Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Discussions => Topic started by: Robert & Linda on March 25, 2014, 06:58:06 pm

Title: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Robert & Linda on March 25, 2014, 06:58:06 pm
Hello
In looking at coaches to buy we've discovered that one we're considering was in an accident. The Foretravel driver rear-ended someone. Apparently, as far as repairs went a new front cap was needed, plus lights, and a new generator as the generator was damaged in the impact. We're concerned about the frame (which we're not in a position to look at since we're in a different state). We're assured by the seller that it's fine but prudence dictates we should consider more than just their assurances. What do experienced FT owners think about this? Since it's been repaired should we disregard it, or are there things we should have checked specifically because of the accident? Grateful for all opinions. Thanks.
Linda
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: kb0zke on March 25, 2014, 07:20:17 pm
That's a tough one. The main frame is probably fine, but the sub-frame up front might be the question. I think I'd want to know who did the repair work. If Foretravel did it then I wouldn't worry about it. If Bubba's Body and Bait Shop did it I think I'd ask more questions.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Carol Savournin on March 25, 2014, 08:00:54 pm
That's a tough one. The main frame is probably fine, but the sub-frame up front might be the question. I think I'd want to know who did the repair work. If Foretravel did it then I wouldn't worry about it. If Bubba's Body and Bait Shop did it I think I'd ask more questions.

Ditto.  And you could still require that any issue related to the impact that requires repair within a year is 50% covered by the seller.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: John S on March 25, 2014, 08:16:16 pm
I would look at the the tires.  If the H member is bent then you would have issues with alignment.  I think that if it was fix at FT it would be fine.  I have seen a number of accidents on FTs and they can be fixed brand new but much of it is cosmetic and the generator is on much light steel than the front H member.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Gary Bouland (RIP) on March 26, 2014, 09:36:21 am
If FT or Xtreme repaired it I would not worry about it.  If the owner had it done there he will probably be glad to tell you, if he CAN'T RECALL who did the work I would have a thorough inspection made by someone like Brett.
Gary B
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Keith and Joyce on March 26, 2014, 11:41:15 am
I would want a thorough inspection by a qualified person who knows Foretravel construction AND have it put on an alignment rack to check caster, camber, toe-in, thrust angle etc.  Just because it's been repaired does not mean it's straight.

Keith
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Chuck Pearson on March 26, 2014, 06:43:39 pm
New front cap, generator, this was a serious hit.  There is a lot of structure up front that has to be just so and I wouldn't trust these repairs to have been made properly by anyone other than Foretravel.  There are steel and plywood subframes and bulkheads in the front area that support the fiberglass cap, keep the windows in place, the generator subframe actually hangs from the frame rails.  I'd be less worried about the relatively easy to inspect front suspension than this stuff. 

Personally wouldn't want anything to do with it unless it was inspected by FT or at a price point that would justify risk. 
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Robert & Linda on March 26, 2014, 10:35:12 pm
Thanks for the opinions and insights. We have decided to pass. The price was very good but we didn't want to find issues down the road. We found out about the accident through a Carfax/Autocheck report we ran on the VIN, otherwise we wouldn't have known about it.

Can't say how much I appreciate the willingness of this group to help out. Can't wait till we get a Foretravel!

Linda
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Keith and Joyce on March 27, 2014, 01:09:39 pm
Linda,

So you had to find out about the accident.  It was not revealed by the seller.  You are right to run far, far away.

Keith
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: wayne m on March 27, 2014, 02:55:04 pm
I don't want to start something, but the accident in question was a
slow speed rear ending of a garbage truck at a stop light. yes the
repair required the bottom part of the end cap and repairs to the
generator. all prospective buyers have been informed of damage
and have been sent pictures.  I have never told anyone that the repairs
were made at the factory.  I consider some of the previous comments
bordering on slanderous.  If someone wants to make a comment on a coach,
perhaps they should at least have a look at it.
Me and the co-owner of this coach have over thirty years of fore-
travel ownership between us and we have some knowledge of what
constitutes a good coach.  this coach has a few minor fiberglass issues,
but the rest of the coach is in outstanding condition.  it is sharply
priced and will make someone very happy.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Keith and Joyce on March 27, 2014, 03:47:47 pm
Wayne,

I did not mean to cast any aspersions on you.  If you feel that I did then I apologize.  I was posting on what I read at face value which was that there was a coach for sale by someone unknown who had not revealed previous damage.  If a seller does not reveal accident damage then that's a red flag.

Keith
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Raymond Jordan on March 27, 2014, 03:50:59 pm
Hi Wayne,
  Thanks for the great explanation. Foretravel owners are the best.
Raymond
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: John S on March 27, 2014, 04:53:42 pm
I had a small accident on my 99. A kid pulled out across the road in front of me.  FT fixed it with no issues.  It was impossible to tell and I drove it for another 70k miles and it was fine.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Robert & Linda on March 27, 2014, 04:59:07 pm
As a newbie here I certainly don't want to start anything. I didn't intend to bad mouth anyone when I asked for advice which was why I refrained from naming names when I asked my question. But in my defense, Wayne, we were *not* told anything about this accident. We found out about it on Autocheck, and the pictures we've seen are the ones posted on the forum classifieds.
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: Ed Pan on August 31, 2014, 09:48:29 am
Compare this coach in question to the Phoenix whose front end was crushed by the drawbridge counterweight and then repaired by Foretravel.
Ed
Title: Re: How much of an accident is too much of an accident?
Post by: D.J. Osborn on August 31, 2014, 11:04:25 am
It's clear that any coach involved in a serious crash requires a very careful inspection by someone qualified and familiar with Foretravels. Any other speculation on its condition is just that: It's speculation.