links that may still work:

Aeroturbine 5" Resonated Performance Diesel Muffler AT5050XL (http://www.puredieselpower.com/catalog/aeroturbine-resonated-performance-diesel-muffler-5050xl-p-137.html?m1track=googlebase&osCsid=b452173eae0d3988f161a6f178cafff6#googlebase)

Aeroturbine Resonated 5.0" In x 5.0" Out Muffler 5050XL (http://www.dieselpowerproducts.com/p-7527-aeroturbine-resonated-50-in-x-50-out-muffler-5050xl.aspx)

Price for the first link is $199 and the second $193. Second link says that it may not be available for long.

Has anyone installed a resonator on a 5.9 Cummins U225? Just had a long look under my coach and there is a gigantic muffler there so obviously whoever installed the Banks system didn't bother with the resonator.

Craig
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: PatC on January 30, 2012, 07:02:24 pm
Has anyone installed a resonator on a 5.9 Cummins U225? Just had a long look under my coach and there is a gigantic muffler there so obviously whoever installed the Banks system didn't bother with the resonator.
Can't believe they left that monster on there.  Has to weigh close 75 to a 100 lbs.  Considering the expense of the Banks system, you would think that they would have removed it.
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: wa_desert_rat on January 30, 2012, 07:56:22 pm
Can't believe they left that monster on there.  Has to weigh close 75 to a 100 lbs.  Considering the expense of the Banks system, you would think that they would have removed it.

Yeah... it's huge. Have you switched to a resonator? It's on my #1 do-list and I'd like to get the mod started ASAP. Would really like some info from those who have changed over.

Craig
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: John Haygarth on January 30, 2012, 10:41:18 pm
Actually the banks stinger will increase the hp regardless of whether the muffler is there or not. It is independent of it but does a better job in our humble opinion with the muffler removed as less restriction. Banks would really like you to install their muffler system but I do not know if one is available for our units.
It is one of those things in life that you do not know what is good for you till you have done it!! eh Dave M?
John H
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: Dave M (RIP) on January 31, 2012, 06:39:18 am
You got it John, In my world, it is such an obvious need, unless you are not aware.  Am glad I got it started here.  I am always thinking performance / efficient operation.  Fuel mileage improvement is just a side benefit.
Hope Mexico is good to you.
Dave M
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: wa_desert_rat on February 01, 2012, 02:46:55 pm
Actually the banks stinger will increase the hp regardless of whether the muffler is there or not. It is independent of it but does a better job in our humble opinion with the muffler removed as less restriction. Banks would really like you to install their muffler system but I do not know if one is available for our units.
It is one of those things in life that you do not know what is good for you till you have done it!! eh Dave M?
John H

I'm still trying to search information on which resonator I should use for the 5.9L Cummins in a U225. The resonator that Banks sells does not offer a 5.9L Cummins earlier than 2003 for some reason.

Is the resonator (Aero) Dave Head posted suitable for the U225. Anyone done the conversion yet?

Jeez... I hope I don't have to blaze the trail for these models. :P

Craig
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: PatC on February 01, 2012, 03:38:22 pm
I'm still trying to search information on which resonator I should use for the 5.9L Cummins in a U225. The resonator that Banks sells does not offer a 5.9L Cummins earlier than 2003 for some reason.

Is the resonator (Aero) Dave Head posted suitable for the U225. Anyone done the conversion yet?

Jeez... I hope I don't have to blaze the trail for these models. :P

Craig
I don't think that the resonator is engine dependent.  It is more dependent on the side of the intake exhaust pipe and output tail pipe.  You are probably 3" and converting to 4" would really help, but  if you have a exhaust brake it is probably best to stay with the size of the intake and exhaust sides of the exhaust brake, cause you are not going to want to change that.  I'm going to guess you are 3" unless someone has changed every thing.  If the resonator is 5" and you need to go down to 3", that is no problem because there are adaptors you can get welded in to go down to 3".

The only reason for the muffler or resonator is to quiet things down some.  The turbo meets the requirements of a muffler in most states.  So if you could put up with the noise, you could get rid of them all together.  But some LEO might just decide you need a muffler, so there lays the need for the resonator.  It looks like a muffler.
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: Jerry Whiteaker on February 01, 2012, 06:57:51 pm
I put a 4040 XL aeroturbine muffler/resonator on my coach last year.  It replaced the stock Donaldson muffler. Stick with the size of exhaust pipe that you have to keep it simple.  I had to fabricate new brackets, buy a 90 degree ell and install some SS flex pipe to the chrome exhaust tip.  Exhaust pipe, ells, and fittings come in OD and ID sizes, so you have to buy the right sizes for the parts to fit together.  About a 6 week wait to get the SS ell.  Bought everything except the metal for the mounting brackets from companies I found on the internet. The XL model is longer and I believe a little quieter.  You can look straight though it, not much to cause back pressure.  Expect the shiny SS muffler to discolor as soon as you drive the coach.  If it has helped increase the power and mileage, I can't tell it, but hopefully a little.  The exhaust at idle is a little louder, but I don't notice any difference in the sound going down the road.  I had the drivers window open going up the Zion NP tunnel expecting a big racket, but it was rather quiet.
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: John S on February 01, 2012, 07:16:54 pm
I got to say that I love my new set up.  I can not wait to take it out west and see it climb the mountains.  I think Dave's HP increase is next.
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: wa_desert_rat on February 01, 2012, 09:31:56 pm
I don't think that the resonator is engine dependent.  It is more dependent on the side of the intake exhaust pipe and output tail pipe.  You are probably 3" and converting to 4" would really help, but  if you have a exhaust brake it is probably best to stay with the size of the intake and exhaust sides of the exhaust brake, cause you are not going to want to change that.  I'm going to guess you are 3" unless someone has changed every thing.  If the resonator is 5" and you need to go down to 3", that is no problem because there are adaptors you can get welded in to go down to 3".

The engine side of the muffler (and, damn!, that thing is HUGE!!!) is a 3" diameter exhaust pipe. I'll have to get in there again and see whether it would be feasible to upgrade that to 4" dia. I didn't measure the exhaust pipe out of the muffler.

Quote
The only reason for the muffler or resonator is to quiet things down some.  The turbo meets the requirements of a muffler in most states.  So if you could put up with the noise, you could get rid of them all together.  But some LEO might just decide you need a muffler, so there lays the need for the resonator.  It looks like a muffler.

I'll have to wait until the area dries out a bit before I get into the system much further. I'm not sure if I can take that right-rear panel off... there is an access door just forward that opens next to the forward part of the muffler.

I can't believe how gigantic that muffler is. LOL

Thanks for your helps... everyone!

Craig
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: PatC on February 02, 2012, 09:19:40 am
Craig,
Your Cummins "Retarder" exhaust brake is probably 3", so if it is working and you plan on retaining it, you might as well stay with the 3" all the way from the engine to the rear.  But if you plan on changing to a Pac PRXB exhaust brake (which is already  set up with  4") and do it at the same time, then it would be feasible to change to a larger diameter exhaust from engine back.  But I see no benefit of going larger than 4".  If you go larger behind the existing 3" Retarder exhaust brake, I really doubt you will see and power gain.
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: Gayland Baasch on February 03, 2012, 08:56:33 pm
All reports on this mod seem positive, but before I jump on the bandwagon I've got to ask one question.  If this is so great, why don't they come from the factory that way?
Title: Re: Aero resonator
Post by: Dave M (RIP) on February 03, 2012, 09:43:20 pm
I am not certain, but my guess is the normal is muffler mind set.  Most folks have a hard time thinking past muffler, also the truck resonator I think is a recent item, like in the last 20 years or so.  Besides who ever heard of not using a muffler, some things are hard to change or accept.
I learned about them when I needed a muffler for my Detroit Diesel, the turbo noise was  way too harsh, I found an old 5" resonator laying around the shop, since it was short and simple to install, it went on.  Amazed now it cut the harshness from the exhaust.  Since it has no baffles, straight thru, felt it was a great idea and it works.
This is my story and I am sticking with it.  ;D