Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Tech Talk => Topic started by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 05:45:11 am

Title: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 05:45:11 am
Hey guys, I'm looking for some info on how the battery charging system works on my 92 320
while plugged in at home.  50 amp line to the MH.  I have 3 new 8d batteries all connected
together.  Most info refers to a starting battery and house batts.  Also, how or what does the
boost switch do?
Thanks,
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: John44 on August 05, 2021, 06:00:26 am
The 3 8d's are the house batteries,in case your start batteries fail the boost switch adds the house batteries to the starter,let us know what batteries you have and what charger,will help answer your questions.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Twig on August 05, 2021, 07:29:16 am
When plugged in or on the generator ONLY the house batteries will charge. Turn on the boost and all the batteries are combined so even the start batteries will charge. When the engine is running ALL batteries are charging whether the boost is on or not.

With the boost switch on, ALL batteries will discharge as well without hookups or generator on. That's why the boost switch is illuminated. A reminder.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Michelle on August 05, 2021, 08:42:25 am

With the boost switch on, ALL batteries will discharge as well without hookups or generator on. That's why the boost switch is illuminated. A reminder.

Yes - definitely don't leave boost on unattended.  It's intended to help start the coach if the chassis batteries go low by linking in the house batteries, but things can go south if you forget about it and lose shore power.  Most OEM ones aren't rated for continuous duty, either.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 08:55:18 am
Hey guys, I'm looking for some info...
You should find a 12V wiring diagram B-2126 included with the coach manuals and paperwork.  If not, refer to the diagram linked below.

Note (on the diagram) how the ENG (start) batteries and the COACH batteries are wired.  They are on separate circuits, EXCEPT when the BOOST switch is activated, as explained in the comments above.

The INVERTER/CONVERTER is connected to the COACH batteries.  When plugged into shore power (or generator running) it can charge the ENG batteries only when the BOOST switch is ON.

IN the bottom left corner of the diagram, there is the notation ISOLATOR BOARD with an arrow.  Right where the arrow points you will see the notation "TO ALT".  This is where the engine driven alternator ties into this diagram.  It charges both sets of batteries through the ISOLATOR.

You have been on this Forum since 2018 but are just now wondering how your charging system works?  You must have been very fortunate to not have any questions come up before now.  Most new-to-Foretravel owners are totally mystified by the electrical system right from the very first day of ownership.

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=media;sa=media;in=4746

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Twig on August 05, 2021, 09:12:20 am
The INVERTER/CONVERTER is connected to the COACH batteries.  When plugged into shore power (or generator running) it can only charge the ENG batteries (unless the BOOST switch is ON).
I believe he means the COACH batteries. The start battery charges only if the engine is running or the boost switch is on.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 09:16:34 am
I believe he means the COACH batteries.
Thanx Twig!  My proof reader (ME) failed to catch that error.

I corrected my post.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 09:32:28 am
I was somewhat confused by the OP's first post.  Three 8D batteries all connected together?  Is he talking about the COACH batteries?

Looking back through the OP's post history, I see he started a long thread in 2018 (link below) where we all (myself included) tried to figure out how his battery system was configured.  I THINK we finally concluded that he only has three 8D batteries in total, and that they somehow serve as both start and coach batteries.  I don't think we ever saw a photo of the actual battery cable arrangement, so I (for one) was never clear on how his coach is wired.

Batteries etc. (https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=37519)

Now he is saying all three batteries are connected together.  How does that work?  Does he even have a isolator, or do both the inverter/converter and the alternator connect directly to the single battery bank?  If that is the case, then the BOOST switch would serve no purpose.  All 3 batteries would be charged from any available charging source.

One of our members, P. Wyatt Sabourin, has run his coach for years with a single combined battery bank.  If he sees this thread perhaps he will review for us how his charging system works.  Batteries (https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=38101.msg369345#msg369345)

It may be that my comments, and indeed ALL of the comments above, do not actually apply to Yurre's "unique" battery setup.

But we still need to figure out how his charging system is configured...

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: John44 on August 05, 2021, 09:56:29 am
Think now's the time to wait for Mr. Yurre to answer.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 05:19:43 pm
Thanks for the replies.  I have been in CE class all day.  What a nightmare.
I'll try to upload a picture of the battery bay.  If there is a separate starting battery, I don't
know where it hides.
Chuck and Jeannie, After I got the MH a friend of mine needed it to live in for a year and half .
So I am just now going through it and getting it ready for a trip to Sheboygan
this fall-maybe.
The owners manual and online info has only confused me more and you guys are so much more helpful.
Y
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: oldguy on August 05, 2021, 05:21:48 pm
You should have a start battery near the engine.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: kb0zke on August 05, 2021, 05:27:48 pm
There must be some big differences between a 1992 U300 and a 1993 U300. I have two 8D batteries in parallel on the driver's side just aft of the rear tires. Those are the house (coach) batteries. I have three normal-size batteries, also in parallel, in the engine compartment. Those three start the Detroit.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 05:28:36 pm
Chuck and Jeannie, After I got the MH a friend of mine needed it to live in for a year and half.
So I am just now going through it...
OK, that explains your silence for the past 2 years.  Sounds like you are a good friend of your friend.  ^.^d

A photo of your battery compartment that clearly shows the battery cable routing would be a BIG help.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 05:31:24 pm
I (once again) refer all interested parties to the thread from 2018 where we (the Forum members) tried to understand the strange battery setup in this coach.  See Reply #7 up above.

Batteries etc. (https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=37519)

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 05:33:07 pm
Battery bay
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 05:35:32 pm
inverter
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 05:42:12 pm
Might as well start out by using the correct terminology.  The PD9180 is not a inverter - it is a convertor/charger.  See description linked below:

PD9180A - 80 Amp Electronic Power Converter - Progressive Dynamics (https://www.progressivedyn.com/rv/power-converters/pd9100-series-rv-power-converters/pd9180a-80-amp-electronic-power-converter/)

If you DO have a inverter on your coach, it is located in another place.  It might possibly look like the Taytronics pictured below (in the storage bay under the entry steps):




Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Doug W. on August 05, 2021, 05:46:31 pm
1992 Unihomes and earlier had one battery bay. One of those 8d batteries is the start battery. Someone may have tied them altogether by the looks of the red jumper cable. Do all have equal voltage?
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 05:55:06 pm
1992 Unihomes and earlier had one battery bay. One of those 8d batteries is the start battery. Someone may have tied them together by the looks of the red jumper cable.
That is the conclusion we came to back in 2018.  The questions are:
1.  Why?
2.  What other "modifications" were made to the battery and charging systems?

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Doug W. on August 05, 2021, 06:00:22 pm
That is the conclusion we came to back in 2018.  The questions are:
1.  Why?
2.  What other "modifications" were made to the battery and charging systems?

#1 easy to keep start battery charged when plugged into shore power/ larger battery bank.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 06:09:11 pm
Hey guys, I'm looking for some info on how the battery charging system works on my 92 320
while plugged in at home.  50 amp line to the MH.  I have 3 new 8d batteries all connected
together.
So now, having seen your two photos, I can tell you my opinion of how your charging system should work while plugged in at home.

You have three batteries, all connected together.  The PD9180 has two functions.  It is a battery charger, and it is a 12 volt power supply.  It must be plugged into (or hard wired to) a 110V power source to function.

IF your PD9180 is connected to a 110V outlet, and IF it is connected to one of the 3 batteries, and IF the coach is plugged into 50 amp shore power, then all three batteries should receive a charging current.

The PD9180 in base configuration is a "dumb" battery charger.  It may not provide the optimal charge rate for your new batteries.  There is a optional add-on module called a Charge Wizard that will upgrade the PD9180 to a "smart" battery charger.  If you do not already have this module added to your converter/charger, it would be highly recommended.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 06:18:53 pm
1992 Unihomes and earlier had one battery bay. One of those 8d batteries is the start battery. Someone may have tied them altogether by the looks of the red jumper cable. Do all have equal voltage?
Yes they do.  And they are new.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 06:20:05 pm
So now, having seen your two photos, I can tell you my opinion of how your charging system should work while plugged in at home.

You have three batteries, all connected together.  The PD9180 has two functions.  It is a battery charger, and it is a 12 volt power supply.  It must be plugged into (or hard wired to) a 110V power source to function.

IF your PD9180 is connected to a 110V outlet, and IF it is connected to one of the 3 batteries, and IF the coach is plugged into 50 amp shore power, then all three batteries should receive a charging current.

The PD9180 in base configuration is a "dumb" battery charger.  It may not provide the optimal charge rate for your new batteries.  There is a optional add-on module called a Charge Wizard that will upgrade the PD9180 to a "smart" battery charger.  If you do not already have this module added to your converter/charger, it would be highly recommended.


Cool, where would I get this upgrade module?
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 06:23:45 pm
Cool, where would I get this upgrade module?
Shop around online for the best price.

Charge Wizard PD9105 RV Battery Chargers (https://www.progressivedyn.com/rv/charge-wizard/pd9105-tcms-charge-wizard/)

Amazon.com: Progressive Dynamics PD9105V TCMS Charge Wizard: Automotive (https://www.amazon.com/Progressive-Dynamics-PD9105V-Charge-Wizard/dp/B002OR41UM)

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 05, 2021, 06:33:42 pm
Might as well start out by using the correct terminology.  The PD9180 is not a inverter - it is a convertor/charger.  See description linked below:

PD9180A - 80 Amp Electronic Power Converter - Progressive Dynamics (https://www.progressivedyn.com/rv/power-converters/pd9100-series-rv-power-converters/pd9180a-80-amp-electronic-power-converter/)

If you DO have a inverter on your coach, it is located in another place.  It might possibly look like the Taytronics pictured below (in the storage bay under the entry steps):





yes I have the inverter in the bay with the compressor
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 05, 2021, 07:29:43 pm
I just replaced our converter/charger with the Progressive Dynamics 45 amp model. Amazon.com: Progressive Dynamics PD9245CV Inteli-Power 9200 Series Converter/... (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000GANZZ6/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1). It does come with the Charge Wizard pendent linked to on Chuck's post above. I've never been able to keep the charge voltage at the 13.2 volts float voltage with the old WFCO model. The solar controller worked OK but since it is off at night, the voltage really varies. I didn't need even 45 amps as the solar controller keeps the batteries charged rapidly each morning.

The Progressive Dynamics converter/chargers get outstanding reviews and since the house batteries would be expensive to replace, I used the Foretravel link for Amazon to make the purchase.

If you do the installation hot, it's easy to get a lot of sparks when you use the Allen wrench to install the cables into the converter. I ordered a battery switch at the same time, made a couple of cables for the in and out of the switch and then used the handy dandy hydraulic crimper to install the copper lugs. I was then able to shut off the + supply to the new converter when I installed the new cables.

The only down side is the Charge Wizard's phone cable is way too short to reach up into the coach. Read the Amazon specs on the converter and the reviews. They give a good user experience.

I use a coiled cable to run between the two lighter plugs to keep the voltage up on the engine batteries. You can see the readings for the coach AGM on the top LED and the three conventional engine batteries. Each lighter plug is fused and each end of the plugs has a 5 amp fuse so there is no danger of a fire. I unplug while traveling but if staying at any campsite, I plug both back in again.

The unit seems quite bright and charges at several float voltages before settling down at close to the advertised 13.2v. It does give a conditioning charge of 14.4v for 15 minutes once a day.

Now I have the old converter for a battery charger in the garage.

About $200 delivered for both the converter and the 12V switch. Be sure to use the Amazon link provided on the forum page.

Again, top voltage is coach, bottom is engine batteries. It's been a week or so and the voltages are stable.

Pierce
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 05, 2021, 07:35:26 pm
I have the inverter in the bay with the compressor.
The INVERTER uses battery power to provide 110V power to the coach when it is not plugged into shore power or when the generator is not running.  When using the inverter, you must monitor the voltage on your "combined" battery bank so that it does not drop too low.

The biggest problem with having all three of your batteries tied together is that it is possible for them to be depleted to a point where you cannot start the big engine or the generator.  To avoid this situation, your coach was originally equipped with the battery isolator which separated the two battery circuits.

It is not "wrong" to have all three batteries tied together, but it requires additional vigilance on the part of the owner.  If your coach will be plugged into shore power most of the time, it probably won't be a problem.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: red tractor on August 05, 2021, 08:34:02 pm
That coach originally had 2 house batteries 8D and 1 engine battery 8D in the same compartment. Someone apparently tied them all together. Not a good idea as that is a single bank so if one goes down they will all be down. I would figure out how it was originally wired and then correct the wiring. There should be a battery isolator located on the frame behind the left rear wheel accessible through the small door behind the left rear wheel.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 05, 2021, 11:34:45 pm
Too bad the forum is B&W or you could see my red face.

Pierce
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 06, 2021, 07:10:09 am
The INVERTER uses battery power to provide 110V power to the coach when it is not plugged into shore power or when the generator is not running.  When using the inverter, you must monitor the voltage on your "combined" battery bank so that it does not drop too low.

The biggest problem with having all three of your batteries tied together is that it is possible for them to be depleted to a point where you cannot start the big engine or the generator.  To avoid this situation, your coach was originally equipped with the battery isolator which separated the two battery circuits.

It is not "wrong" to have all three batteries tied together, but it requires additional vigilance on the part of the owner.  If your coach will be plugged into shore power most of the time, it probably won't be a problem.


I got ya.  So in reality the inverter would be seldom used maybe for lights in an emergency.
Good information and thank you!
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 06, 2021, 07:12:35 am
That coach originally had 2 house batteries 8D and 1 engine battery 8D in the same compartment. Someone apparently tied them all together. Not a good idea as that is a single bank so if one goes down they will all be down. I would figure out how it was originally wired and then correct the wiring. There should be a battery isolator located on the frame behind the left rear wheel accessible through the small door behind the left rear wheel.
I am with you RT.  Better to have a starting battery in worst case.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 06, 2021, 09:02:14 am
So in reality the inverter would be seldom used maybe for lights in an emergency.
Actually, in our era coaches, the original modified sine wave inverter was used to power quite a few devices.

In our coach, the original Taytronics control panel switched between two circuits.  One circuit powered the microwave plug-in receptacle - the other powered the ice maker, TVs, VCR, chandelier, (optional) Gaggeneau gas burner ignitors, (optional) blender, plus one inside and one outside duplex outlet.  The control panel allowed the owner to choose which circuit they wanted to use.  See photo below:

In the 110V electrical circuit diagram linked below, see under the NOTES notation #3:

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=media;sa=item;in=3266#viewitem

Back in the day, modified sine wave inverters worked OK, although on our coach the Taytronics never seemed very "happy" running the OEM microwave.  If you plan to power any "sensitive" electronic devices with the inverter, you might consider an upgrade to a pure sine wave model.  See below for more general info:

What is a Sine Wave Inverter? – The Inverter Store (https://theinverterstore.com/portfolio-items/what-is-a-sine-wave-inverter/)

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: hcharlson on August 06, 2021, 10:09:56 am
On my 1992 U280 the start battery is on the left and the coach batteries are on the right as viewed from the picture you posted.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 06, 2021, 10:44:02 am
I removed the OEM Taytronics MSW inverter a few months ago and installed my old Trace inverter and a new pure sine wave inverter. I did have to modify the wiring at the changeover box because of the Taytronics switch. Saying that because you can't just install a new inverter where the old one was and have it work correctly.

The OEM inverter worked flawlessly since the coach was built but used a lot of juice at idle. As soon as it was powered on, the voltmeter took a dive. The new sine wave inverter goes just to the microwave and the big wall TV with the Trace powering everything else. Both are much more efficient. The Trace surprisingly so since I purchased it in 1989. It pulses ever second to see if anything is on and then turns itself on. Even when on. it does not draw much current. I still have more wiring to do.

REMOTE SWITCH FOR INVERTERS WITHOUT A PORT: If you buy or have most any inverter without a remote switch, I found a trick to run a telephone type wire and turn the inverter on or off from most anywhere in the coach. It even works on the '89 Trace inverter. Your inverter does NOT have to have a port for a plug but you will need to pull the cover to connect a set of wires to the on/off switch. I can post a DIY for inverters without a port for a remote switch. With a port, it's a no brainer plug and play.

Pierce
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 06, 2021, 11:04:34 am
I removed the OEM Taytronics MSW inverter a few months ago and installed my old Trace inverter and a new pure sine wave inverter. I did have to modify the wiring at the changeover box because of the Taytronics switch. Saying that because you can't just install a new inverter where the old one was and have it work correctly.

The OEM inverter worked flawlessly since the coach was built but used a lot of juice at idle. As soon as it was powered on, the voltmeter took a dive. The new sine wave inverter goes just to the microwave and the big wall TV with the Trace powering everything else. Both are much more efficient. The Trace surprisingly so since I purchased it in 1989. It pulses ever second to see if anything is on and then turns itself on. Even when on. it does not draw much current. I still have more wiring to do.

REMOTE SWITCH FOR INVERTERS WITHOUT A PORT: If you buy or have most any inverter without a remote switch, I found a trick to run a telephone type wire and turn the inverter on or off from most anywhere in the coach. It even works on the '89 Trace inverter. Your inverter does NOT have to have a port for a plug but you will need to pull the cover to connect a set of wires to the on/off switch. I can post a DIY for inverters without a port for a remote switch. With a port, it's a no brainer plug and play.

Pierce

What size inverter should I look for?
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: wolfe10 on August 06, 2021, 11:26:02 am
What size inverter should I look for?

Depends on:

What you want to be able to run (120 VAC appliance).

Size, state of charge and condition of your battery bank. Discharging below 50% SOC (State Of Charge) materially shortens battery life.

And, the inverter can not be realistically used to run high-amp loads like roof A/C.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Twig on August 06, 2021, 11:48:04 am
Do a search on P. Wyatt Sabourin for inverter information. He makes the most sense. And you will save money.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 06, 2021, 12:18:47 pm
With only a few exceptions, an updated RV with flat screen LED TV, LED lights, etc. will require less power today than when built. Old inverters used transformers and rectifiers, were very heavy and produced a modified sine wave that while working well for lights, most TVs, resistance heating, tools, etc. didn't work well for microwave ovens and other electronic items.

They do have an advantage in that a 1500 watt OEM Taytronics inverter will work better on something like a small compressor with a high startup load.

Having said that, it's best to purchase the largest pure sine wave inverter you can afford. But since many suppliers lie, it's mandatory to read all the reviews as found on Amazon and then pick the best for your requirements.

We are 36 feet long so no washer/dryer. Our TV is 50 inches but LED so not much draw there. All lighting is LED so again, low draw. We do have two Senco 110V compressors onboard that are used to air tires and run impacts and staple guns as an example. Either the 1500 watt MSW (modified sine wave) Trace or the new 1500 watt sine wave inverter will instantly start the compressors. The pure SW inverter cuts the MW time drastically so it not only cooks faster but much less inverter time at the high output is needed to get the food cooked. But, I had to run a couple of new Romex cables to feed the MW and TV from the new inverter plus telephone cable to turn both inverters on and off. We have a Norcold RV fridge so that is not a factor in power consumption.

I'm not a fan of the converter/inverter units as I don't like to put all the eggs in one basket plus on older Foretravels, the inverter and converter are on opposite sides of the coach and would require a major wiring change to fit one of these units.

So, like Brett says, don't plan on an inverter to be able to run even one roof AC unit. While deep discharge will shorten the life of your coach batteries, installation of solar panels on the roof will keep the discharge to a minimum and you will not longer have to run the generator except for AC. If you are handy, purchasing and installing 1200 watts of solar will not cost more than $1500 for everything. Plenty of room on the roof of your U300 for even more than that.

Read as much as you can about inverters, read the reviews plus you can see a lot of inverters in action on YouTube videos.

We have had inverters and solar starting back in 1989 and on our U300 since 2008. I have posts with the sources and prices back when I did the installation. Everything still works as installed 13 years later.

Pierce



Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 06, 2021, 01:09:02 pm
Thanks for all the info folks!
Today's project- new tranny oil cooler on my 97 F250 :(
Then back to the FT.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 06, 2021, 08:22:27 pm
Before you spend a bunch of money (and time and effort) replacing your old inverter, it would be a good idea to think about how you will use your coach.  With your coach in stock factory configuration, you will only NEED to use your inverter if you do not have a shore power hookup AND you do not want to run the generator.  How often will you be in that situation?

If, when traveling, you spend most or all nights at campgrounds with 30 or 50 amp shore power connections, then you won't need a new inverter.  If you tend to camp mostly in the HOT summer months, and you don't have shore power hookups, you will be running your generator to power the roof air conditioners.  In that case, you won't need to use the inverter.

The most likely time that you would want the inverter is when boondocking in cool weather conditions where the roof air is not needed.  THAT is when you will appreciate a good inverter, AND a large capacity battery bank.  Using the inverter to power ac loads avoids having to listen to the irritating (to you and other campers) racket made by the generator.  Of course, there is no free lunch.  If you deplete your batteries running the inverter, you will eventually need to recharge them.  If you are driving every day, you can let the alternator do the recharge work.  If camped in one spot for multiple days, you'll probably need to run the generator for several hours each day, but you can do it in the middle of the day when the noise will be less annoying to everyone.

Of course, as Pierce suggests, you can always add solar to supplement the generator, but that is another subject entirely.

All I'm saying is think about how you will use your coach, come up with a long-term plan, and then spend your upgrade money where it will do you the most good.


Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 07, 2021, 06:28:37 am
Before you spend a bunch of money (and time and effort) replacing your old inverter, it would be a good idea to think about how you will use your coach.  With your coach in stock factory configuration, you will only NEED to use your inverter if you do not have a shore power hookup AND you do not want to run the generator.  How often will you be in that situation?

If, when traveling, you spend most or all nights at campgrounds with 30 or 50 amp shore power connections, then you won't need a new inverter.  If you tend to camp mostly in the HOT summer months, and you don't have shore power hookups, you will be running your generator to power the roof air conditioners.  In that case, you won't need to use the inverter.

The most likely time that you would want the inverter is when boondocking in cool weather conditions where the roof air is not needed.  THAT is when you will appreciate a good inverter, AND a large capacity battery bank.  Using the inverter to power ac loads avoids having to listen to the irritating (to you and other campers) racket made by the generator.  Of course, there is no free lunch.  If you deplete your batteries running the inverter, you will eventually need to recharge them.  If you are driving every day, you can let the alternator do the recharge work.  If camped in one spot for multiple days, you'll probably need to run the generator for several hours each day, but you can do it in the middle of the day when the noise will be less annoying to everyone.

Of course, as Pierce suggests, you can always add solar to supplement the generator, but that is another subject entirely.

All I'm saying is think about how you will use your coach, come up with a long-term plan, and then spend your upgrade money where it will do you the most good.



Very good points.  I will stick with my stock inverter for now.
Thanks for the words of wisdom...
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: len.barron on August 07, 2021, 10:08:57 am
Many of the good modern inverters also have a built in multi-stage battery charger. If you are considering upgrading the existing converter/charger (which you should do because they are battery cookers) and are also wanting a pure sine wave inverter (many modern electronics require that) then you have the option of replacing those two units with a single inverter/charger...I have one and it works perfectly...this is my third project vehicle that I've used AIMS inverter chargers on and haven't had a single failure..
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 08, 2021, 08:33:00 am
Many of the good modern inverters also have a built in multi-stage battery charger. If you are considering upgrading the existing converter/charger (which you should do because they are battery cookers) and are also wanting a pure sine wave inverter (many modern electronics require that) then you have the option of replacing those two units with a single inverter/charger...I have one and it works perfectly...this is my third project vehicle that I've used AIMS inverter chargers on and haven't had a single failure..
Nice installation.  Was it hard to combine all wiring into one location? Or did you have to?
Or should I maybe just replace the converter charger.  I did order a smart
charge adapter add on suggested by another member.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 08, 2021, 09:22:41 am
I did order a smart charge adapter...
Wait until you get the Charge Wizard - try it - see how it works.  The charger you have will probably work just fine.

Are your 3 new batteries AGM or are they traditional "flooded" wet cells (the kind with removable caps so you can add water)?

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 08, 2021, 12:22:27 pm
Wait until you get the Charge Wizard - try it - see how it works.  The charger you have will probably work just fine.

Are your 3 new batteries AGM or are they traditional "flooded" wet cells (the kind with removable caps so you can add water)?


They are old style flooded with removable caps.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Doug W. on August 08, 2021, 12:36:01 pm
They are old style flooded with removable caps.

Your coach came originally with a battery box, the lower portion in your picture has deteriorated somewhat. Do you still have the top section? When covered the top portion has a vent hole which a 2" pipe  attaches to vent wet cell batteries. Pretty easy to rebuild bottom section with fiberglass but will have to be taken out to repair.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 08, 2021, 01:14:05 pm
Your coach came originally with a battery box, the lower portion in your picture has deteriorated somewhat. Do you still have the top section? When covered the top portion has a vent hole which a 2" pipe  attaches to vent wet cell batteries. Pretty easy to rebuild bottom section with fiberglass but will have to be taken out to repair.
Yes I do have the cover intact.  The bottom is a little better that it looks.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: len.barron on August 08, 2021, 02:47:13 pm
Was it hard to combine all wiring into one location? Or did you have to?

No rewiring required, I simply removed the converter/charger completely. Plugged the new inverter in where the old charger used to plug in. Removed old inverter and used that same wiring for the new one.  The one bit of rewiring I did do was to put the refrigerator on one of the circuits that the inverter supplies (I have no idea why Foretravel didn't do that) as I always use the inverter to run my fridge while driving (unless I have the generator fired up to run roof air cond.).
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Jack Lewis on August 08, 2021, 11:10:05 pm
.......The one bit of rewiring I did do was to put the refrigerator on one of the circuits that the inverter supplies (I have no idea why Foretravel didn't do that) as I always use the inverter to run my fridge while driving (unless I have the generator fired up to run roof air cond.).


If FT did not put the 110v supply to the refrigerator thru the inverter on your 1988, it would have been to save the batteries from unnecessary drain.  My 1997 original refrigerator compartment had two 110v plug outlets, one wired thru the inverter and one not,  so I had a choice.  This of course applied to my Norcold, before I installed my current residential refrigerator. I connected my current residential refrigerator to the available inverter 110v outlet.  Another consideration might have been that in 1988 few rvs charged the house batteries while driving, they only charged the chassis batteries as you drove down the road.

In today's world, with higher propane cost per gallon, with more available ah house battery systems, and the many option choices we now have to charge our batteries, posibly this is no longer a necessity. 
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 08, 2021, 11:45:40 pm
Driving down the road, the Norcold is on propane but when we stop at a camp site, I turn on the inverter and push the fridge mode button to AC. At night when we turn the inverter off, it auto switches back to propane. Turning on the inverter auto switches the the fridge supply 110V outlet to be hot if not plugged into shore power.

Propane at the house ranges from $.95 to $2.00 a gallon depending on the season and the market. Since we have a Suburban Propane account, we can stop at one of their locations and get the association price. Love having the choice between the two energy sources.

Pierce
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 09, 2021, 08:39:06 am
They are old style flooded with removable caps.
Your PD9180, after you add the Charge Wizard pendant, should work great with those batteries.  It will have a charging profile that is well suited to the flooded wet cells.  See page linked below.

Charge Wizard, 4-Stage Battery Charging System (https://www.progressivedyn.com/rv/charge-wizard/)

It is imperative that you regularly check the electrolyte level in the batteries.  If you let them run dry it will ruin them.  Period.  See the excerpt below from the Trojan Battery web page:

Flooded batteries need water.

More importantly, watering must be done at the right time and in the right amount or the battery's performance and longevity suffers.

Water should always be added after fully charging the battery. Prior to charging, there should be enough water to cover the plates. If the battery has been discharged (partially or fully), the water level should also be above the plates. Keeping the water at the correct level after a full charge will prevent having to worry about the water level at a different state of charge.

Depending on the local climate, charging methods, application, etc., Trojan recommends that batteries be checked once a month until you get a feel for how often your batteries need watering.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on August 09, 2021, 10:40:58 am
You have to check to see if you have removable caps or two flat plates that would have to be pried off. The only others in most common use are AGM and GEL batteries and they will have that written on the side. Most cars come with "maintenance free" batteries and don't need to we watered. Here is a quote:

Non-maintenance-free batteries (also called a "wet-cell" battery) are easily identified by the removable filler caps on the top of the battery. Battery fluid in NMF batteries needs to be regularly checked and topped off. Non-maintenance-free batteries come with six individual fill caps or two caps covering three cells each.

Maintenance-free batteries are also easily identifiable because they do not have filler caps. A large, plain unremovable flat cover encases the battery housing and may be labeled with the words "Maintenance Free." Today, virtually all new cars come standard with maintenance-free batteries. While maintenance-free batteries do not need to be topped off, you may still want to test your battery from time to time to ensure good performance.


Our U300 has three 31 series conventional batteries that are maintenance free. I never check them and they should last 8 to 12 years if kept charged. Our six house batteries are AGM type and are also maintenance free. I also never check these. They are about 13 years old and work as well as when installed.

I do check the connections and battery posts on the engine batteries to make sure there is no corrosion a couple times a year.

Do I Need to Top Off My Battery Fluid? | The Family Handyman (https://www.familyhandyman.com/article/top-off-battery-fluid/)

Pierce
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on August 09, 2021, 12:12:11 pm
You have to check to see if you have removable caps or two flat plates that would have to be pried off.
Yurre said (Reply #44):  "They are old style flooded with removable caps."


Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Barry & Cindy on August 09, 2021, 01:59:12 pm
Additional clarification:

Most "Maintenance Free" batteries have removable flat cell covers that try to recycle any evaporation and can be checked for proper water level.

All "AGM" & "GEL" are Sealed and cannot be opened. In fact, opening them will destroy internal pressure required for them to work.
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Protech Racing on August 09, 2021, 02:07:40 pm
 The pic shows the grounds connected. The red cable connects the outer positives but the center positive fades into the solenoid area. All 3 may not be linked . IMHO
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on August 09, 2021, 03:03:00 pm
The pic shows the grounds connected. The red cable connects the outer positives but the center positive fades into the solenoid area. All 3 may not be linked . IMHO
Good pick up Mike, I'll have to investigate further. 
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on September 28, 2021, 02:07:19 pm
Good pick up Mike, I'll have to investigate further. 
The pic shows the grounds connected. The red cable connects the outer positives but the center positive fades into the solenoid area. All 3 may not be linked . IMHO

Mike et al,
Well after all, it appears that the center battery is not connected to the other two.  On finding the coach with low power
for cranking, I tested the middle 8d and it was low.  I guess the middle battery is the start battery.
The booster enabled me to crank the engine.
So does the booster need to be on to charge that 3rd battery?  I now have the charge wizard connected and  I am connected to shore power.  What is the draw back to this setup?  Should I convert back to the original?
 Thanks in advance.  Y

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on September 28, 2021, 03:14:51 pm
I guess the middle battery is the start battery.
The booster enabled me to crank the engine.
So does the booster need to be on to charge that 3rd battery?
Normally, the answer would be YES.  However, we don't know if (or how) the wiring has been altered (modified) on your coach.

In stock configuration, the BOOST switch activates a solenoid that connects the Start (chassis) battery to the Coach (house) batteries.

In stock configuration, the factory installed battery charger is only directly connected to the Coach (house) batteries.

In stock configuration, the BOOST switch must be ON if you want the factory installed battery charger to charge the Start battery.

In stock configuration, all three batteries should charged by the alternator, through the battery isolator, when the big engine is running.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on September 28, 2021, 03:39:08 pm
Normally, the answer would be YES.  However, we don't know if (or how) the wiring has been altered (modified) on your coach.

In stock configuration, the BOOST switch activates a solenoid that connects the Start (chassis) battery to the Coach (house) batteries.

In stock configuration, the factory installed battery charger is only directly connected to the Coach (house) batteries.

In stock configuration, the BOOST switch must be ON if you want the factory installed battery charge to charge the Start battery.

In stock configuration, BOTH battery sets should charged by the alternator, through the battery isolator, when the big engine is running.


I got ya. 
Well I turned on the boost and the 'start' battery shows a charge voltage.
I'll let it go for a while and see if it is taking the charge.  Also, what does the off/on switch at the door effect as far as battery usage?  Is it ok to leave it on while connected to shore power and not occupied?  Which batteries does it turn off/on?
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on September 28, 2021, 03:47:56 pm
...what does the off/on switch at the door effect as far as battery usage?  Is it ok to leave it on while connected to shore power and not occupied?  Which batteries does it turn off/on?
The switch at the door is called the "Salesman Switch".  It is powered by the Coach (house) batteries.

Why is it called the Salesman Switch?  I was told:  When a coach is For Sale - sitting on a dealer lot - it makes a better impression on potential buyers to step into a brightly lite coach.  The salesman would turn on all the interior lights, then (to conserve battery power) turn OFF the Salesman Switch when he exited the coach.  Later, when he takes the customers to look inside the coach, he opens the door and cuts on the switch.  Voila!  Customers enter a bright cheerful coach.

Leaving the Salesman Switch on all the time is no problem.  The one on our coach has not been turned off in over 7 years.

The Salesman Switch occasionally gets turned off accidentally, by kids or pets or careless owners.  Causes considerable consternation until discovered.

You have to refer to the B-2126 Automotive Wiring Diagram for your coach to find out exactly what is controlled by the Salesman Switch.  It typically cuts power to such things as interior lights, storage bay lights, the water pump, some items on the dash, etc.

Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: P. Wyatt Sabourin on September 28, 2021, 06:00:28 pm
I just noticed this thread and found it quite interesting.
I do have three 8D AGM batteries connected together in one battery bank for "start" and "coach" needs.
I also have 1460 watts of solar with an 80amp Outback Solar Controller so the batteries are kept charged most of the time.
The M11 engine cranks faster with three 8D deep cycle batteries than with the OEM three size 24 start batteries. Eleven years with this Foretravel and six years with the previous coach, a boost was required to start the big engine on two occasions. This has not happened for circa 8 years because there is an amp hour meter on each battery and I monitor them frequently.
I have a Xantrex pure sign 1800 watt inverter and a separate Iota 55 amp dual voltage converter. Iota has a four stage smart charger module which does not work well because the voltages available for charging are 14 volts and 13.4 volts, not the 14.2 and 13.6 volts that Iota claims. Perhaps my Iota converter is too old to work with their smart charge module. I only use the converter when plugged into shore power on cloudy days or at night.
 
It seems that a Progressive Dynamics converter does become a battery charger with addition of their smart charger module.

For those of you interested in knowing the difference between a Battery Charger and a Converter, it is voltage/amperage control. A Converter provides current at a single fixed voltage (typically circa 13.5 volts) while a Battery Charger will provide current at 13.6 volts, 14.6 volts, or a voltage between 13.6 and 14.6 depending on the state of charge of the battery. Many Battery Chargers can also equalize at circa 15.6 volts when needed.



Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Yurre on September 29, 2021, 07:21:41 am
The switch at the door is called the "Salesman Switch".  It is powered by the Coach (house) batteries.

Why is it called the Salesman Switch?  I was told:  When a coach is For Sale - sitting on a dealer lot - it makes a better impression on potential buyers to step into a brightly lite coach.  The salesman would turn on all the interior lights, then (to conserve battery power) turn OFF the Salesman Switch when he exited the coach.  Later, when he takes the customers to look inside the coach, he opens the door and cuts on the switch.  Voila!  Customers enter a bright cheerful coach.

Leaving the Salesman Switch on all the time is no problem.  The one on our coach has not been turned off in over 7 years.

The Salesman Switch occasionally gets turned off accidentally, by kids or pets or careless owners.  Causes considerable consternation until discovered.

You have to refer to the B-2126 Automotive Wiring Diagram for your coach to find out exactly what is controlled by the Salesman Switch.  It typically cuts power to such things as interior lights, storage bay lights, the water pump, some items on the dash, etc.


Chuck,
according to the Diagram, I am supposed to have 3 start batteries and 3 coach batteries.
Not sure where they would all go.  Anyway, just trying to figure out a way to maintain these new $700 8d's
and not do any damage to the coach!  Also, is there a way to monitor or test each battery without having to
disconnect the heavy terminal lines.  They are also in the way of some of the water caps.  I think I need to rework
this whole thing.  Thanks for your input.  Y
Title: Re: Battery charging
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on September 29, 2021, 08:32:43 am
1.  According to the Diagram, I am supposed to have 3 start batteries and 3 coach batteries.
2.  Not sure where they would all go.
3.  Is there a way to monitor or test each battery without having to disconnect the heavy terminal lines.  They are in the way of some of the water caps.
1.  Foretravel often made running changes to how they built different models, so what a wiring diagram shows may not always match what you actually have in your coach.

2.  Other members (earlier in this thread) told you how their U300 has the engine start batteries mounted in the engine bay behind the engine.  If your coach had the same arrangement, you would have room for 3 start batteries and 3 house batteries.

3.  No way that I know of...unless you added a separate battery disconnect switch for each battery.  Don't be afraid to move the big battery cables around to make your watering chores easier.