Skip to main content
Topic: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35 (Read 3067 times) previous topic - next topic

Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Hi. First time poster and new to ForeForums. I'm a big believer in considering the experiences of others when it comes to things I know far less about, like RVs. We are preparing to retire, likely in 2023. As part of that transition, we are seriously researching full-time RV'ing to write our next chapter. Having spent the past 6 months or so researching different companies, makes, and models we have narrowed our focus to a DP in the 35' to 40' range (but are still open to a longer tag-axle option should we feel after actual walkthroughs that we want more space). Our finalist manufacturers are Foretravel and Newmar. A Newell/Prevost are out of our price range and none of the other companies impressed us sufficiently that we would put them on par with Foretravel and Newmar.

So, finally the question I am posing. Considering the FS450 versus the Newmar New Aire 35, what are the key distinctions worth mentioning, beyond the obvious difference in lengths - 38'+ of FS450 versus approx. 36' of the New Aire. I believe both are built on the Spartan K2 and produce 450hp. From a differences standpoint, we really like the greater visibility of the picture windshield on the NewAire, the escape door ladder feature, a large 40"x32" shower, and the 'Comfort Drive'/related safety features. I'm also very impressed with the slide seals Foretravel uses on their coaches as well as what appears to be their higher resale value as a product line over time.

So, let me turn it over to the community. For anyone who has researched either of these models or has brand comparison knowledge, please share. Thanks.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #1
I had 2 Newells and now a 36' 1999 no slide Foretravel. PM me if you'd like opinions on Newell.
New or used? Your budget will limit you to certain year ranges.
A 36-38' coach will allow you into more options for campgrounds, especially the smaller national forests and others. That's one of the greatest drawbacks of a 45' coach. Not sure how tall you are but consider headroom in either brand. Interestingly a longer coach with a tag axle probably won't give you much more basement storage if any. But a longer coach may give you a larger separate washer/dryer which if fulltiming might be advantageous.
Look also at the size and heating capacity of the Aquahot in each, Rudy can help you understand the limitations and features.
It's important to figure out how your travels will be. Campground to campground, Resort to resort, BLM dry camping, national parks & forests?  Or a combination?  Most new/er coaches will be all electric and could limit you to campgrounds with 50 amp hookups.
Lots of decisions but you'll get lots of opinions here.  Have fun!
Forest & Cindy Olivier
1987 log cabin
2011 Roadtrek C210P
no longer 1999 36' U320 build #5522
2013 Rzr 570 & 2018 Ranger XP1000
2006 Lexus GX470
2011 Tahoe LT 4x4
Previous 1998 45' 2 slide Newell, 1993 39' Newell

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #2
A suggestion on the two manufactures you chose. We also did the research and the difference was seen at the factories. Have you been to both Foretravel and Newmar factories? We also went to Newell to see how they were built. In order of OUR choice, it was, Newell, Foretravel, and we totally eliminated Newmar.  Just crappy construction except for the King Aire. It came closest to Foretravel.
Future Foretravel Owners
2019 Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk
Retired USAF, Retired DOD Civ's
FAA A&P, Indust. Eng., Acft Depot Lvl. Maint.
Larry and Becky Rountree

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #3
Have you looked at NCCC differences between the two?  I recall reading from iRV2 that the 35' New Aire is a bit "pudgy", but that may have been the first year of the longer length which may have been on the 360 hp chassis.  I do recall running the numbers and the weight to HP ratio for the 2021 35' New Aire is much worse than a 40' 2003 U320 (different engine, but both have 450 hp).  I don't have the FS450 approximate UVW or wet weights for calculation.

It appears the FS450 has a 150 gallon fuel tank, vs 90 for the New Aire.  That's significant in terms of travel distance and also using some of the diesel discount programs which have a 100 gallon minimum to get the discount (pump start is not affected)

One of the 2 chassis options, I can't recall if it's Spartan or Freightliner, for the New Aire moved away from pad/switch controls and put things (like engine brake and cruise control) on a "smart stick".  If it's Spartan - see if the FS450 has the same.  I watched an "Angie video" that included it, and it seemed like it would have a bit of a learning curve (for someone used to separate controls).

FS450 has a combined grey/black waste tank at 130 gallons (likely has a grey tank bypass); New Aire has 40 gallons black, 60 gallons grey. 

FS450 has 122 gallon fresh tank, New Aire has 105 gallons

FS450 has AquaHot 450D which will have an engine heating loop; New Aire has Oasis hydronic heating - don't know if that includes an engine loop or not.

FS450 also has steering assist; they just don't use the name "Comfort Drive" since Newmar has that trademarked.  Likely the same or very similar system.

One two notable things - underlying assembly quality and documentation.  A major issue I see repeated time and again with Newmar is how unbelievably sloppy the wiring is.  Owners complain they can't get schematics to figure things out (perhaps this will documentation issue will change now that they're owned by WGO).  You will not have that with Foretravel, if they are building them the same as they have in the past.  You will get schematics.  You will get reasonable documentation.  Your wiring will be neatly loomed AND LABELED with wire numbers.

Newmar owners don't have Foreforums  ;)
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #4
A suggestion on the two manufactures you chose. We also did the research and the difference was seen at the factories. Have you been to both Foretravel and Newmar factories? We also went to Newell to see how they were built. In order of OUR choice, it was, Newell, Foretravel, and we totally eliminated Newmar.  Just crappy construction except for the King Aire. It came closest to Foretravel.

Great idea on the factory tour. That is something we have as part of our final decision-making process. While Indiana and Texas aren't exactly next door to us (or each other), we'll make the trip to each company before we make any coach purchase.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #5
And to add to Michelle 's  comments re Newmar not having the Forum, I was visiting our large Newmar dealership here in Penticton, which happens to be the biggest dealer of Newmars on the west coast,  and while talking to the owner, George, about the differences I asked him if he had ever seen our  member run help forum with all the notable info one may need at some time. I used his big screen computer and logged in and ran thru a few points so he had an idea of what I was relating to. Goerge made a very complimetary comment about it and wished that the same idea was available for Newmar owners. He added, of course that due to the incredible build quality of Newmars that really as they never break down this would most probably be a mute point anyway. He did laugh though.
George does know about Foretravels as they have had at least 2 for sale over the last few years, and both owners became members of forum.
JOHNH
Coachless, now use aircraft. 2003 Ford Travelair TC280 class C. Super shape. Just for 1 yr .
1994 Ford E350 ClassC,total renovation inside and out. Now sold.
2000 U295  36' Cummins 350 c/w Banks Stinger, Resonator upgrade,Solar, LED lites.Residential fridge with slide out pantry. Build 5674. Sold
ex 92 GV 022C ored Cummins. Sold
ex 95 GV240 cat 3116. Sold
2017 Mini cooper s & 2016 land Rover LR2 HSE  LUX.
jhaygarth@aol.com    SKP #130098
treat everyone as you would like to be.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #6
Have you looked at NCCC differences between the two?  I recall reading from iRV2 that the 35' New Aire is a bit "pudgy", but that may have been the first year of the longer length which may have been on the 360 hp chassis.  I do recall running the numbers and the weight to HP ratio for the 2021 35' New Aire is much worse than a 40' 2003 U320 (different engine, but both have 450 hp).  I don't have the FS450 approximate UVW or wet weights for calculation.

It appears the FS450 has a 150 gallon fuel tank, vs 90 for the New Aire.  That's significant in terms of travel distance and also using some of the diesel discount programs which have a 100 gallon minimum to get the discount (pump start is not affected)

One of the 2 chassis options, I can't recall if it's Spartan or Freightliner, for the New Aire moved away from pad/switch controls and put things (like engine brake and cruise control) on a "smart stick".  If it's Spartan - see if the FS450 has the same.  I watched an "Angie video" that included it, and it seemed like it would have a bit of a learning curve (for someone used to separate controls).

FS450 has a combined grey/black waste tank at 130 gallons (likely has a grey tank bypass); New Aire has 40 gallons black, 60 gallons grey. 

FS450 has 122 gallon fresh tank, New Aire has 105 gallons

FS450 has AquaHot 450D which will have an engine heating loop; New Aire has Oasis hydronic heating - don't know if that includes an engine loop or not.

FS450 also has steering assist; they just don't use the name "Comfort Drive" since Newmar has that trademarked.  Likely the same or very similar system.

One two notable things - underlying assembly quality and documentation.  A major issue I see repeated time and again with Newmar is how unbelievably sloppy the wiring is.  Owners complain they can't get schematics to figure things out (perhaps this will documentation issue will change now that they're owned by WGO).  You will not have that with Foretravel, if they are building them the same as they have in the past.  You will get schematics.  You will get reasonable documentation.  Your wiring will be neatly loomed AND LABELED with wire numbers.

Newmar owners don't have Foreforums  ;)

Great points. The increased tank capacities (especially regarding the fuel discount program) is relevant for us as boondocking is something I see we would do occasionally using either parks/COE or Harvest Host type of stops. I've heard about the Newmar owner frustration with schematics. While I'm not a big 'do it yourselfer' (especially with anything wiring related), that may be indicative of a bigger underlying issue with Newmar.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #7
kds4, the only reason I don't own a Prevost --it is above my pay grade--others may disagree but I personally put Newell and Foretravel on much the same level when It comes to quality--Newmar--(again just my opinion) is about same level as Tiffin
They all will have problems and need something fixed, but this Forum is hands down one of the best things going if you own a
Foretravel. I'm just glad they let this old farm boy participate!!
Just my 2c worth
Chris
1999 U 320 DGFE
Build Number 5523
Chris & Elka Lang
In the field, Lonoke AR

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #8
There is another point I forgot to mention and that is if you look at PPL motorhomes web site and deisel units for sale, you will find there are 20 Newmars to 1Foreteavel  for consignment.  Yes I know there are more of the former on the road but the principle reason is actually that we owners do not want to sell normally as you really do not get a better unit for the money, so hang onto it.
I use PPL as they do more business selling Deisel motorhomes than anyone else as far as I see.
JohnH
Coachless, now use aircraft. 2003 Ford Travelair TC280 class C. Super shape. Just for 1 yr .
1994 Ford E350 ClassC,total renovation inside and out. Now sold.
2000 U295  36' Cummins 350 c/w Banks Stinger, Resonator upgrade,Solar, LED lites.Residential fridge with slide out pantry. Build 5674. Sold
ex 92 GV 022C ored Cummins. Sold
ex 95 GV240 cat 3116. Sold
2017 Mini cooper s & 2016 land Rover LR2 HSE  LUX.
jhaygarth@aol.com    SKP #130098
treat everyone as you would like to be.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #9
Some call them 36' some 37'

Used New Air at MHT, a few Mos ago. looked at it, not what we wanted given our current situation.

We had a Newmar, Dutch star 43 2011.. this was built 010 when the RV mkt was lousy.  MR.Miller owned the business lock stock & barrel.  Met him, like Bob Tiffin nice guy U felt was trust worthy  Sold 018  about 50,000 miles.

  We had big problems [$25 to 30,000] with the Cummins, that's traced to freight liner, my guess saving a few dollars on the coolant, fortunately extended warrenty covered it, with a little help from Cumins. 
Only problem that we had traced to upholstery, which after much whatevering the Mfg  gave us new, with I think some help from Newmar.  Cost us to get it put on.  This was after 6 yrs ownership
We had a variety of problems, beyond that but nothing could blame Newmar for.  Oasis, hot water system I still wonder why we had it but they were generous with there help the one time we needed them.
Thus "I think" a Newmar is a good coach..
NOW, THE PROBLEM.

Newmar has sold recently, Tiffin has sold recently, Foretravel almost died, has a newer owner.  Got to look at the new ownership,  NEW-BALL GAME.
The old owners had Quirks, Newmar Oassis , TRW electric/ hyd. Steering )OUTSTANDING ..and lots of odd things such as pull out tables,  Tiffin spot lights, internal mirrors. Slide outs that did not fit.
Mr Fore,  a weird generator, near perfect woodwork,  odd arrangements , desks.
Currently happy with Mr Fore's odd arrangement.  Hate the giant queen chair.    Our oldest, cheapest investment in a MoHo.

We had the opportunity to tour the 36'  Foretravel  at the recent F-Travel gathering Mineola TX.  Nice, but in our few min. Our thoughts not up to F travel past.
We have some friends with a 36, Vintana, Newmar, bottom of the line, solid front axle etc.  so know it won't ride as well as the FTravel  BUT we like the interior, fit finish not as good as the F Travel but not bad either.  Close to 1/2 the price.
If we had more use for a coach, we would buy it Up grade a few things over the FTravel.  And then buy better wine & Steaks.

Motor Homes some things have improved over the years, got to consider, most things that fail are not the fault of the name on the front.


Bill, Tricia, Sassy  Mostly poodle. Maybe
It,s. 5 o clock somewhere,  ?
MoHo has 3 happy days,  Buy, everything works, sell.
  Hopefully the rest are pleasant days.

Pull 05 Jeep Liberty.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #10
kds4, the only reason I don't own a Prevost --it is above my pay grade--others may disagree but I personally put Newell and Foretravel on much the same level when It comes to quality--Newmar--(again just my opinion) is about same level as Tiffin
They all will have problems and need something fixed, but this Forum is hands down one of the best things going if you own a
Foretravel. I'm just glad they let this old farm boy participate!!
Just my 2c worth
Chris

I see some things that support that opinion, especially on the tag-axle DPs, like the Spartan K4 chassis as opposed to the K3 on the Newmar TOTL King Aire. My wife (and to a lesser extent me), actually prefer the Newmar paint scheme over the Foretravel (picky, I know). However, no matter how good the inside you have to get past the outside first. Who knows? Maybe by the time we'll be in the market their color/style palate will be more appealing to us. We're also very impressed with the shower size on the Foretravel tag-axle DPs (not that 50"x32" on the King Aire/Essex models is something to sneeze at). The spa tub was a hit 'out of the park' in terms of 'wow' factor, but not sure how many customers can afford the Realm line.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #11
Some call them 36' some 37'

Used New Air at MHT, a few Mos ago. looked at it, not what we wanted given our current situation.

We had a Newmar, Dutch star 43 2011.. this was built 010 when the RV mkt was lousy.  MR.Miller owned the business lock stock & barrel.  Met him, like Bob Tiffin nice guy U felt was trust worthy  Sold 018  about 50,000 miles.

  We had big problems [$25 to 30,000] with the Cummins, that's traced to freight liner, my guess saving a few dollars on the coolant, fortunately extended warrenty covered it, with a little help from Cumins. 
Only problem that we had traced to upholstery, which after much whatevering the Mfg  gave us new, with I think some help from Newmar.  Cost us to get it put on.  This was after 6 yrs ownership
We had a variety of problems, beyond that but nothing could blame Newmar for.  Oasis, hot water system I still wonder why we had it but they were generous with there help the one time we needed them.
Thus "I think" a Newmar is a good coach..
NOW, THE PROBLEM.

Newmar has sold recently, Tiffin has sold recently, Foretravel almost died, has a newer owner.  Got to look at the new ownership,  NEW-BALL GAME.
The old owners had Quirks, Newmar Oassis , TRW electric/ hyd. Steering )OUTSTANDING ..and lots of odd things such as pull out tables,  Tiffin spot lights, internal mirrors. Slide outs that did not fit.
Mr Fore,  a weird generator, near perfect woodwork,  odd arrangements , desks.
Currently happy with Mr Fore's odd arrangement.  Hate the giant queen chair.    Our oldest, cheapest investment in a MoHo.

We had the opportunity to tour the 36'  Foretravel  at the recent F-Travel gathering Mineola TX.  Nice, but in our few min. Our thoughts not up to F travel past.
We have some friends with a 36, Vintana, Newmar, bottom of the line, solid front axle etc.  so know it won't ride as well as the FTravel  BUT we like the interior, fit finish not as good as the F Travel but not bad either.  Close to 1/2 the price.
If we had more use for a coach, we would buy it Up grade a few things over the FTravel.  And then buy better wine & Steaks.

Motor Homes some things have improved over the years, got to consider, most things that fail are not the fault of the name on the front.




I think that's a valid point. It's easy to tout or point the finger at the badge on the front of the coach but good or bad quality is likely traceable to something 'behind the badge', whether it's corporate leadership, supply chain/vendor quality issues, etc. I've read the Newmar story and heard some about the Foretravel story (was there really a shop class involved in building the first coach they actually sold)? I know Newmar was acquired. Was Foretravel acquired by a larger coach company like Newmar was or is it staying 'independent' (even with the new ownership)? I hadn't heard the founding family was no longer operating Foretravel.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #12
The Foretravel story will be told by people in a better position than me, but, having said that it is owned independently private and not some big other outlet. I believe there are still some long time workers there too.
JohnH
Coachless, now use aircraft. 2003 Ford Travelair TC280 class C. Super shape. Just for 1 yr .
1994 Ford E350 ClassC,total renovation inside and out. Now sold.
2000 U295  36' Cummins 350 c/w Banks Stinger, Resonator upgrade,Solar, LED lites.Residential fridge with slide out pantry. Build 5674. Sold
ex 92 GV 022C ored Cummins. Sold
ex 95 GV240 cat 3116. Sold
2017 Mini cooper s & 2016 land Rover LR2 HSE  LUX.
jhaygarth@aol.com    SKP #130098
treat everyone as you would like to be.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #13
I've read the Newmar story and heard some about the Foretravel story (was there really a shop class involved in building the first coach they actually sold)?

Foretravel's History [ForeForums Foretravel Motorcoach Wiki]

Quote
I know Newmar was acquired. Was Foretravel acquired by a larger coach company like Newmar was or is it staying 'independent' (even with the new ownership)? I hadn't heard the founding family was no longer operating Foretravel.

Foretravel nearly went under in 2005 (believe me, 2004 and 2005 were really bad times for the company - no parts, broken vendor relationships, many employees let go, etc.).  The company was acquired from the Fore family by a small group of investors (no history in the RV business); much of the financial backing came from partner Dane Miller (no relation to the Miller family - he was the owner of Biomet and passed away a few years ago).  Early years under the new ownership had some growing pains.  The Phenix, 2007 and newer Nimbus, IH, Realm, the MicroVilla Sprinter conversion, and the short-lived IC-37 were all designed/built under the new company.

Since it's a privately-held company, no one really knows the present situation, however several years ago, right after the Realm (and it's pompous, pretentious videos arrived  ::) ), we were at MHSRV in Alvaredo, TX talking with Donny O'Banion's father.  He referred to the Realm as their (MHSRV's) coach and that they had Foretravel build the coach for them (they certainly did the spec'ing of things).  MHSRV was purchased by start-up RV Retailer, LLC a couple of years after that and that group added RVOne to their holdings.  Those are now the exclusive dealers for Foretravel coaches (they no longer sell from the factory). 
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #14
Foretravel's History [ForeForums Foretravel Motorcoach Wiki]

Foretravel nearly went under in 2005 (believe me, 2004 and 2005 were really bad times for the company - no parts, broken vendor relationships, many employees let go, etc.).  The company was acquired from the Fore family by a small group of investors (no history in the RV business); much of the financial backing came from partner Dane Miller (no relation to the Miller family - he was the owner of Biomet and passed away a few years ago).  Early years under the new ownership had some growing pains.  The Phenix, 2007 and newer Nimbus, IH, Realm, the MicroVilla Sprinter conversion, and the short-lived IC-37 were all designed/built under the new company.

Since it's a privately-held company, no one really knows the present situation, however several years ago, right after the Realm (and it's pompous, pretentious videos arrived  ::) ), we were at MHSRV in Alvaredo, TX talking with Donny O'Banion's father.  He referred to the Realm as their (MHSRV's) coach and that they had Foretravel build the coach for them (they certainly did the spec'ing of things).  MHSRV was purchased by start-up RV Retailer, LLC a couple of years after that and that group added RVOne to their holdings.  Those are now the exclusive dealers for Foretravel coaches (they no longer sell from the factory). 

Thanks for the link. Very interesting history of Foretravel. I had heard about MHSRV and RVOne being exclusive sales outlets and wondered their connection to Foretravel. Makes sense now.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #15
Welcome, kds4. From the discussion it sounds like you are looking at a new, rather than used, coach. If this is going to be your first RV you may want to rethink that. Very few first time RV buyers get it right. Depending on their financial situation, they may trade fairly quickly, or wait a year. Unless you are somewhat experienced, you often don't know what you don't know.

We researched for a couple of years before we did anything. We started with a blank sheet of paper and jotted down what we thought we would like to do as full-timers. Then we joined several forums, some brand-specific and some more general, and asked lots of questions. We went to every RV show we could and talked to people there and at campgrounds (we were tent-camping then). We asked people why they chose a particular type (MH, TT, 5'er, etc.). As we got answers we compared that to what we thought we wanted to do. While we were researching the different types we paid attention to brands. We knew we wouldn't be buying anything anywhere close to new, but we were interested in quality. Several brands kept coming to the top of the lists, so we focused on those.

Eventually we settled on a MH as what would best suit us. The top brands for us were Bluebird, Foretravel, and Newell. There were no Newells available in our price range, but I had several 'Birds and a couple of Foretravels on our short list. We went to see the coach that was closest to us, only 300 miles away. A few days later we made an offer. We are the third owners of our Foretravel. No, we never even looked at any of the others on the list.

Going back to the quality, for a moment. There is a member of this forum who told us their story. They bought a brand-new popular brand MH for fulltime use. Within a year they traded it even-up for a 10-year-old Foretravel because they could see the difference in quality. Even if you aren't going to buy one, go look at some 10-20-year-old coaches and see how they stand up.

Given the number of 'Birds on my list, I was pretty sure that's what we would get. Boy am I glad we didn't get one! I mentioned above that you don't know what you don't know. We didn't know that Foretravel and Newell use the air bags to level the coach, while Bluebird uses hydraulic jacks. If you are parking on concrete pads that may not be much of a difference, but if you are parking on asphalt it will be. We were campground hosts with a couple who have a 'Bird. They actually had to move from one host site to the other because their jacks were sinking into the asphalt!

Last comment: spend some time talking about how you will be traveling and what you need/want to take with you. We started out thinking that we'd travel 4-5 days per month, maybe stay two months once in a while, but generally move around quite a bit. Since then we've stayed in one place for more than a month at a time several times, once for nearly six months and another for five months. We're now realizing that a towable would make more sense for they way we are now living, so this summer our Foretravel will get a for sale sign.


Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #16
Welcome, kds4. From the discussion it sounds like you are looking at a new, rather than used, coach. If this is going to be your first RV you may want to rethink that. Very few first time RV buyers get it right. Depending on their financial situation, they may trade fairly quickly, or wait a year. Unless you are somewhat experienced, you often don't know what you don't know.

We researched for a couple of years before we did anything. We started with a blank sheet of paper and jotted down what we thought we would like to do as full-timers. Then we joined several forums, some brand-specific and some more general, and asked lots of questions. We went to every RV show we could and talked to people there and at campgrounds (we were tent-camping then). We asked people why they chose a particular type (MH, TT, 5'er, etc.). As we got answers we compared that to what we thought we wanted to do. While we were researching the different types we paid attention to brands. We knew we wouldn't be buying anything anywhere close to new, but we were interested in quality. Several brands kept coming to the top of the lists, so we focused on those.

Eventually we settled on a MH as what would best suit us. The top brands for us were Bluebird, Foretravel, and Newell. There were no Newells available in our price range, but I had several 'Birds and a couple of Foretravels on our short list. We went to see the coach that was closest to us, only 300 miles away. A few days later we made an offer. We are the third owners of our Foretravel. No, we never even looked at any of the others on the list.

Going back to the quality, for a moment. There is a member of this forum who told us their story. They bought a brand-new popular brand MH for fulltime use. Within a year they traded it even-up for a 10-year-old Foretravel because they could see the difference in quality. Even if you aren't going to buy one, go look at some 10-20-year-old coaches and see how they stand up.

Given the number of 'Birds on my list, I was pretty sure that's what we would get. Boy am I glad we didn't get one! I mentioned above that you don't know what you don't know. We didn't know that Foretravel and Newell use the air bags to level the coach, while Bluebird uses hydraulic jacks. If you are parking on concrete pads that may not be much of a difference, but if you are parking on asphalt it will be. We were campground hosts with a couple who have a 'Bird. They actually had to move from one host site to the other because their jacks were sinking into the asphalt!

Last comment: spend some time talking about how you will be traveling and what you need/want to take with you. We started out thinking that we'd travel 4-5 days per month, maybe stay two months once in a while, but generally move around quite a bit. Since then we've stayed in one place for more than a month at a time several times, once for nearly six months and another for five months. We're now realizing that a towable would make more sense for they way we are now living, so this summer our Foretravel will get a for sale sign.


Great feedback. We will definitely be shopping for a pre-loved coach. I'm not interested in taking the depreciation hit for buying a new coach. We will continue to do research before pulling the trigger on anything. We are members of a few different forums/online RV related groups. We have actually looked at Foretravel coaches back to about 2010 models. All appear to have been well maintained (or well upgraded so it's not that obvious). We will be trying our best to follow the counsel of 'buy your last RV first'.

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #17
When we had bought our IH45 we were not thinking there were very many differences between our coach and an Entregra Cornerstone. or the Newmar's top of the line. Now that we have owned the IH45 and look at these other coaches it is very easy for us to notice the quality differences. between them.
2014 ih45  (4th Foretravel owned)
 1997 36' U295 Sold in 2020, owned for 19 years
  U240 36' Sold to insurance company after melting in garage fire
    33' Foretravel on Dodge Chassis  Sold very long time ago

 

Re: Foretravel FS450 versus Newmar New Aire 35

Reply #18
We looked at the Cornerstone and My wife nor I liked it as much as our old Foretravel. You can tell the difference by the sounds when you walk in. Quality construction starts with the insulation that keeps the world out. We could still hear the traffic and the crowds on the outside.. The doors are Flimsy and the cabinets are junk... Well maybe not junk but Nothing I was impressed with.

After owning a foretravel.. its hard to drive or stay in anything else. Sometimes a blind squirrel finds an acorn and boy did I when My Coach found me.