Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Tech Talk => Topic started by: goldbehen on November 22, 2015, 08:57:02 pm

Title: Block heater question
Post by: goldbehen on November 22, 2015, 08:57:02 pm
How long should I leave the block heater on for it to be effective. Looking at temps in the high 20's.
Any other advice for cold weather starting is appreciated.


              Thanks
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 22, 2015, 09:04:02 pm
Two hours at that temperature will be sufficient to ease starting.

Assume you have some means of keeping the chassis batteries charged.

Turn on boost switch BEFORE turning key to on/start.  The more battery amp hours behind the starter, the less the voltage drop and easier it will start.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: bbeane on November 22, 2015, 09:06:51 pm
I turn mine on 2-3 hours before leaving. If we are leaving early I turn it on when I go to bed. Also as Brett says the boost switch helps a bunch.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: goldbehen on November 22, 2015, 09:33:23 pm
Do these draw a lot of power ? I'll be storing unplugged for the next few weeks. I guess I'll need to run the generator when I turn the block heater on rather than the inverter next time I start it.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 22, 2015, 09:40:56 pm
Do these draw a lot of power ? I'll be storing unplugged for the next few weeks. I guess I'll need to run the generator when I turn the block heater on rather than the inverter next time I start it.

Yes, most are 1000-1500 watt heaters.  I would be surprised if your block heater is wired through the inverter.  I would sure not recommend taking down the batteries to power it even if it is wired to run on the inverter.  Yes, I know the inverter runs on the house bank, but in really cold weather, it is a good idea to use the boost switch for less voltage drop, AND you are really hard-timing your alternator to start with deeply discharged large battery bank and it will also be powering the INTAKE MANIFOLD HEATER for the first couple of minutes in blow freezing temperatures.

So, yes, start the generator, let it bring the batteries (both banks!) up to full charge and also power the block heater.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Caflashbob on November 22, 2015, 11:29:24 pm
Does your model come with ether start?  I would not hesitate to use it.  Only works below 50 degrees and has a measured shot.

20 degrees probably does not need it.  Extended crank time (60 seconds) used to be ok long ago.

Just a lot of white cold smoke. 

More politically correct to pre heat the engine.  Not sure about needing number one diesel at 20 degrees but might help.

Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2015, 08:48:28 am
Does your model come with ether start? 

VERY unlikely.  Modern diesels use an INTAKE MANIFOLD HEATER to aid in cold starts.  Very dangerous to shoot ether into a red hot heater grid! So, check before even considering the use of ether.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: ohsonew on November 23, 2015, 09:06:18 am
Just curious, I have used the aqua hot engine preheat when the engine is cold. I also have an electric switch on the bed platform labeled engine block. I assume it  is  an electric heating element located somewhere on the engine. Is there any advantage/disadvantage to one over the other, or to use both in unison?

Thanks,
Larry
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: goldbehen on November 23, 2015, 09:25:47 am
Great info as usual. I'll return it to storage and disconnect the battery terminal - side. When I'm ready to go in 3 weeks I'll run the generator and the block heater. As far as a different diesel fuel will the northeast switch over or do I need to look for it? Do I need an additive. I plan to go up North over Christmas and who knows what the temps will be up near West Point. Could be in the 50's or in the teens.
Thanks again!
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: rbark on November 23, 2015, 09:42:50 am
Larry, I will run my Aqua Hot eng preheat sometimes over the electric. Turn it on when we go to bed and when it's time to go the eng is around 100 deg depending on how cold it is outside.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Roger & Susan in Home2 on November 23, 2015, 10:07:51 am
I turned on the engine block heater many times for an easier start.  One day I was in the electronis box at the foot of the bed and there was nothing connected to the outlet where the block heater should have been.  There is no block heater at all.  It was a California coach.  Double check, do you actually have one?  So overnight with the AquaHot works perfectly well.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: krush on November 23, 2015, 11:38:42 am
  The more battery amp hours behind the starter, the less the voltage drop and easier it will start.

Amp-hours? I believe amps are what we want to run a short duration high load device such as a starter.

Having a huge battery bank with a billion amp hours won't do much good if they aren't designed to push out momentary high amounts of current.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Caflashbob on November 23, 2015, 11:46:09 am
VERY unlikely.  Modern diesels use an INTAKE MANIFOLD HEATER to aid in cold starts.  Very dangerous to shoot ether into a red hot heater grid! So, check before even considering the use of ether.


All of the older coaches had that system from Foretravel as was discussed here before.  My m11 has it and the nomenclature on the engine shows the port for the system.  I understand that his 99 is probably an electronic 8.3 as is my m11 and to increase my personal knowledge base I asked if he had the button on the dash.

If he does and has an electronic diesel also there would be a port on the engine to bypass the grid heater I assume.

We were skiers long ago and at a unintended -30F the ether system got the 3208 going.

if I owned a coach with the system installed by the manufacturer and was in a winter area I would test the system personally just for safety.

Cummins must think it's ok on my m11 so I was wondering if the electronic 8.3 also had the system available.

Versus hours of maybe hard to arrange block heating the ether might be a useable option?

Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 23, 2015, 11:55:36 am
I don't even know if we have a block heater. I do know we fired her up in Flagstaff after a freezing night and got white smoke for a short moment. Is that normal?  :-\
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: toyman on November 23, 2015, 01:18:12 pm
Having a huge battery bank with a billion amp hours won't do much good if they aren't designed to push out momentary high amounts of current.
And conversely, I'd bet that a lot of amps for a couple of seconds aren't gonna do you much good ..... Or will they ?
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Rick on November 23, 2015, 01:32:52 pm
I always use my block heater when getting ready to leave in the morning. Even if it's in the 60's at night. If in the 60's I just run it for a couple of hours and if boondocking it gives the gen a good load along with morning necessities. If lower temps I'll turn it on somewhere around 2:00AM, (not boondocking) it warms the bed too. Turn off block heater and all other loads and disconnect elect/gen then start engine. It allows the engine to spin better lessening the stress on the batteries, starter etc.
Good luck,
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 23, 2015, 01:52:21 pm
I always use my block heater when getting ready to leave in the morning. Even if it's in the 60's at night. If in the 60's I just run it for a couple of hours and if boondocking it gives the gen a good load along with morning necessities. If lower temps I'll turn it on somewhere around 2:00AM, (not boondocking) it warms the bed too. Turn off block heater and all other loads and disconnect elect/gen then start engine. It allows the engine to spin better lessening the stress on the batteries, starter etc.
Good luck,

Sign me up, Scotty. I still don't know if I have one on our old time girl. 
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: rsihnhold on November 23, 2015, 02:19:42 pm
Cummins actually lists the requirements for reserve capacity in their engine manual.

For my mechanical C8.3 in 32F temperature, CCA is 1280 and reserve capacity is 480 minutes.  At 0F, CCA is 1800 and reserve capacity is required to be 640 minutes. 
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: goldbehen on November 23, 2015, 02:33:51 pm
Well it fired right up after the block heater was on for a couple hours. Outside temp was right at freezing. Regarding an ether switch, I don't see one. We'll see how it does after sitting in extended sub freezing temps. So far so good.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: nitehawk on November 23, 2015, 02:54:00 pm
The block heater switch at the foot of the bed in our '89 GV lit up whenever I turned it on. I didn't discover how badly the outlet the block heater plugged into was burned/melted until I replaced the insulation lining the engine compartment. One of the blades was totally gone/melted off!
Apparently corrosion had deteriorated the contacts to the point that it heated up. I strongly recommend, now that the season for their use is here, that those that use their block heaters unplug them and clean all the blades. We were lucky to avoid a fire under the bed! Could have lost the coach to a fire.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2015, 05:19:32 pm
I don't even know if we have a block heater. I do know we fired her up in Flagstaff after a freezing night and got white smoke for a short moment. Is that normal?  :-\

Yes, you have a block heater.  Switch under bed skirt.  Block heater plugged into outlet on the front wall of the engine compartment under the bed.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 23, 2015, 06:48:13 pm
Yes, you have a block heater.  Switch under bed skirt.  Block heater plugged into outlet on the front wall of the engine compartment under the bed.

Once again, "Popa Brett" bails me out, found the coach battery boost switch, as well as the block heater switch. Another plus was finding the 12v fuse box! I think when the PO was showing me the coach, he did not think a scruffy long hair (white ponytail) and a week old beard could afford the coach and did not want to spend a lot of time on explanations + I had no clue how complicated these coaches are and my head was spinning after an hour!  Thanks again, Popa. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2015, 07:00:28 pm
Actually, the marine on/off switch is much more than a battery boost switch.

Yes, it can be use for combining battery banks (for charge or discharge).

ALSO:  If OFF with engine running, alternator charges only the chassis battery.  A good position if plugged in last night and tonight.  Ridiculous to burn diesel to OVER-charge the house bank while driving.

With the switch ON, both battery banks are charged.  And, with no diode-based isolator, you are not turning diesel/alternator output into HEAT in the diode-based isolator. 

Simple and effective.  But not automatic. But how hard is a major decision between OFF and ON???
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Don Rickey on November 23, 2015, 09:02:14 pm
This question may be for Brett.

I have a couple of unlabeled switches in our 2007 Nimbus, one of which is by the bed. Have asked the factory about this, but they seem mystified as well. I am not aware that I have a block heater, have always used the Hydro-Hot engine pre-heat. Do the 2007's have a block heater and, if so, should we use that in conjunction with the engine pre-heat?

Thanks for any info,

Don
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: amos.harrison on November 23, 2015, 09:17:37 pm
If I'm paying for the electricity I use the A-H for engine pre-heating.  If I use the block heater, I only use it long enough to bring the engine temperature above 60 degrees.  I feel that is responsible energy conservation.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: kb0zke on November 23, 2015, 09:44:39 pm
Last year temperatures were in the upper teens with strong winds for several days before we left. The night before we were to leave I turned on the block heater as we went to bed. The next day we packed up (outside work was done as quickly as possible), I turned off the block heater, turned on the boost, and cranked. The engine wasn't real happy about starting, but it did start.

The plan is to move up to Babler Wendesday morning. Tomorrow night it is supposed to be 37, so I'll turn on the block heater at bedtime (if I remember). If I forget I'll turn it on as soon as we wake up, and it may just take us a little longer to get going.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2015, 10:32:35 pm
This question may be for Brett.

I have a couple of unlabeled switches in our 2007 Nimbus, one of which is by the bed. Have asked the factory about this, but they seem mystified as well. I am not aware that I have a block heater, have always used the Hydro-Hot engine pre-heat. Do the 2007's have a block heater and, if so, should we use that in conjunction with the engine pre-heat?

Thanks for any info,

Don

Sorry, Don--  I don't know the answer.  But a quick look in the engine room should tell you.  An "extension cord"/120 VAC cord coming from the engine and plugged into a 120 VAC outlet should be easy to spot.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: krush on November 24, 2015, 06:56:46 am
And conversely, I'd bet that a lot of amps for a couple of seconds aren't gonna do you much good ..... Or will they ?

As listed in another post in this thread, the engine makers state their specs in CCA. The assumption is that the voltage of the batteries is correct.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Don Rickey on November 24, 2015, 10:23:34 am
Sorry, Don--  I don't know the answer.  But a quick look in the engine room should tell you.  An "extension cord"/120 VAC cord coming from the engine and plugged into a 120 VAC outlet should be easy to spot.
Of course!

I'll check that. Thanks, Brett!

Don
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: bobnkathy on November 24, 2015, 10:33:27 am
Of course!

I'll check that. Thanks, Brett!

Don

Don, the 2007 Nimbus does not have a block heater. We use the HydroHot to preheat the engine. The switches next to the bed are for the speakers from your bedroom television. Turn on the switch if you want the speakers over the bed on. You also have a switch to turn on the generator and your docking lights. Hope this helps
Bob
2007 Nimbus Owner
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Don Rickey on November 24, 2015, 11:18:18 am
Thanks, Bob. Sent you a PM.

Don
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: oldguy on November 24, 2015, 01:38:51 pm
Last year temperatures were in the upper teens with strong winds for several days before we left. The night before we were to leave I turned on the block heater as we went to bed. The next day we packed up (outside work was done as quickly as possible), I turned off the block heater, turned on the boost, and cranked. The engine wasn't real happy about starting, but it did start.

The plan is to move up to Babler Wendesday morning. Tomorrow night it is supposed to be 37, so I'll turn on the block heater at bedtime (if I remember). If I forget I'll turn it on as soon as we wake up, and it may just take us a little longer to get going.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: oldguy on November 24, 2015, 01:41:32 pm
Last year temperatures were in the upper teens with strong winds for several days before we left. The night before we were to leave I turned on the block heater as we went to bed. The next day we packed up (outside work was done as quickly as possible), I turned off the block heater, turned on the boost, and cranked. The engine wasn't real happy about starting, but it did start.

The plan is to move up to Babler Wendesday morning. Tomorrow night it is supposed to be 37, so I'll turn on the block heater at bedtime (if I remember). If I forget I'll turn it on as soon as we wake up, and it may just take us a little longer to get going.
I would check to make sure your block heater is working 
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 24, 2015, 01:43:05 pm
I would check to make sure your block heater is working 

How would one know, except for white smoke at start-up?  A warm engine block?
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 24, 2015, 01:48:42 pm
Mike,

Yes, pretty easy to tell  by touching the block near it (lower driver's side of block) . Certainly make sure the switch is on (red light illuminated) and that the block heater is plugged into the outlet on the front wall of the engine room.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Dave Head on November 24, 2015, 02:03:14 pm
Unplug it, plug into an extension cord, then plug the cord into an inverter supplied outlet and monitor the drain on your batteries. "Holy crap" indicates its working.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: kb0zke on November 24, 2015, 07:05:25 pm
Mike, I know the "block" heater works because I check it whenever I use it. For some unknown reason, Foretravel decided that the proper place for the heater is in a tank at the top of the engine. Yes, coolant is in there, but since heat rises, that little tank gets quite warm as it tries to warm all of the coolant. I'm thinking that when I have the engine serviced in March I'll have that block heater moved to the lower part of the engine, where it belongs. That way there won't be any loss of coolant, since the coolant will all be disposed of anyway.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 24, 2015, 07:10:16 pm
Block heater location varies by engine make and model.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: oldguy on November 24, 2015, 07:42:56 pm
The block heater should be in the block as in the tank above the block the thermostat would stop the engine from getting warm. The
only heater that I know of that isn't in the block is the circulation heater that that is installed out side the engine and is hooked to the engine by heater hoses. They work great too.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on November 24, 2015, 09:22:08 pm
The Detroit coolant heater when installed in the thermostat housing is almost useless. Do yourself and your starter a favor and install one in the proper location or install a circulating heater for less than $100 with hoses/fittings.

Pierce
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 25, 2015, 09:52:17 am
Funny that we could be in very cold temps with the Airstream, hit the glow plug button to heat for 30 seconds and be in business, rather than all the fooling around we have to do now.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 25, 2015, 12:41:07 pm
Mike,

Your engine will start down into the 20's without all the "fooling around". 

But the "fooling around" makes it a lot easier on the engine, starter and batteries.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 25, 2015, 01:05:05 pm
Mike,

Your engine will start down into the 20's without all the "fooling around". 

But the "fooling around" makes it a lot easier on the engine, starter and batteries.

Ah, the temp was what I was wondering about. When she "white smoked" for a instant in Flagstaff, I wondered. Thanks, Brett.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: wolfe10 on November 25, 2015, 01:07:32 pm
Yup, in the 20's with no block heater, it WILL cough white smoke!
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on November 25, 2015, 02:13:43 pm
The Airstream with the Isuzu 6BD1A diesel had quick heat glow plugs. Only takes a couple of seconds to fire up in cold weather. Our Mercedes 300SD is an indirect injection (pre-combustion chambers) engine and with almost 450,000 miles, it starts instantly with a 3 or 4 second glow down in the teens and with no smoke.

The Cummins, Detroits, CATs don't have glow plugs and take a lot longer to start in very cold weather with just heated screens like the Cummins has.

Heavy duty diesels spend lots of over the road time so don't usually make cold starts that often. Our Detroit owners just got stuck with a terrible order spec on the Foretravel engine installation.

Pierce

Izuzu glow plugs example below:
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: Mike Leary (RIP) on November 25, 2015, 02:44:10 pm
The Airstream with the Isuzu 6BD1A diesel had quick heat glow plugs.

No wonder GM bought Isuzu, a bullet-proof design! Owners of Chev dura-max engines can thank the Isuzu engineers! We've poked our noses into some "chilly" areas with the AS, and the glow-plug method never failed us!
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: krush on November 25, 2015, 06:15:00 pm
My 8.3 will start instantly down to 25F or so without me waiting for the grid heater to come on (I turn the key to start instantly). It puffs a bit of smoke for about a minute. I try to use the block heater when possible, though.

I run synthetic oil. It helps with cold cranking.
Title: Re: Block heater question
Post by: oldguy on November 26, 2015, 06:29:29 pm
I like glow plugs, it always work the best. Some cat engines use glow plugs and I could get them going at -30 no problem. Cat engines with pup engines is probably the easiest on the engine as the main engine can get a bit warm before starting, cat hasn't made pup engines for about 50  years.