Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Tech Talk => Topic started by: 4stakes on October 20, 2014, 10:09:36 pm

Title: Generator solenoid
Post by: 4stakes on October 20, 2014, 10:09:36 pm
My generator (7.5 KW Onan Diesel) starts fine and runs for about 15-20 minutes then dies.  It then won't start again.  After about an hour, it will start again and run for 10 minutes and die.
The fuel filter is clean and is fairly new.  After looking over the generator, there is a solenoid on the front of it that appears to be bad and I suspect this is the problem.  What does this solenoid do?
Thanks,
Kearn
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: Irwin on October 20, 2014, 10:26:34 pm
Do you have a picture of the suspect relay?
Regards,Irwin
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: J. D. Stevens on October 20, 2014, 10:49:29 pm
Symptoms are what I would expect from an overheating problem. Check coolant and cooling systems.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: amos.harrison on October 20, 2014, 10:50:51 pm
I suspect that is the fuel shutdown solenoid.  It needs a signal to open, and another to hold it open.  This would affect start-up, but wouldn't cause a delayed shutdown.  I would look at possible overheating conditions.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: Don Hay on October 20, 2014, 11:00:00 pm
The cooling system has a temperature sensor.  Check your thermostat and coolant level.  It's possible that if its not opening, the coolant temperature is building up, causing the sensor to shut down the Onan. 
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: JohnFitz on October 20, 2014, 11:22:10 pm
I have the same generator.  As others have said it's the fuel solenoid.  It has to be pulled in for the engine to run.  When you manually crank it from the control panel (box that is on the generator), you should see this solenoid pull in WHILE it's cranking and running.  When it dies, try re-starting right away and notice if the solenoid is being pulled in.  If so, it's a fuel supply issue.  If not, it's a wiring or solenoid going bad issue.  But this just my own thinking, I'm no expert.  You can also manually pull the solenoid in to see if it will start.

As for overheating, when that happens it pops a red button the panel and cuts power to this solenoid.  I believe the button is labeled "FAULT".  If you don't reset it, it will crank but not start.  A fault can also be caused by low oil pressure IIRC.  I assume you have checked coolant and oil levels.  How about fuel level in the tank?  Above 1/4 tank?
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: Don Hay on October 20, 2014, 11:41:01 pm
Actually, the temperature sensor is at the top right of the Onan, next to the top radiator hose.  You can see wires going to/from it.  I should, but don't know where the thermostat is located.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: Don Hay on October 21, 2014, 12:51:43 am
John is correct: The Red Fault button on the front of the box would have to be pushed back in if it's a temperature problem.  Otherwise it wouldn't start, even when antifreeze has cooled down 10-15 minutes later.  If the button isn't popped out, it's probably not a temperature issue.  I had the fuel shutoff solenoid crap out last spring, after 22 years.  Guess I shouldn't complain :)
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: JohnFitz on October 21, 2014, 07:20:36 am
Member Coastprt just posted about replacing the fuel pump: What did you do to your coach today III (http://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=22378.msg175326#msg175326) Reply #535
Another possibility.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: Dave M (RIP) on October 21, 2014, 09:42:33 am
FanBelt loose or broken
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: pocketchange on October 21, 2014, 12:48:31 pm
Now would be a good time to replace the fuel shut-off solenoid, start solenoid, fuel pump, etc., etc..
Flush the cooling system (RMI 25),  replace the fuel lines

Especially if you enjoy piece of mind.. pc 
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: 4stakes on October 21, 2014, 01:29:38 pm
Thanks for the replies.
Fluids are good and the temperature fault button has not had to be reset.  Belts are good and tight also.  Fuel tank is full. 
My plan is to change this solenoid first and see if that fixes the problem.  I just was not sure what its job was.
Thanks again for the suggestions and I hope that replacing it solves the problem.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: George on October 21, 2014, 02:52:37 pm
A left field idea, this was like a problem a friend of my had. The fuel supply line was bad inside, not letting a steady flow to the apu.
Title: Re: Generator solenoid
Post by: coastprt on August 25, 2022, 09:21:38 pm
I have the same generator.  As others have said it's the fuel solenoid.  It has to be pulled in for the engine to run.  When you manually crank it from the control panel (box that is on the generator), you should see this solenoid pull in WHILE it's cranking and running.  When it dies, try re-starting right away and notice if the solenoid is being pulled in.  If so, it's a fuel supply issue.  If not, it's a wiring or solenoid going bad issue.  But this just my own thinking, I'm no expert.  You can also manually pull the solenoid in to see if it will start.

As for overheating, when that happens it pops a red button the panel and cuts power to this solenoid.  I believe the button is labeled "FAULT".  If you don't reset it, it will crank but not start.  A fault can also be caused by low oil pressure IIRC.  I assume you have checked coolant and oil levels.  How about fuel level in the tank?  Above 1/4 tank?


I have a Kubota V1305 4 cylinder Kubota and was having similar problems with hard starting and shutting down after running a while and then finally it would start and shut down immediately. I thought maybe the fuel lines needed replacing ( which they probably do). This has been going on for a while and I would just bleed the air out of the fuel line and it would run okay but not great for any length of time. 

Oil and coolant levels were okay. I pulled the fuel shutoff solenoid immediately after starting manually before it had a chance to die and it ran perfect.  Inserting the relay back in would shut it off. I tested it that way several times and let it run for a couple of hours with no problems!

Ordered a new solenoid from Ebay 12V Fuel Shutoff Solenoid for Kubota D905 D1005 D1105 V1205 V1305 V1505... (https://www.ebay.com/itm/164289799212)  and replaced it today.  Started immediately from the dash switch and ran great for an hour with a full load (both A/Cs) with no sputtering or shutdowns.   

The old solenoid was probably on its way out for a long time and was working intermittently enough to fool me.   

Thanks John for the excellent tech tip on how to troubleshoot the generator fuel shutoff solenoid!  It's an easy an inexpensive fix that everyone should know to eliminate a potential generator problem before going on to something else.  A new spare to carry onboard along with other spare relays would be a good idea!

Jerry