Foretravel Owners' Forum

Foretravel Motorhome Forums => Foretravel Discussions => Topic started by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 09:57:41 pm

Title: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 09:57:41 pm
Good evening. My family is considering purchasing a 2000 Grand Villa in the DFW area. We are new to coaches but previously owned class B and C RVs. Would very very much appreciate any insight and advice the community can offer on this Grand Villa. The configuration appears to be uncommon, per the wiki resource. We visited last weekend and were impressed with the exterior condition. The interior is immaculate and nicely updated.  Tires are dated 2020 and chassis/house batteries recent. The engine and genset started quickly while cold and ran smoothly. Maintenance records have been requested but not yet received. We have an inspection with local Cummins shop (with fluid analysis) and also an RV technician inspection scheduled this week.

There is an odometer issue as the coach was previously listed for sale by the PPL dealer in Oklahoma last year with 49,703 miles. The current Cleburne TX dealer reports that they identified an odometer issue and computer issue and had the odometer reprogrammed to report 214,695 miles, which they believe is accurate. Interestingly the prior owner disclosure documentation reports an odometer issue with 214,695 kilometers reported and actual mileage of 133,405 miles, which matches Mi-kM conversion. Not quite sure what to make of this and the sales manager and service manager couldn't explain this well, either. The sales and service managers believe that a $6,000-7,000 computer replacement is necessary, but is unsure of the details on this. A prior interested party had a diesel mechanic inspection completed, during which a computer issue was identified. The dealer had diesel shop evaluate and came back with a diagnosis of bad computer or impending computer failure, and that estimate amount. The dealer is selling As-Is and is not interested in having any repairs done, themselves.  Request for information on both the odometer and computer issue, to dealership owner is pending. They have dropped the price considerably and stated willing to move a bit more.

VIN# 1F97D5406YN054902
FMCA# 14814

Link to current listing:
2000 Foretravel Grand Villa Series M4000 GV320 | D744CL (https://www.pplmotorhomes.com/used-rvs-for-sale/diesel-motorhomes/2000-foretravel-grand-villa-series-m4000-gv320_rv-57058?srsltid=AfmBOopGbgxs-qqwvyyQWShg8Xhl6x_LFl_Z8E8eqZYcmc3Yn_2k6Tbn)

Video from Oklahoma PPL listing last year:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DsN0dS2lo7j4&ved=2ahUKEwi-2buwrOeJAxWJrYkEHSkwKgwQwqsBegQIDxAG&usg=AOvVaw3g-g0MXwjj8dflDw6MwyFD

Videos from current Texas PPL dealer:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DF5MvGuB-5-g&ved=2ahUKEwi-2buwrOeJAxWJrYkEHSkwKgwQwqsBegQIDRAG&usg=AOvVaw2r94D1aHMd_prq_Qcf1lSt

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DQDuCnkwyfO4&ved=2ahUKEwi-2buwrOeJAxWJrYkEHSkwKgwQwqsBegQIEBAG&usg=AOvVaw2Os2gU3WjeQG1tY89pWA2R


We would very much any advice the community can offer as we consider this coach for our family. We know this is a "pig and a poke" to some extent but hopeful that this coach has potential with a reasonable (at least initial) entry price point.  We are trying to establish realistic expectations for additional investment required to get things safely road worthy and ready for travel. MOT also has a couple of good options currently, which we will consider visiting, pending outcome of inspections this week.

Thank you all, in advance, for any guidance you can offer!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Michelle on November 18, 2024, 10:09:18 pm

Welcome to Foreforums!

FYI, that's not an FMCA number, it's a Foretravel Motorcade club number.  The number follows the owner, not the coach.  They may not have been the most recent owner of the coach.  That's a fairly old number that I'm pretty sure pre-dates 2000, so it wouldn't have been their first Foretravel.

Can you get the build number?  It will be on the plate with the VIN and tire pressures, near the driver's left knee.  Reading The Foretravel Build / Model Code (https://wiki.foreforums.com/doku.php?id=through_the_years:model-codes)

I believe the odometer can be reset to the actual mileage presented by the ECM (engine control module), which does not involve a pricey replacement of the computer.

BTW, since the coach is in Texas, if the RV tech you've hired for inspection isn't Keith Risch, I HIGHLY recommend you cancel and get Keith to do your inspection.  He knows much more about Foretravels than any typical RV tech and will know the chassis systems, where most techs won't.  He's in Nac, worked for Foretravel for many years, and now runs his own shop.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 10:18:03 pm
Thank you for the reply and advice, Michelle!

I believe the build# is G00549540WTMEGV320E27.  I will dig into the reference you linked.

Also, will reach out to Keith.  Thank you for your reply and advice!

Brendan
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Michelle on November 18, 2024, 10:19:50 pm
Let the forum know if you need Keith's contact info.  I don't believe he's a member here. 

There are a couple of other inspectors well-versed in Foretravels, but the typical RVIA inspector will not be one of them.  When we were selling our LTV, a buyer hired an RVIA inspector.  I actually had to demonstrate every single thing to the guy.  He had no idea how to operate anything (other than his camera to take pictures of the odometer and the tire dates.)
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 10:38:16 pm
Let the forum know if you need Keith's contact info.  I don't believe he's a member here. 

There are a couple of other inspectors well-versed in Foretravels, but the typical RVIA inspector will not be one of them.  When we were selling our LTV, a buyer hired an RVIA inspector.  I actually had to demonstrate every single thing to the guy.  He had no idea how to operate anything (other than his camera to take pictures of the odometer and the tire dates.)

Thanks so much.  I found his number in an old post and have reached out.  Have a great evening and thank you again for your advice.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Woody & Sitka on November 18, 2024, 10:44:31 pm
Buy it, Fix it, Drive it, Love it.  Nothing better than a Foretravel GV320!!!!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 10:46:25 pm
Buy it, Fix it, Drive it, Love it.  Nothing better than a Foretravel GV320!!!!

Thank you for the advice!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 10:55:27 pm
tires dated 2020....not 2000.  Sorry about the typo and thank you for the replies. 
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Tim Fiedler on November 18, 2024, 11:09:28 pm
lots of things to break at first. Engine and transmission (outside the potential computer) usually run fine for much longer than 200,000 miles (if correctly maintained).
Plenty likely need repair and cost $$$ in the first year of ownership - airbags, aquahot, brakes, OEM Refrigerator and more. W/O a slide, budget $10-$12K in the first year, less if you can work on it yourself. No matter what you pay, you are buying a 24 year old coach that today would cost in excess of $1M.

Great news is it probably is at the lower point of its depreciation cycle, maybe do a bit of remodel and love it for a LONG time. check out all the storage space, and that mile high driving position! Also, you will need a Foretravel trained inspection, as there are some expensive potential issues that come with the foretravel custom chassis the average RV inspector would not know about. The coach either has the issues or does not have them. If it does, repairs need to be ascertained and factored into the purchase price. Keith Risch is the right man for the job.

Good luck, hope it all turns out, you will love that coach.
Tim Fiedler

Quote
On Mon, Nov 18, 2024 at 9:55 PM Foretravel Fan 2024 via ForeForums <noreply@foreforums.com (noreply@foreforums.com)> wrote:

tires dated 2020....not 2000. Sorry about the typo and thank you for the replies.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Barry & Cindy on November 18, 2024, 11:15:33 pm
What is their considerable dropped selling price? Not easy to price these, and always allow for some large additional costs.

No slides will reduce your unknown maintenance problems.

From the below nameplate, being made Dec 2098, I would think of this as a highly futuristic model.

Wonder when the coach was made ? Dec 2098?  Anyone know what that number stands for. . . 

Without slide could it be 1998?  Maybe they wanted to call it a 2000 model year by design, but messed up the 19 & 20.  But when it was made will indicate how long the coach has been on the road.


Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 11:34:51 pm
What is their considerable dropped selling price? Not easy to price these, and always allow for some large additional costs.

No slides will reduce your unknown maintenance problems.

From the below nameplate, being made Dec 2098, I would think of this as a highly futuristic model.

Wonder when the coach was made ? Dec 2098?  Anyone know what that number stands for. . . 

Without slide could it be 1998?  Maybe they wanted to call it a 2000 model year by design, but messed up the 19 & 20.  But when it was made will indicate how long the coach has been on the road.

Recent price decrease was $11,000.  Thank you for the reply and info.  I look forward to hearing responses to your question!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 18, 2024, 11:36:14 pm
lots of things to break at first. Engine and transmission (outside the potential computer) usually run fine for much longer than 200,000 miles (if correctly maintained).
Plenty likely need repair and cost $$$ in the first year of ownership - airbags, aquahot, brakes, OEM Refrigerator and more. W/O a slide, budget $10-$12K in the first year, less if you can work on it yourself. No matter what you pay, you are buying a 24 year old coach that today would cost in excess of $1M.
Great news is it probably is at the lower point of its depreciation cycle, maybe do a bit of remodel and love it for a LONG time. check out all the storage space, and that mile high driving position! Also, you will need a Foretravel trained inspection, as there are some expensive potential issues that come with the foretravel custom chassis the average RV inspector would not know about. The coach either has the issues or does not have them. If it does, repairs need to be ascertained and factored into the purchase price. Keith Risch is the right man for the job.
Good luck, hope it all turns out, you will love that coach.
Tim Fiedler TCERDirect® | TC-ER-JP cable for ALL of your Projects | Generator Installatio... (https://www.tcerdirect.com) - Our Products. Your Solution. Call me at 630 240-9139 Gen-Pro Products LLC

On Mon, Nov 18, 2024 at 9:55 PM Foretravel Fan 2024 via ForeForums <noreply@foreforums.com (noreply@foreforums.com)> wrote:

Thank you for the response and advice.  Reached out to Keith and hope to have additional information by next week.  Thank you!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Jeff & Sandy on November 19, 2024, 04:51:48 am
Beautiful, very desirable coach!

Note that Keith is the best and can be tough to connect with on occasion. It's well worth it! Mornings seem to be the best time, he prefers texting.

Good luck!


(936) 462-3764‬
8946 US HWY 259
Nacogdoches TX 75965
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 19, 2024, 08:32:00 am
According to my 2008 Motorcade book the owner at that time was;  Vincent & Eva  Abate,  P.O. Box 6456 Lake Charles, LA  70606. Shows an Email -  abatesplumbing @aol.com 
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: erniee on November 19, 2024, 08:34:13 am
It looks clean. Don't fall for the computer replacement scheme. I have 250, 000 miles on my coach. Drive it away. Cheap price
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Michelle on November 19, 2024, 09:41:30 am
From the below nameplate, being made Dec 2098, I would think of this as a highly futuristic model.

Wonder when the coach was made ? Dec 2098?  Anyone know what that number stands for. . . 

Good catch on the typo.


Reading the VIN code (https://wiki.foreforums.com/doku.php?id=through_the_years:vin)

Vehicle Identification Numbers (VIN codes)/Model year - Wikibooks, open... (https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Vehicle_Identification_Numbers_%28VIN_codes%29/Model_year)

Digit Y = 2000

Build number 5495 must be a very early 2000.  Our 2000 U320 was delivered to the original owners in late 2000 and has a build number 220 units after that GV

ETA and the date on our info plate is Jan 2000.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on November 19, 2024, 12:46:46 pm
This thread tickled my curiosity about the 2000 model GV320, so I poked around a bit in our Forum.

Found an old post by Barry Beam estimating that Foretravel built only 10 examples of the GV320 in model year 2000.

2000-2003 GV production numbers (https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=15171.msg91192#msg91192)

I also located two other recently active Forum members who own 2000 model GV320 coaches.  Build numbers are 5712 and 5717.
They might be willing to answer any questions the OP has (that are specific to the GV320 model).

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=profile;u=5611

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=profile;u=8240
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 19, 2024, 04:50:42 pm
According to my 2008 Motorcade book the owner at that time was;  Vincent & Eva  Abate,  P.O. Box 6456 Lake Charles, LA  70606. Shows an Email -  abatesplumbing @aol.com

Thanks so much.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 19, 2024, 04:54:51 pm
It looks clean. Don't fall for the computer replacement scheme. I have 250, 000 miles on my coach. Drive it away. Cheap price

Thank you for the advice.  Will keep everyone updated.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 19, 2024, 04:56:07 pm
This thread tickled my curiosity about the 2000 model GV320, so I poked around a bit in our Forum.

Found an old post by Barry Beam estimating that Foretravel built only 10 examples of the GV320 in model year 2000.

2000-2003 GV production numbers (https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?topic=15171.msg91192#msg91192)

I also located two other recently active Forum members who own 2000 model GV320 coaches.  Build numbers are 5712 and 5717.
They might be willing to answer any questions the OP has (that are specific to the GV320 model).

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=profile;u=5611

https://www.foreforums.com/index.php?action=profile;u=8240

Thanks so much for posting this. 
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Michelle on November 19, 2024, 06:38:10 pm
Thank you for the advice.  Will keep everyone updated.

Please do!  You have an entire forum waiting (with fingers crossed) to hear how it goes  :)
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: "Irish" on November 19, 2024, 09:31:42 pm
Tommy D in Bardstown is super nice guy!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: kgrover on November 19, 2024, 10:37:02 pm
When you have it at the cummins dealer, have them connect to the ecm and check the mileage.  Also get a list of any error codes it has. Many members here can help you understand any codes it might have.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: MMoore on November 20, 2024, 01:39:32 am
Dropped by $11,000 or to $11,000 ? It makes a difference. I can't see how you could go wrong at $11,000
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 20, 2024, 06:28:51 am
Dropped by $11,000 or to $11,000 ? It makes a difference. I can't see how you could go wrong at $11,000

Recent price drop was $11,000, resulting in current price of $27,995.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 20, 2024, 07:07:25 am
If it has not been submerged in Salt Water, that sounds like a Bargain price. The pictures of the interior are beautiful, Outside looks nice, Pre blue def is a positive, What's not to like ? ? ? ?
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Tommy D on November 20, 2024, 09:20:34 am
Be happy to answer any questions.  I was once told there were only 6 2000 GV320 ordered as it was only made to order?  I've put close to 100k miles on mine since I bought it in 2019.  It had sat unused since 2013.  Huge learning curve if you have never owned a diesel pusher or a Foretravel but you will have so much fun with it.

Cheers!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Bob & Sue on November 20, 2024, 02:05:07 pm
Be happy to answer any questions.  I was once told there were only 6 2000 GV320 ordered as it was only made to order?  I've put close to 100k miles on mine since I bought it in 2019.  It had sat unused since 2013.  Huge learning curve if you have never owned a diesel pusher or a Foretravel but you will have so much fun with it.

Cheers!
A very nice coach.... I have some GV envy.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: SuperFore on November 20, 2024, 05:06:02 pm
GV #5717 here...

I thought that I checked out this coach years ago but it's got a different floorplan than I expected so I didn't...interesting to see some of the differences between my coach and this one.

Personally I'll suggest you probably won't miss the slide-i wouldn't...I also like the street side kitchen.

If it doesn't have any bulkhead issues this  looks to be a great deal! Basement looks super clean so it's probably a southern coach and I'd be optimistic it's good to go.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 20, 2024, 05:23:00 pm
GV #5717 here...

I thought that I checked out this coach years ago but it's got a different floorplan than I expected so I didn't...interesting to see some of the differences between my coach and this one.

Personally I'll suggest you probably won't miss the slide-i wouldn't...I also like the street side kitchen.

If it doesn't have any bulkhead issues this  looks to be a great deal! Basement looks super clean so it's probably a southern coach and I'd be optimistic it's good to go.

Thank you for the reply!  Fingers crossed on pending inspections.  Based on suggestions from this community, I believe we have the right team lined up to evaluate the coach, no later than next Tuesday.  Have a great night!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 20, 2024, 05:29:00 pm
Be happy to answer any questions.  I was once told there were only 6 2000 GV320 ordered as it was only made to order?  I've put close to 100k miles on mine since I bought it in 2019.  It had sat unused since 2013.  Huge learning curve if you have never owned a diesel pusher or a Foretravel but you will have so much fun with it.

Cheers!

I'm sure we'll have questions soon...thank you for offering to answer them!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Jeff M. on November 20, 2024, 06:27:12 pm
Thank you for the reply!  Fingers crossed on pending inspections.  Based on suggestions from this community, I believe we have the right team lined up to evaluate the coach, no later than next Tuesday.  Have a great night!
Well if you have Keith lined up, you are way ahead.  He is definitely "The guy"...
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Olde English on November 20, 2024, 11:19:10 pm
If I were 10 years younger I would have already bought that coach, a quick check of the bulkheads and off to the fuel station.
For that kind of money it's a steal.
IMHO
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: SuperFore on November 21, 2024, 07:31:04 pm
If I were 10 years younger I would have already bought that coach, a quick check of the bulkheads and off to the fuel station.
For that kind of money it's a steal.
IMHO
I agree with that - if I didn't have the 2000 this would be mine... The headlights would have snagged me and I wanted a white Coach with the gray graphics... Bulkheads would not have scared me away, I used to think that they were part of a boat not motorhome! 🤣
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 22, 2024, 09:42:15 am
Thank you all for the replies.  Update from Cummins shop - fluid analysis for engine, genset, and transmission looked good.  They were unable to read the error codes responsible for the check engine light, possibly due to previously mentioned computer issue.  They also believe there's a problem with the ABS system and will provide more detail on that this afternoon. Keith is not available for an inspection but he has a partner or colleague who is...inspection date pending, hopefully this weekend or early next week.

One question for the group.  The RV warranty company that PPL uses does not offer warranties on coaches over 20-years old. Is anyone familiar with a warranty company that might offer a warranty on a 2000 coach? Thanks so much in advance and have a great Friday and weekend.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Elliott on November 22, 2024, 09:52:41 am
One question for the group.  The RV warranty company that PPL uses does not offer warranties on coaches over 20-years old. Is anyone familiar with a warranty company that might offer a warranty on a 2000 coach? Thanks so much in advance and have a great Friday and weekend.
In my time here on the Forum I've never heard of anyone successfully using a warranty to repair a Unicoach. Even if you could find one, I suspect it'd be ridiculously expensive. You are better off keeping $10k in the bank to self insure and having Keith give it a look-over every couple years.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Gerry Vicha on November 22, 2024, 10:39:09 am


One question for the group.  The RV warranty company that PPL uses does not offer warranties on coaches over 20-years old. Is anyone familiar with a warranty company that might offer a warranty on a 2000 coach? Thanks so much in advance and have a great Friday and weekend.


Put the premiums for the, "Warranty Money" in a separate bank  savings account,  for when You will need repairs....
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on November 22, 2024, 12:47:59 pm
Ditto the "warranty" advice above.

You'd be surprised how many "problems" encountered with these great old coaches can be solved by DIY.  Initially, it's a steep learning curve, but we'll help you climb the slope.  Within this Forum you will have the benefit of the greatest single collection of Foretravel knowledge and expertise available anywhere in the known universe.  Questions?  We got answers.  Something breaks?  It has more than likely happened to another Forum member and the fix is documented in our archives.  Locating obscure parts for old systems?  We'll tell you our secret sources.

Paying for parts and repairs?  That's on you.  8)
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Pamela & Mike on November 22, 2024, 01:30:13 pm
I have been quiet as my plans are set in Jello, but I plan on being it the area of this coach in a couple of weeks. With all this talk it has piqued my interest, and I plan on swing by and give it a look unless it gets snapped up first.  If they changed the ECM that makes it impossible to get the total mileage and see what the flag was that caused them to change out the ECM to start with. It could have been nothing more than a billfold drain for the owner rather than a real problem.  The thing is some of the info seems to be askew and until someone that knows the Foretravel quirks like Kieth there is a lot of guessing.

Mike
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 22, 2024, 02:08:52 pm
Ditto the "warranty" advice above.

You'd be surprised how many "problems" encountered with these great old coaches can be solved by DIY.  Initially, it's a steep learning curve, but we'll help you climb the slope.  Within this Forum you will have the benefit of the greatest single collection of Foretravel knowledge and expertise available anywhere in the known universe.  Questions?  We got answers.  Something breaks?  It has more than likely happened to another Forum member and the fix is documented in our archives.  Locating obscure parts for old systems?  We'll tell you our secret sources.

Paying for parts and repairs?  That's on you.  8)

Thank you all for the support and invaluable information.  We very much appreciate it.  Will have an update by Monday or Tuesday, at the latest.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 27, 2024, 07:09:00 pm
We owe everyone that helped us with this process a great deal of gratitude. Thank you to everyone who made recommendations and otherwise replied to this post. A colleague of Keith's (info available upon request and with his permission) completed a thorough inspection on Monday, after the diesel shop inspection. He believes it to be a solid coach with modest repairs and maintenance needed.  He has been phenomenal and his decades of experience as a subject matter expert on these coaches was immediately apparent. We also were able to reach the prior owner of 16-years. He was extremely helpful and had invaluable insights to offer. The question on the coach's mileage was resolved...the explanation is strange, but bottom line, the coach and its original powertrain do have almost 215,000 miles. It runs and drives very well. 

Ultimately, we made an offer today, which accounted for planned immediate repairs/maintenance, and the dealer accepted. Thank you again for all of your advice and have a great Thanksgiving!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: SuperFore on November 27, 2024, 07:12:11 pm
We owe everyone that helped us with this process a great deal of gratitude. Thank you to everyone who made recommendations and otherwise replied to this post. A colleague of Keith's (info available upon request and with his permission) completed a thorough inspection on Monday, after the diesel shop inspection. He believes it to be a solid coach with modest repairs and maintenance needed.  He has been phenomenal and his decades of experience as a subject matter expert on these coaches was immediately apparent. We also were able to reach the prior owner of 16-years. He was extremely helpful and had invaluable insights to offer. The question on the coach's mileage was resolved...the explanation is strange, but bottom line, the coach and its original powertrain do have almost 215,000 miles. It runs and drives very well. 

Ultimately, we made an offer today, which accounted for planned immediate repairs/maintenance, and the dealer accepted. Thank you again for all of your advice and have a great Thanksgiving!

That's awesome & congratulations!

Any GV specific questions feel free to hmu - otherwise our coaches are just about identical to a U320.

Happy Thanksgiving! 🦃
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Michelle on November 27, 2024, 08:18:15 pm
Ultimately, we made an offer today, which accounted for planned immediate repairs/maintenance, and the dealer accepted. Thank you again for all of your advice and have a great Thanksgiving!

 :dance:
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Pamela & Mike on November 27, 2024, 08:38:26 pm
That is great news so welcome to the group. As far as that mileage that original owner kept the road hot so no problem with lot rot. I was sure looking forward to seeing it myself next week just to check it out for you. When you get stumped on a problem remember someone here has most likely dune been down that road and will have an answer.

Mike
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: kgrover on November 28, 2024, 06:35:37 am
Thank you all for the replies.  Update from Cummins shop - fluid analysis for engine, genset, and transmission looked good.  They were unable to read the error codes responsible for the check engine light, possibly due to previously mentioned computer issue.  They also believe there's a problem with the ABS system and will provide more detail on that this afternoon. Keith is not available for an inspection but he has a partner or colleague who is...inspection date pending, hopefully this weekend or early next week.

One question for the group.  The RV warranty company that PPL uses does not offer warranties on coaches over 20-years old. Is anyone familiar with a warranty company that might offer a warranty on a 2000 coach? Thanks so much in advance and have a great Friday and weekend.

Were they unable to read anything from the ECM, or were there no codes stored? There might not be an issue with it at all. My experience has been that the codes that the engine reports are not always clear exactly what is wrong with it, and it often interpreted wrong by the techs.
You may want to look into a device to read the codes and information from the ECMs for future troubleshooting. Some of the other members can chime in as to what works well. I have the tools for this from work, and a coach that is too old to support most of it. But if you need any help troubleshooting codes or ECM issues, I'm glad to help.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on November 30, 2024, 04:38:41 am
Were they unable to read anything from the ECM, or were there no codes stored? There might not be an issue with it at all. My experience has been that the codes that the engine reports are not always clear exactly what is wrong with it, and it often interpreted wrong by the techs.
You may want to look into a device to read the codes and information from the ECMs for future troubleshooting. Some of the other members can chime in as to what works well. I have the tools for this from work, and a coach that is too old to support most of it. But if you need any help troubleshooting codes or ECM issues, I'm glad to help.

Thank you for offering to help.  Repeated scan last night. Not the most sophisticated device, admittedly. These are the scanner codes.  Thank you for any insight you have!

# - ID / FM / CNT
1 - 128 / 0 / 0
2 - 10 / 0 / 0
3 - 20 / 0 / 0
4 - 5 / 0/ 0
5 - 7 / 0 / 0
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: kgrover on November 30, 2024, 06:02:43 am
What scanner did you use to get these?
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on December 02, 2024, 11:58:40 am
Thanks for the reply.  It was a fairly inexpensive and simple scanner called a ScanGauge. Thanks for any help you can offer!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on December 05, 2024, 09:55:36 am
Update - We have our 2000 GV320 at the Cummins shop right now. They identified the likely source of the CEL and a couple of other issues, primarily involving low battery voltage. It appears that the alternator (Wilson 90-01-4721N) and battery isolator (Cole Hersee Co. 48160 isolator for heavy duty applications, 12-36VDC 200A) were recently replaced. The tech informed us that the isolator is a 3-stud solid state isolator which should be connected only to a solid state alternator. The current alternator is a 180A variable alternator with an internal voltage regulator. Per the isolator manufacturer, this alternator is incorrect for the model and can cause issues. With the isolator in place, alternator voltage was low. When the isolator was bypassed, the alternator voltage was normal. The tech believes the alternator is functional and the isolator has failed. He recommended replacing the failed isolator with another Cole Hersee Co. model (48162), which he believes be configured to work with the current alternator.
 
Also, they were able to identify different fault codes than I previously posted.  They used a Cummins Insite scanner to identify the faults listed below.  The tech used Cummins Quickserve to determine that the faults could be caused by insufficient battery voltage.

1. 245 x8 active Fan Control Circuit - Voltage Below Normal or Shorted to Low Source
2. 289 x35 active Idle Shutdown Vehicle Accessories Relay Driver Circuit - Root Cause Not Known

Thank you all for your input and suggestions!



Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on December 05, 2024, 10:56:03 am
Update - We have our 2000 GV320 at the Cummins shop right now. It appears that the alternator (Wilson 90-01-4721N) and battery isolator (Cole Hersee Co. 48160 isolator for heavy duty applications, 12-36VDC 200A) were recently replaced. The tech informed us that the isolator is a 3-stud solid state isolator which should be connected only to a solid state alternator. The current alternator is a 180A variable alternator with an internal voltage regulator. Per the isolator manufacturer, this alternator is incorrect for the model and can cause issues. With the isolator in place, alternator voltage was low. When the isolator was bypassed, the alternator voltage was normal. The tech believes the alternator is functional and the isolator has failed. He recommended replacing the failed isolator with another Cole Hersee Co. model (48162), which he believes be configured to work with the current alternator.
The tech is correct when he recommends the 48162 isolator, but I think he is incorrect in saying the 48160 isolator has "failed".  It didn't fail - it was just improperly paired with the Wilson alternator.  The Wilson 90-01-4721 alternator is a clone (or rebuilt) version of a Delco 28Si alternator.  The 28Si will not turn on unless it sees 12V on the B+ output terminal.  If this model alternator is connected directly to a battery (like when you bypassed the isolator) then it works fine.  BUT, when it is connected to the center post on the isolator, it can't see any 12V signal, because the isolator diodes prevent voltage from the battery posts getting to the center post.  So, the alternator will not turn on.  The solution, in this case, is to use a isolator that includes a separate "ignition terminal".  You connect a wire to this terminal that is hot only with ignition switch in ON position.  The "ignition terminal" on the isolator supplies the required 12V signal to the isolator alternator post, which will then tell the alternator to turn on.

I can't tell (from my search) if the Wilson 90-01-4721 alternator has a "sense" terminal.  If it DOES NOT have a sense terminal, then it will still not work correctly on your coach, even if they replace the isolator with the 48162.  If it DOES have a sense terminal, then it will work with the 48162.  The sense terminal on the alternator should be connected to a 12V source that that reads CHASSIS battery voltage and is HOT all the time.

If the Wilson alternator does NOT have a "sense" terminal, then I would recommend a different replacement isolator.  The Victron ArgoFET 200-2AC has the requisite "ignition" terminal AND, in contrast to diode isolators, has virtually zero voltage drop between the alternator post and the battery posts.

Amazon.com: Victron Energy Argofet Battery Isolators 200-2AC (2 Batteries... (https://www.amazon.com/Victron-Energy-Argofet-200-2-Batteries/dp/B00NT9MTMQ)

Amazon.com: Cole Hersee 48162 Battery Isolator : Automotive (https://www.amazon.com/Cole-Hersee-48162-Battery-Isolator/dp/B07BYH6Q9M)

https://www.truckspring.com/products/Alternator-Wilson-180-Amp-New-28SI-Type__90-01-4721N.aspx

Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on December 05, 2024, 11:10:02 am
The tech is correct when he recommends the 48162 isolator, but I think he is incorrect in saying the 48160 isolator has "failed".  It didn't fail - it was just improperly paired with the Wilson alternator.  The Wilaon 90-01-4721 alternator is a clone (or rebuilt) version of a Delco 28Si alternator.  The 28Si will not turn on unless it sees 12V on the B+ output terminal.  If this model alternator is connected directly to a battery (like when you bypassed the isolator) then it works fine.  BUT, when it is connected to the center post on the isolator, it can't see any 12V signal, because the isolator diodes prevent voltage from the battery posts getting to the center post.  So, the alternator will not turn on.  The solution, in this case, is to use a isolator that includes a separate "ignition terminal".  You connect a wire to this terminal that is hot only with ignition switch in ON position.  The "ignition terminal" on the isolator supplies the required 12V signal to the isolator alternator post, which will then tell the alternator to turn on.

I can't tell (from my search) if the Wilson 90-01-4721 alternator has a "sense" terminal.  If it DOES NOT have a sense terminal, then it will still not work correctly on your coach, even if they replace the isolator.  If it DOES have a sense terminal, then it will work.  The sense terminal on the alternator should be connected to a 12V source that is HOT all the time.

If the Wilson alternator does NOT have a "sense" terminal, then I would recommend a different replacement isolator.  The Victron ArgoFET 200-2AC has the requisite "ignition" terminal AND in contrast to diode isolators has virtually zero voltage drop between the alternator post and the battery posts.

https://www.amazon.com/Victron-Energy-Argofet-200-2-Batteries/dp/B00NT9MTMQ

https://www.amazon.com/Cole-Hersee-48162-Battery-Isolator/dp/B07BYH6Q9M

https://www.truckspring.com/products/Alternator-Wilson-180-Amp-New-28SI-Type__90-01-4721N.aspx

Thank you for the reply.  The tech's summary included this statement "the model 48162 is a 12-36 VDC 200A with a 4th leg. We would need to make and connect to an ignition circuit on the unit for proper operation with the installed alternator. "  Excuse my ignorance, but does it sound like he is referencing the sense terminal that must be connected to 12V source that must be HOT all of the time? Thanks in advance!
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: craneman on December 05, 2024, 11:18:40 am
No that would go to the b terminal to activate the alternator.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on December 05, 2024, 11:23:01 am
Thank you for the reply.  The tech's summary included this statement "the model 48162 is a 12-36 VDC 200A with a 4th leg. We would need to make and connect to an ignition circuit on the unit for proper operation with the installed alternator. "  Excuse my ignorance, but does it sound like he is referencing the sense terminal that must be connected to 12V source that must be HOT all of the time? Thanks in advance!
The way I interpret the tech's statement is he is talking about the "ignition" terminal on the 48162 isolator, saying it must be connected to a "hot with ignition ON" voltage source.  So he is correct in that statement.  However, he is not addressing the question about whether or not your Wilson alternator has a "sense" terminal.  You should ask them about this.

The reason a diode isolator will not work in the absence of a "sense" terminal on the alternator is because, with a DIODE based isolator, there is a voltage drop of approximately 0.8 volts between the center alternator post and the two battery posts.  The battery banks will not receive sufficient voltage to achieve full charge.  This problem can be overcome by either using an alternator with a "sense" terminal, OR by using an isolator that does not suffer the voltage drop between the posts.  The Victron ArgoFET meets this requirement.
 
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on December 05, 2024, 11:33:01 am
The way I interpret the tech's statement is he is talking about the "ignition" terminal on the 48162 isolator, saying it must be connected to a "hot with ignition ON" voltage source.  So he is correct in that statement.  However, he is not addressing the question about whether or not your Wilson alternator has a "sense" terminal.  You should ask them about this.

The reason a diode isolator will not work in the absence of a "sense" terminal on the alternator is because, with a DIODE based isolator, there is a voltage drop of approximately 0.8 volts between the center alternator post and the two battery posts.  The batteries will not receive sufficient voltage to achieve full charge.  This problem can be overcome by either using an alternator with a "sense" terminal, OR by using an isolator that does not suffer the voltage drop between the posts.  The Victron ArgoFET meets this requirement.

Thanks so much for the detailed explanation and recommendation.  Passing this info along to the tech as we speak. 
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Chuck & Jeannie on December 05, 2024, 11:54:10 am
Link below to the installation sheet for a Delco Remy 28Si.  I installed this model alternator on our coach.  The "sense" terminal on this model 28Si is clearly marked.  This does not mean a clone of the 28Si will also have the "sense" terminal, or if it does that it would be in the same location.  DO NOT connect any 12V source to any of the small posts on your alternator unless you are sure it is, in fact, a clearly designated "sense" terminal.  It should be marked with a large S.  Hooking up 12 volts to the wrong small post can smoke the voltage regulator.

https://www.delcoremy.com/documents/alternator-instruction-sheets/installation-instructions-24si-28si.aspx

Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: Foretravel Fan 2024 on May 20, 2025, 10:30:47 am
I want to thank everyone for all of the advice leading up to and since our purchase in November. We spent several months sorting things out, and thanks to Bob, Gary, Keith, and Virginia in Nacogdoches (and nearby), our coach is running great. We had the bulkhead repair completed and a dozen other smaller repairs/replacements. We couldn't be happier with the Grand Villa and so appreciate both the people here and in Texas. Have a great week.
Title: Re: 2000 Grand Villa M4000 GV320
Post by: SuperFore on May 20, 2025, 02:06:33 pm
I want to thank everyone for all of the advice leading up to and since our purchase in November. We spent several months sorting things out, and thanks to Bob, Gary, Keith, and Virginia in Nacogdoches (and nearby), our coach is running great. We had the bulkhead repair completed and a dozen other smaller repairs/replacements. We couldn't be happier with the Grand Villa and so appreciate both the people here and in Texas. Have a great week.

Funny thing I was just thinking about your purchase a few days ago and wondering how things were going - glad to hear that you are on track...

Feel free to reach out directly if you run into any GV specific issues - I'm finding there are lots of little items specific to our coaches that have never been addressed on this forum (not something you're going to deal with but as an example, I just replaced my headlights - what an adventure!)

Enjoy your coach!