Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Tech Talk => Topic started by: Chip7 on November 23, 2021, 03:05:32 pm
Title: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on November 23, 2021, 03:05:32 pm
I've searched and read most every thread on the board about the front cap movement and windshield movement, but I feel as though I'm missing something.
Under nominal twist situations, my windshield can shift up to two inches out of alignment at the bottom (popping out of the gasket). The shift is always in the same direction - moving outward on the drivers side, and toward the inside on the passenger. The shift has NEVER occurred the other direction.
If on reasonably level ground, I can manipulate the airbags and tilt the coach back and forth to bring it gradually back into alignment (only to drive it and have it pop back out after pulling into a rutted truck stop or similar).
The shifting was previously accompanied by creaking noises of the dash plywood slipping over the inner surface of the front cap. I resolved that by getting things lined up and used West Marine Six10 to re-attach the two. There is now ZERO movement between the dash and the front cap. The windshield shifting reduced slightly, but is still significant.
I understand some movement is expected in this design, but the amount I'm getting can't be normal. I also do not think that a new gasket would do much for the problem (perhaps a very small amount of improvement, but not a real resolution). I'm concerned about using windshield adhesive in the gasket since that may move the stress more into the glass itself causing a bigger issue.
Any additional things to check or ideas?
Thanks!
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on November 23, 2021, 03:32:08 pm
I've searched and read most every thread on the board about the front cap movement and windshield movement, but I feel as though I'm missing something.
Under nominal twist situations, my windshield can shift up to two inches out of alignment at the bottom (popping out of the gasket). The shift is always in the same direction - moving outward on the drivers side, and toward the inside on the passenger. The shift has NEVER occurred the other direction.
If on reasonably level ground, I can manipulate the airbags and tilt the coach back and forth to bring it gradually back into alignment (only to drive it and have it pop back out after pulling into a rutted truck stop or similar).
The shifting was previously accompanied by creaking noises of the dash plywood slipping over the inner surface of the front cap. I resolved that by getting things lined up and used West Marine Six10 to re-attach the two. There is now ZERO movement between the dash and the front cap. The windshield shifting reduced slightly, but is still significant. I understand some movement is expected in this design, but the amount I'm getting can't be normal. I also do not think that a new gasket would do much for the problem (perhaps a very small amount of improvement, but not a real resolution). I'm concerned about using windshield adhesive in the gasket since that may move the stress more into the glass itself causing a bigger issue. Any additional things to check or ideas? Thanks!
No steel in the front 9 feet other than the suspension is the reason. Our U300's glass moves and I have to push it back into place probably once a year. The front really creaks and groans over uneven ground. Not too much you can do. I'm afraid to glue it as it may break.
Pierce
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on November 23, 2021, 03:51:48 pm
Thanks Pierce - about how much movement do you experience? Does it always move the same way for you too? Mine seems to have gotten worse over the past year, then seemed to improve a small amount after re-attaching the dash to the front cap.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2021, 04:07:58 pm
Have you verified that the front fiberglass to wood blocks (look up from the two front small "doors") are still a solid connection.
Particularly if used in areas with a lot of condensation, water condenses on the windshield and runs down into the wood, eventually rotting it.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on November 23, 2021, 04:31:57 pm
Ours moves too, but has never popped completely out of the frame (at least since we have owned it). It's the nature of the beast. I try my darnedest to avoid driving over the typical places that cause the movement. If I can't avoid it, then I go REAL SLOW, and try to minimize the abuse. I hate it when our old coach makes the groaning noises...like it is in agony. :'(
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on November 23, 2021, 04:52:34 pm
Thanks Pierce - about how much movement do you experience? Does it always move the same way for you too? Mine seems to have gotten worse over the past year, then seemed to improve a small amount after re-attaching the dash to the front cap.
For us, it's the driver's side that moves. About an inch, just enough to let air in. Our driveway goes up like a roller coaster with several turns. I do like Chuck says, take it slowly and listen to the terrible noises.
Pierce
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: nitehawk on November 23, 2021, 05:05:57 pm
Wow!! You guys should have an old coach like our '89. No creaks. No groans. No shifting windshield(s). Nothing but pure boredom when going across unlevel terrain. And our chassis frame was designed by farm equipment designers (John Deere) and built by a firm that built garbage trucks and then military vehicles (Oshkosh Truck). Couldn't ask for any better.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: wolfe10 on November 23, 2021, 05:13:38 pm
And, another variable may be body width-- 96" vs 102'". Same torque applied to wider dimension= more movement.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 23, 2021, 05:28:29 pm
Wow!! You guys should have an old coach like our '89. No creaks. No groans. No shifting windshield(s). Nothing but pure boredom when going across unlevel terrain.
I think the "Ored" has a different sub frame...
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: FourTravelers on November 23, 2021, 05:56:12 pm
So.... the question I have is, what has happened to the front cap that has allowed all that movement? We had slight movement and a few noticeable squeaks until I reattached the underside of the dash to the front cap fiberglass with a seam of 3M adhesive. No more noticeable movement of the windshield. If the OP has done this too.... what else could be "unattached".? Possibly delamination on the sides below the driver passenger windows?
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on November 23, 2021, 06:23:17 pm
Have you verified that the front fiberglass to wood blocks (look up from the two front small "doors") are still a solid connection.
Particularly if used in areas with a lot of condensation, water condenses on the windshield and runs down into the wood, eventually rotting it.
I'll check underneath from the outside again tomorrow, but pretty sure my six10 repair has firmly tied the cap to the blocking and dash. I had a short area of soft wood on one side, but not bad at all compared to some of the photos I've seen in other posts (slightly soft, only two inches wide). I cleaned it up and injected some six10 to firm it up.
After the Six10, I have zero groaning, popping, or the like. Only the sound of the windshield gasket flexing as the glass moves.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 23, 2021, 08:48:49 pm
So.... the question I have is, what has happened to the front cap that has allowed all that movement? We had slight movement and a few noticeable squeaks until I reattached the underside of the dash to the front cap fiberglass with a seam of 3M adhesive. No more noticeable movement of the windshield. If the OP has done this too.... what else could be "unattached".? Possibly delamination on the sides below the driver passenger windows?
Yes, that is what happened to mine. I did the repair myself, I separated the cap where it is joined to the roof by removing the metal strip that covers the joint. I also removed the drivers sider fender, that allowed me to separate the fiberglass from the backing (the glue had already released) so I was able to open the area from the windshield down to the bottom of that panel about 3 to 5 inches. I applied coat of adhesive in as far as I could reach with a spatula/putty knife and also spayed 3M adhesive in the rest of the areas. I then put a 5' x 6' approx.. piece of cardboard against the area to protect the finish and on top of that I placed a 5' x 6' piece of 3/4" plywood, then I put a brace against the whole area to compress the laminate to the backing and allowed it to cure for about a week. This worked for me, I had my windshield reset last May in Lakeland Florida by Richard at Coach Glass and it has held so far. I think the adhesion between the laminate and the backing is a major part in the stability of the windshield. The drivers side of my coach is exposed to the Florida sun most of the winter months. I can see the difference from that side to the passenger side which is in the shade or does not get the direct sunlight/heat for extended periods of time. ^.^d
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: kb0zke on November 23, 2021, 09:16:26 pm
I've been told that the windshield on our Grand Villas is actually a structural member, so it needs to be properly connected to the rest of the nose. Yes, there needs to be a certain amount of flexibility there, but when the windshield moves that much there is something wrong.
In the summer of 2020 we had to drive up from The Ranch (near Carlsbad, NM) to Riverton, WY. That took us through Colorado, and the windshield suffered for it. I didn't realize that it was that far out until we went through the Blue Beacon in Cheyenne. I got a shower, too! Fortunately I was able to grab some towels and keep most of the water on the outside, but we couldn't leave the windshield that way. The next day we found a shop that promised to reseat the windshield. When we got there they said they didn't work on motorhomes (!), but fixed it anyway - no charge! Last summer we had MOT replace the gasket. MUCH quieter now.
The Foretravel will not visit Colorado again. When we leave here this summer our route will NOT take us through Colorado, even if we head right back to The Ranch.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Twig on November 23, 2021, 11:50:08 pm
On the corners of the driver and passenger SIDE windows are welded joints. If one or more of these welds has broken that is most likely your cause. Happened to me. They are aluminum frames so welding is tricky.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Bob & Sue on November 24, 2021, 01:46:55 am
It looks like a combination of things could contribute. The dash well secured to the front cap probably the most important.
On our drive home to Oregon with our new to us coach I noticed the drivers side cap ( below the side window) was moving around a bit. So that was one of the first things that I repaired. The repair was very similar to Gerry's fix only I used Gorrilla foam. Mixed with water it activates and boy is that stuff permanent. Or at least I hope so.
I also try to avoid twisting the coach or doing it very slowly if unavoidable. 0 window movement so far.....fingers crossed.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on November 24, 2021, 09:52:51 am
Yes, that is what happened to mine. I did the repair myself, I separated the cap where it is joined to the roof by removing the metal strip that covers the joint. I also removed the drivers sider fender, that allowed me to separate the fiberglass from the backing (the glue had already released) so I was able to open the area from the windshield down to the bottom of that panel about 3 to 5 inches. I applied coat of adhesive in as far as I could reach with a spatula/putty knife and also spayed 3M adhesive in the rest of the areas. I then put a 5' x 6' approx.. piece of cardboard against the area to protect the finish and on top of that I placed a 5' x 6' piece of 3/4" plywood, then I put a brace against the whole area to compress the laminate to the backing and allowed it to cure for about a week. This worked for me, I had my windshield reset last May in Lakeland Florida by Richard at Coach Glass and it has held so far. I think the adhesion between the laminate and the backing is a major part in the stability of the windshield. The drivers side of my coach is exposed to the Florida sun most of the winter months. I can see the difference from that side to the passenger side which is in the shade or does not get the direct sunlight/heat for extended periods of time. ^.^d
I checked this morning, and I've got significant delamination under the windows down to the wheel wells on both sides. It's not visible, and certainly wasn't this way before we did our year of travel last year. All the use may have contributed to the adhesive giving way and causing the windshield shift to worsen over time. I'm not certain of the repair approach that will be needed yet. I suppose the skin of the cap when properly fastened to the structure underneath yields a significant amount of stiffness.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on November 24, 2021, 09:54:26 am
I've been told that the windshield on our Grand Villas is actually a structural member, so it needs to be properly connected to the rest of the nose. Yes, there needs to be a certain amount of flexibility there, but when the windshield moves that much there is something wrong.
In the summer of 2020 we had to drive up from The Ranch (near Carlsbad, NM) to Riverton, WY. That took us through Colorado, and the windshield suffered for it. I didn't realize that it was that far out until we went through the Blue Beacon in Cheyenne. I got a shower, too! Fortunately I was able to grab some towels and keep most of the water on the outside, but we couldn't leave the windshield that way. The next day we found a shop that promised to reseat the windshield. When we got there they said they didn't work on motorhomes (!), but fixed it anyway - no charge! Last summer we had MOT replace the gasket. MUCH quieter now.
The Foretravel will not visit Colorado again. When we leave here this summer our route will NOT take us through Colorado, even if we head right back to The Ranch.
Our problem is that we LOVE Colorado adventures in our Foretravel :)
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Pierce & Gaylie Stewart on November 24, 2021, 10:15:09 am
While cars made today rely on the windshield as a structural member, I doubt very much if Foretravel's engineering thought much about making the glass a structural member. A large bird could come through the front cap and get you.
Colorado is great! While our Sierra's are an outstanding mountain chain, they are mostly inside of California and pretty narrow. The Rockies are huge in comparison, extending down just south of Santa Fe, NM to far up in Canada for a total of 3000 miles.
Wish we lived closer as that would be endless exploration. Almost frustrating and as a visitor. You could only see a small portion in a lifetime.
Pierce
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: nitehawk on November 24, 2021, 10:35:56 am
Moral of the windshield/Colorado story? If you are going to drive thru Colorado and other states with really bad roads? Get an ORED chassis Foretravel. >:D >:D >:D >:D :))
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 24, 2021, 10:47:48 am
I checked this morning, and I've got significant delamination under the windows down to the wheel wells on both sides. It's not visible, and certainly wasn't this way before we did our year of travel last year. All the use may have contributed to the adhesive giving way and causing the windshield shift to worsen over time. I'm not certain of the repair approach that will be needed yet. I suppose the skin of the cap when properly fastened to the structure underneath yields a significant amount of stiffness.
I would say that is the reason for your windshield movement. If you have the time and ability, using the same process that I did will help secure the windshield. The higher up you can get, (between the slide window and the rear cap edge) when regluing the more secure the cap will be. Also, I added some aluminum angle bracing where the floor meets the side between the headlight and the fender opening. I also added angle where the dash meets the front/nose above both access doors above the windshield wipers. After that was done is when I took it to have the windshield moved back into place at Coach Glass in Lakeland Florida..
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Hans&Marjet on November 24, 2021, 12:09:43 pm
I would say that is the reason for your windshield movement. If you have the time and ability, using the same process that I did will help secure the windshield. The higher up you can get, (between the slide window and the rear cap edge) when regluing the more secure the cap will be. Also, I added some aluminum angle bracing where the floor meets the side between the headlight and the fender opening. I also added angle where the dash meets the front/nose above both access doors above the windshield wipers. After that was done is when I took it to have the windshield moved back into place at Coach Glass in Lakeland Florida..
Gary...can you post afew photos of the aluminum bracing on the side of the coach....would like to add similar as I did my dash/nose a few years ago.
Thx
Hans
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Bob & Sue on November 24, 2021, 12:31:17 pm
+ 1 (What Hans said)
I have noticed that Foretravel installed a piece of vertical angle iron under the dash. It would join the sidewall to the firewall IF it was bolted or otherwise attached to the SIDEWALL which it isn't. It's only bolted to the front firewall. I think that if / when we have our decals painted on I will go ahead and bolt the sidewall to that angle
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on April 23, 2022, 07:18:03 pm
Bringing this post back up since the weather is warmer and I'm ready to attempt a repair. Starting on the driver's side. This joint looks gnarly and I'm going to clean it up, then get it reattached with some good adhesive. I'm thinking 3m 5200 for permanent fix? Surface prep will be challenging...
Not sure how far I can get the adhesive back in the the area below the window. I am considering some type of mechanical attachment in addition to the adhesive but haven't come up with a solid plan yet.
Any experience share with pictures would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on April 23, 2022, 07:30:44 pm
One idea about a side wall mechanical attachment is to fasten a piece of angle iron flush to the wall to the inside plywood floor (the same the seat is mounted to).
Then through drill the angle and the sidewall along the length of the angle iron (a quantity of 6 x 3/8" stainless carriage bolts along the angle iron approximately 48" in length, properly bedded/sealed).
That flooring is relatively strong because it holds the seat, and is tied to the dash and the floor solidly. This would serve to help take the strain off the bonding adhesive from the floor level down to the fender, though I'm not convinced it would help between the bottom of the driver side window and the floor.
Thoughts?
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: wolfe10 on April 23, 2022, 07:39:52 pm
Start by carefully inspecting the front cap to wood just below dash. You have a LOT of movement to open up that much seam on the side.
How is windshield fitment?
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on April 23, 2022, 08:30:27 pm
Start by carefully inspecting the front cap to wood just below dash. You have a LOT of movement to open up that much seam on the side.
How is windshield fitment?
Overall the windshield fitment seems good (other than walking out of place). If anything, the drivers side doesn't sit into the gasket front to back very well at the base.
I'll grab some pics of the dash underside behind the access doors tomorrow. I did resolve dash to cap movement with six10 from the top last Fall. So now there is no creaking noise when the windshield moves under very light twisting.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Protech Racing on April 23, 2022, 08:42:15 pm
I glued and rivited my caps on. Pry up the skin, inject your glue of choice , press the skin and large head rivet between the screws. Turn the trim strip into a trim strip, and remove it from adding much to the structure.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Gerry Vicha on April 23, 2022, 08:52:25 pm
Bringing this post back up since the weather is warmer and I'm ready to attempt a repair. Starting on the driver's side. This joint looks gnarly and I'm going to clean it up, then get it reattached with some good adhesive. I'm thinking 3m 5200 for permanent fix? Surface prep will be challenging...
Not sure how far I can get the adhesive back in the the area below the window. I am considering some type of mechanical attachment in addition to the adhesive but haven't come up with a solid plan yet.
Any experience share with pictures would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!
Your picture shows exactly what my delamination looked like. The outside "skin" moves on the structure that it had been secured to. It was not easy getting the glue into the inner part of the structure. It took me and my son, one holding the "skin" out as far as possible, while the other applied the glue to the surface. As in my previous post we then applied pressure to the entire area until the adhesive set up. I allowed that pressure on the side to set for 6 or 7 days..... Good Luck with your project it looks like you are on the right track..
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Chip7 on April 23, 2022, 09:34:55 pm
I glued and rivited my caps on. Pry up the skin, inject your glue of choice , press the skin and large head rivet between the screws. Turn the trim strip into a trim strip, and remove it from adding much to the structure.
This makes a lot of sense too and should augment my other efforts. There is a metal frame behind that trim piece to take the rivet I presume?
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Protech Racing on April 23, 2022, 09:59:39 pm
This makes a lot of sense too and should augment my other efforts. There is a metal frame behind that trim piece to take the rivet I presume?
Not sure really if there is a frame piece there or not.
Title: Re: Grand Villa U300 Windshield Movement
Post by: Mr B3 on April 24, 2022, 09:13:24 pm
I have a Oshkosh chassis, My windscreen popped out after it broke, At least two inches each way, I put an angle across the floor behind the seats, 3x4 inch x 3/8 thick, It was welded to 4 x 2 inch RHS up the walls, Between the cupboards on the right hand side, My drivers side, Up to the base of the window on the Old drivers side, 6 inch Bolts right thru the walls to outside, A 2 x 3/8 bar down the outside of the coach, The plate on the outside has countre sunk holes and welded to fill up the holes and ground smooth, So it is just a flat bar on the outside, Painted white,
The angle behind the seats is thru bolted to the chassis under neath the coach, It cant move, Ive now done 1000 miles in it and its worked so far, All the pictures are on my posts,