Skip to main content
Topic: Satellite Dish Choice  (Read 1767 times) previous topic - next topic

Satellite Dish Choice

When I purchased my coach, it had a Winegard Trav'ler 1000 dish, set up for Direct TV.
I wanted to use Dish, so I bought the conversion kit from Winegard.
After I installed it, the control box displayed a "motor" error code! Customer service told me I needed a new turret!!!
I bit the bullet and ordered the new turret, installed it and everything worked! I spent over $1600 for the kit and turret!
10 days after the 2 year warranty expired, the dish won't lock on any satellites!!!
Back and forth with Winegard many, many times and replacing the LNB and cables, it still won't lock!
My options are to ship the turret to Winegard for a flat rate repair for $450, or replace it with a new dish.
I am considering a King One Pro dish, it cost around $100. less than repairing the Winegard and it would be a new unit. Also it could be installed with a release mount so I could remove it from the roof and locate it for a clear shot of the satellites.
Dealing with Winegard has left a bad taste in my mouth, so I'm leaning more towards the King dish!
When the Winegard worked it was excellent, but!!!
Can I expect similar reception with a King dish?

1997 U270 36'
Build #5115
2014 Jeep Rubicon towed
1972 Boston Whaler 16'
Charlie

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #1
The King is a dome with a smaller reflector inside, so - no, reception won't be quite as good as with a Trav'ler open dish, but you can move it around independent of the coach if needed to solve that.  It will be more sensitive to rain.

Be aware, the King has a single LNB, which means the internals will move when you change channels that are on a different satellite.  There will be a slight delay.  Being a dome, it cannot receive DirecTV HD channels (works fine with Dish HD).

We have the King Tailgater with the quick-connect mount and it works very well.  No complaints (with Dish) and it's a much better value for our TV-watching style.
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #2
I installed the King KOP 4800pro and use it with both Bell (being I am in Canada) and with dish and a Wally receiver when states side. Both services come in clear and are easy to set up. I also installed a HDMI extender/splitter with 4K upscale for my 4K TVs so I could simply switch a button to go between the satellite services. I have no complaints except in heavy rain your signal is impacted.
Simple installation as well!
Peter    Alberta Canada
'98 U320 40'  Build 5359 M11 450 HP, Aqua hot, Blu Ox

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #3
Thanks for the replies!
I just purchased a King Tailgater and Quick Release Roof Mount.
The Winegard unit has been removed from the roof!
1997 U270 36'
Build #5115
2014 Jeep Rubicon towed
1972 Boston Whaler 16'
Charlie

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #4
Also thinking of the King, and a roof mount. BUT, here is a question from a person that has never had a satellite system on an RV.

If all Satellites work best when pointed toward the southern sky, before the fine tweaking. If you Park you rig and the Sat antenna needs to be rotated in order to see south, how is that done with a Fixed mount? Does the internals of the Antenna have the capability of rotating 360 deg?

Thanks, Mike
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #5
With the Dish Traveller, the system knows where to align itself to receive all 3 satellites. This is all HD and that little- 47 inch tv we have has a sharp, clear picture.

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #6
Also thinking of the King, and a roof mount. BUT, here is a question from a person that has never had a satellite system on an RV.

If all Satellites work best when pointed toward the southern sky, before the fine tweaking. If you Park you rig and the Sat antenna needs to be rotated in order to see south, how is that done with a Fixed mount? Does the internals of the Antenna have the capability of rotating 360 deg?

Thanks, Mike

Some models of King Dome, need to have the handle pointed north, to access the southern sats. To explain this in simple terms, the dish inside the dome rotates less then 360 degrees.  I ran into this problem with my neighbors coach and a King Dome tailgater.

All Winegard dome dishes rotate over 360 degrees, so no issue with that. 

I'm listed an awesome used winegard INMOTION (listen to music, and copilot watch TV while traveling) on here in a few minutes. Check Classifieds
Chris
Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #7
Thanks for all the feedback. I am at present a DTV customer at 2 homes and soon the RV, so statying with DTV at the moment. I am planning to buy the KING one Pro 4800, it is capable of both DTV and DISH with no need for upgrades or added costs if one were to decide to switch. Winegard will do DTV also, but I am told at an added cost.

All sats regardelss of make, have to start out by pointing somehwere to the south. If they are capable of 360 deg rotation it would make no differerence what direction the RV is pointed at the end of the day. However, if you are pointed due north and you are not 360 capable, then there would be issues. I have no idea of what the KOP4800 is capable of, but plan to get with King and ask. I do know the Winegard IS capable of the 360.

I have read on another forum of 1 inividual that took their old Antenna base mount, that is capable of rotation, and adapted it to mount a dome to. As that person had a system that was capable of only 270 deg rotation, using the old antenna rotator was able to do slight adjustments to get it within the southern plane, then the auto tracker took over. Just a thought if I find that KING is limited.

Chris,
Appreciate you pointing that out and looks like a fair bargain for what your selling, but im just not interested in an in motion system, to boot might would have added cost for the DTV account.

Thanks, Mike
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #8
Thanks for all the feedback. I am at present a DTV customer at 2 homes and soon the RV, so statying with DTV at the moment. I am planning to buy the KING one Pro 4800, it is capable of both DTV and DISH with no need for upgrades or added costs if one were to decide to switch. Winegard will do DTV also, but I am told at an added cost.

All sats regardelss of make, have to start out by pointing somehwere to the south. If they are capable of 360 deg rotation it would make no differerence what direction the RV is pointed at the end of the day. However, if you are pointed due north and you are not 360 capable, then there would be issues. I have no idea of what the KOP4800 is capable of, but plan to get with King and ask. I do know the Winegard IS capable of the 360.

I have read on another forum of 1 inividual that took their old Antenna base mount, that is capable of rotation, and adapted it to mount a dome to. As that person had a system that was capable of only 270 deg rotation, using the old antenna rotator was able to do slight adjustments to get it within the southern plane, then the auto tracker took over. Just a thought if I find that KING is limited.

Chris,
Appreciate you pointing that out and looks like a fair bargain for what your selling, but im just not interested in an in motion system, to boot might would have added cost for the DTV account.

Thanks, Mike


No worries Mike
I personally would go with a Winegard product, never had a lot of luck with king cruise stuff (I realize others have).Their Kingdome was a joke. We called them 'Dumb Domes" (see picture of RV satellite dome dish boneyard) All Winegards rotate more then 360, and software upgradeable. Dish and DTV make changes all the time to the satellites. Many people have had to buy several new systems over and over to get past this......Also, be a whare, that NO dome dish will be HD with DTV, you have to get the Big open face Traveler.

DTV is horrible with RV people. Dish is way more RV friendly, especially when it comes to local networks.
I was the 1st DTV dealer in the Coeur D Alene area some 27 years ago. Then went on to sell Dish also. I too had DTV on my MoHo for many years (and at home). Had a Trac Star for Inmotion, along with a Traveler for HD when parked. Paid extra for LA networks. Then ATT bought DTV, and the customer service went in the dumpster.

Switched out at home, and MoHo with Dish 2 yrs ago, never been happier. Have Dish HD in a small dome dish, both Inmotion and parked. Easy to switch local networks with single text message, no hassles. Way less cost for programing.

Funny, many like yourself never see the value to Inmotion, but once you have it, you can't figure out why you didn't have it before.Probably the cost scares them away, or they visualize driving and watching TV. I don't do that, but can listen, and the Sirus music is impeccable One of the biggest things is, when you pull into park, if you lose the signal, you just back up or move till it comes back. With a fixed dish, you don't know till you park and setup, then it's a hassel to move. Just sayin. One time we were too tired to watch the finals of the drags in Phoenix. No problem, put the inmotion on record, drove to Yuma, then watched them.I have owned /had every RV dish made known to  mankind over 40+ yrs, starting with a 6.5" Travel sat C-band. 'Point A shoot" hoping you find something.I would never own a fixed dish again. Even with the cost we paid of $1400.00 for our T4 winegard inmotion from Amazon (no reciever). But that is just me.
Chris
Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #9
MKC
My king KOP 4800
Pro does search in 360.  I have proved that several times since purchasing it with different positions  in RV sites
Peter    Alberta Canada
'98 U320 40'  Build 5359 M11 450 HP, Aqua hot, Blu Ox

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #10
Chris,
thanks for the continued details and explanations of your experience with the many different types. Much of  what you mention, really to us is just not important. Locals, we dont really care for. HD, could care less have really not seen all the attraction...I know that sounds odd to most by today standards, but we honestly just don't like it. As for the in motion, a few that I know that have them, don't speak very highly of the in motion feature unless on long straight interstate runs. Even 2 RV dealers stated the same, but would sell us whatever we wanted. We are the type that adventure mostly back roads and off the beaten path where they all have stated we would not be satisfied with the in-motion. Yes have given thought to it, and wouldn't let the cost bother me, but other than the 360 motion ability do not see where the cost would justify the features we really don't care for.

We have 2  homes, and now the RV. I fully agree since ATT acquisition, DTV has gotten even worse when it comes to customer service. BUT , I am a 16 year DTV customer with a very old plan that gives me just about anything we want for both homes for little of nothing due to loyalty perks. I have 1 account, with the 2nd home being an added receiver on the 1st home. Adding the RV will be a cost of nothing, as I will just take the DVR receiver out of the main house when we travel. IF we wanted locals on the road, for a small fee could get it, but just not important to us.  And for the most part with exception of heavy storms, does what is is supposed to do. Only mistake I have made with DTV was agree to upgrade to a HD DVR. With that we have had the most issues of anything in all these years.

Due to all the RV forum talk about DTV not being the best for the RV crowd, I did just last year check to see about a change over to dish. However, they wanted us to have 2 seperate accounts for the 2 residents, and the RV was a pay as you use it. To make the change would have more than doubled our existing approach.... We used our DVR receiver with 2 RV rentals in the past few years before buying our own RV, and both times it worked fine for us, other than having to one time move the RV as that unit would not track 360, and the other was a in the yard tripod setup, which I dont really care to have.. So I really dont understand why some folks say DTV is not friendly for those in RV's..As DTV for 16 years has worked for us, right now I plan to stay with them due to our account situation...if we start to heavily use the RV and start to see any issues, might consider a provider change. I would prefer to have a roof mount that will do a 360 if possible, but also be easily removed and tripodable in the event of heavy foilage cover issues.
Yes, WG gives us the 360 but at a hefty price for other features not really important, and VERY pricey to repair if any issues. KING, not as many features, but then much less in price. Both systems appear to have loyal users.

dicksop,
thanks for the piece of feedback, good to hear, that was my biggest concern about the their latest top unit . Emailed KING today to ask, but have not heard back yet.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #11
We have had a Trav'ler with DirecTV for 9 years. We have DirecTV at home as well. Works for us.  Probably what we like most is recording shows we like to watch.  Watch when we want, skip commercials.  But while travelling we are watching streaming TV much more.  We are paying for plenty of data anyway and for the monthly cost of DirecTV, the equipment cost and the Trav'ler cost plus you can sign up for streaming services that you want.

Lots of ways to get the entertainment you want, your choice.
Roger Engdahl and Susan Green
2001 U320 3610 #5879 (Home2) - 2014 Jeep Cherokee or 2018 F150
Hastings, MN

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #12
Chris,
thanks for the continued details and explanations of your experience with the many different types. Much of  what you mention, really to us is just not important. Locals, we dont really care for. HD, could care less have really not seen all the attraction...I know that sounds odd to most by today standards, but we honestly just don't like it. As for the in motion, a few that I know that have them, don't speak very highly of the in motion feature unless on long straight interstate runs. Even 2 RV dealers stated the same, but would sell us whatever we wanted. We are the type that adventure mostly back roads and off the beaten path where they all have stated we would not be satisfied with the in-motion. Yes have given thought to it, and wouldn't let the cost bother me, but other than the 360 motion ability do not see where the cost would justify the features we really don't care for.

We have 2  homes, and now the RV. I fully agree since ATT acquisition, DTV has gotten even worse when it comes to customer service. BUT , I am a 16 year DTV customer with a very old plan that gives me just about anything we want for both homes for little of nothing due to loyalty perks. I have 1 account, with the 2nd home being an added receiver on the 1st home. Adding the RV will be a cost of nothing, as I will just take the DVR receiver out of the main house when we travel. IF we wanted locals on the road, for a small fee could get it, but just not important to us.  And for the most part with exception of heavy storms, does what is is supposed to do. Only mistake I have made with DTV was agree to upgrade to a HD DVR. With that we have had the most issues of anything in all these years.

Due to all the RV forum talk about DTV not being the best for the RV crowd, I did just last year check to see about a change over to dish. However, they wanted us to have 2 seperate accounts for the 2 residents, and the RV was a pay as you use it. To make the change would have more than doubled our existing approach.... We used our DVR receiver with 2 RV rentals in the past few years before buying our own RV, and both times it worked fine for us, other than having to one time move the RV as that unit would not track 360, and the other was a in the yard tripod setup, which I dont really care to have.. So I really dont understand why some folks say DTV is not friendly for those in RV's..As DTV for 16 years has worked for us, right now I plan to stay with them due to our account situation...if we start to heavily use the RV and start to see any issues, might consider a provider change. I would prefer to have a roof mount that will do a 360 if possible, but also be easily removed and tripodable in the event of heavy foilage cover issues.
Yes, WG gives us the 360 but at a hefty price for other features not really important, and VERY pricey to repair if any issues. KING, not as many features, but then much less in price. Both systems appear to have loyal users.

dicksop,
thanks for the piece of feedback, good to hear, that was my biggest concern about the their latest top unit . Emailed KING today to ask, but have not heard back yet.

I would just make sure your receiver is compatible with whatever dish you buy. Most of the HD/DVR's both DTV and Dish are Hybrid. They will not work with dome dishes. Only the Traveler with correct Dish or DTV Hybrid LNB. Travelers come that way now standard.Otherwise it takes a basic receiver. Winegard lists what receivers work with what on their website. King, I don't know.
And I will bet you lunch (been there done that) DTV won't authorize a new basic receiver on the same account, only as a separate RV account. Was the final reason I dumped DTV.They require the purchase of the receiver through them, and a work order # to get it authorized. Even if you buy an unopened new DTV receiver from say Ebay. It takes a work order.
But sounds like you have it all figured out, so hope it works out for you.
Cheers
Chris
Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #13
I would just make sure your receiver is compatible with whatever dish you buy. Most of the HD/DVR's both DTV and Dish are Hybrid. They will not work with dome dishes. Only the Traveler with correct Dish or DTV Hybrid LNB. Travelers come that way now standard.Otherwise it takes a basic receiver. Winegard lists what receivers work with what on their website. King, I don't know.
And I will bet you lunch (been there done that) DTV won't authorize a new basic receiver on the same account, only as a separate RV account. Was the final reason I dumped DTV.They require the purchase of the receiver through them, and a work order # to get it authorized. Even if you buy an unopened new DTV receiver from say Ebay. It takes a work order.
But sounds like you have it all figured out, so hope it works out for you.
Cheers
Chris


My 1st home main unit, ive already used twice on the road in rental units in the past 5 years. Once I know was a WG, roof mount. The other I cannot honestly remember what it was other than it was a tripod and white. Moving fwd in time, if I look at both WG and KG's recommended recievers for DTV, mine is on both lists. As is my 1 standard unit.
As for a basic reciever, I just 6 months ago had to replace the 1 that I still have, we had a lightning strike and it took it out. ( dummy me did not have that one on a surge strip) Yes I did have to pay for it but it was not  much. That one stays at our 2nd home and is rarely used, DTV is aware of it and has no problem with it. All 3 of my rcvrs are on the same account, and no special charge for the 2nd home rcvr other than the monthly rcvr charge on the base account. But like I stated earlier, I have been with them for a very long time. DTV DOES have a loyalty department for long time accounts (over 7 years I was once quoted), and there are all sorts of perks if you only ask for them and ARE in fact a long time dedicated customer. The occasional reference to switch to Dish after being a loyal long term customer, doesnt seem to hurt on occasion either.

 NOW If I were to call them and ask to add another to be specific to just an RV, yes they might state I have to put it on a 2nd account, but I dont know that for sure. But, why would I even want to do that? We take the rv out a few times a year, unplugging 2 cables and moving it to the RV for the trip is no big thing. Its right up there with making sure I have my pistol, spare underwear and a bottle of wild turkey. But like other things, I guess a personal choice some just want to leave it in there. I get it, just not important to me. Having one to leave in the rig, that is where maybe the DISH, use as you go, would be a good thing. Maybe dont have it all figured out, but so far what we have use recvr wise has alwasy done the job. Just wanted to know about the capabilities of the various types of sat dishes, and any that would not do a 360 track. I think WG is a slick setup, but for some of the features I really dont care to have, and a very expensive cost if issues, a bit on the pricey side. But for those that find they really want it, your classified is a great value and somebody will surely jump on it..

Roger,


[Political comments have been deleted from this post.  Politics are NOT PERMITTED on Foreforums - Michelle]
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #14
FYI for those interested in knowing after a contact with manufacturer King on a KOH 4800.

Thank you for your interest in our product. The unit rotates in a full circle. Maximum length of cable you can use is 50ft of cable.

Help Mail
KING
Simply better, by design.
kingconnect.com

Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #15
That sounds great, and you have what you want figured out Just a comment on the inmotion tracking. Dish looks at a much higher look angle then DTV, so it does a bunch better job then DTV with any RV dish. But I still wouldn't kick a DTV inmotion out of bed for eating chips.

Realize all the tour buses have tracking dishes with multiple receivers. Have for years. How do I know? I have worked on several when they came through town on the way to Seattle, or back east. I talked to the drivers all the time. Look at any tour bus now as you are driving, yup Winegard T4's or a Tracvisions.

I personally installed maybe 10 inmotions on FT's, talked to many of the people later, and they loved them. They track excellent, work, and stay locked on, 95% of the time.Even my old DTV Trac Star did fine. Yes, in areas of lots of trees, they will lock and unlock. But all the newer ones have GPS, so they stay looking/tracking in the correct direction, till they are unblocked. I can get off the freeway, go 380 off the ramp, it never misses a beat, unless I go under the freeway, in that case you get a blip.

Those people or dealers that gave you the negative info, either never had one, or were talking about older units that didn't have GPS. Many units were terrible (especially the Kingdomes), because of the lack of GPS, so as soon as they lost the signal, they had to start searching for it again. If they were so bad, why would Tracvision, and Winegard keep manufacturing them, and why are they so expensive.

So I didn't post this to try and talk you into an inmotion,I realize it's not for everyone, and you have stated your reasons. I posted it because the info you received is not correct on inmotion, and I want it here in the search records for those that may want an inmotion in the future. What I say is true, as we have had inmotion DTV and Dish for over 10 yrs, and completely love it.

BTW, I was also a Loyal DTV customer for over 25 yrs (started after I gave up my free dealer showroom subscription). I had all the hidden phone numbers, always negotiated a better price every two yrs of up to $60.00 month .Most the time it's the luck of the draw to get the right person. Many tricks to that, what time of day you call, what you say when you call etc. Otherwise you may be talking to India, or somewhere else to someone that really doesn't speak clear english, or really understand what's really going on. You may spend 10 minutes if your lucky, or 2-3 hrs.

Glad your going to get what you want. Be sure to post back here, so we can hear how it all worked out when done.

Cheers
Chris
Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #16

No worries Mike
I personally would go with a Winegard product, never had a lot of luck with king cruise stuff (I realize others have).Their Kingdome was a joke. We called them 'Dumb Domes" (see picture of RV satellite dome dish boneyard) All Winegards rotate more then 360, and software upgradeable. Dish and DTV make changes all the time to the satellites. Many people have had to buy several new systems over and over to get past this......Also, be a whare, that NO dome dish will be HD with DTV, you have to get the Big open face Traveler.

DTV is horrible with RV people. Dish is way more RV friendly, especially when it comes to local networks.
I was the 1st DTV dealer in the Coeur D Alene area some 27 years ago. Then went on to sell Dish also. I too had DTV on my MoHo for many years (and at home). Had a Trac Star for Inmotion, along with a Traveler for HD when parked. Paid extra for LA networks. Then ATT bought DTV, and the customer service went in the dumpster.

Switched out at home, and MoHo with Dish 2 yrs ago, never been happier. Have Dish HD in a small dome dish, both Inmotion and parked. Easy to switch local networks with single text message, no hassles. Way less cost for programing.

Funny, many like yourself never see the value to Inmotion, but once you have it, you can't figure out why you didn't have it before.Probably the cost scares them away, or they visualize driving and watching TV. I don't do that, but can listen, and the Sirus music is impeccable One of the biggest things is, when you pull into park, if you lose the signal, you just back up or move till it comes back. With a fixed dish, you don't know till you park and setup, then it's a hassel to move. Just sayin. One time we were too tired to watch the finals of the drags in Phoenix. No problem, put the inmotion on record, drove to Yuma, then watched them.I have owned /had every RV dish made known to  mankind over 40+ yrs, starting with a 6.5" Travel sat C-band. 'Point A shoot" hoping you find something.I would never own a fixed dish again. Even with the cost we paid of $1400.00 for our T4 winegard inmotion from Amazon (no receiver). But that is just me.
Chris
I had to break a smile when I read about the Travel Sat in your post. I think you meant to type it has a 6'5" dish.
I had a 86 Winnabago Elandan that had a Travel Sat mounted to the roof, what a monstrosity. It definitely got everybody's attention even when retracted. When raised it could not be overlooked. My Foretravel came with the in motion Tracvison After a lot of struggle I was able to get it to work well. I tried to never complain because I had the Travel Sat experience to remember.
Perfectly level the RV, Raise the 6' dish with the corded remote and point it at the southern sky, start scanning to locate a satellite. then pan the dish and look for another satellite and on and on. With no guide as to what was on each satellite it was an endless search that would occupy me for hours. The only real satisfaction was actually getting something on the screen.

1995 U320C SE 40'
Jeep 4x4 Commander - Limited - Hemi
"The Pack"  Yogi and Diesel our Airedales -  Charlie our Boxer/Akita mix. Gone but NEVER forgotten Jake our yellow Lab.
NRA Law Enforcement Firearms instructor - Handgun/shotgun
Regional Firearms instructor for national Armored Transp. Co.

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #17
I had to break a smile when I read about the Travel Sat in your post. I think you meant to type it has a 6'5" dish.
I had a 86 Winnabago Elandan that had a Travel Sat mounted to the roof, what a monstrosity. It definitely got everybody's attention even when retracted. When raised it could not be overlooked. My Foretravel came with the in motion Tracvison After a lot of struggle I was able to get it to work well. I tried to never complain because I had the Travel Sat experience to remember.
Perfectly level the RV, Raise the 6' dish with the corded remote and point it at the southern sky, start scanning to locate a satellite. then pan the dish and look for another satellite and on and on. With no guide as to what was on each satellite it was an endless search that would occupy me for hours. The only real satisfaction was actually getting something on the screen.



Great story. Yup, 6.5 and 6'5" is what I meant.They were fun. I was actually Nor Cal's largest Travel Sat dealer for a bit. My brother in-law went on work at Travel Sat with Frank Calson in Palm Springs, who bought the company from Dometic.Then went on to build DTV systems on the same platform (motorized, but hunt to find), but later built a self searching version. I use to sell him $75K in DTV receivers at a wack, because he never set up with them, so he couldn't sell his systems. I got all the advertising residuals for the purchases, and frank activated them in my account, so big programing residual checks came in also. Was good for both of us.
I took one off, and installed a 5' Moto sat on Mike Douglas coach, when he was filling basic Instinct in San Francisco. Wild story. See pics.and my old Exploder (nickname for explorer) with one.
Yup, the Tracvision inmotion, was a bit techie, and hard to get tech help with. You also needed to know computer to work on it. Kinda over engineered.But sure I'm preaching at the choir with you. 8)
Chris
Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #18
A reminder - NO POLITICAL COMMENTARY is permitted on Foreforums.  I deleted a paragraph from one of the posts. 
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #19
Chris,

thanks for the continued tech feedback. 1 of those dealers was actually MOT where I purchased our FT just 3 months ago, 1 tech, the sales guy and a customer in the room all made comments on the inmotion, when I asked the opinions about the sytem. I had heard stories in the past where yes as you state it could very well have been related to older pre GPS tracking tech. Non of the comments that I ever recall hearing were about any specific brand or system, only the ability or lack thereof of the in motion type of systems. I have no doubt with todays technology, many things are probably much better.
I have no doubt with your background in Sat systems, you have seen it all and I do appreciate what you've been saying.

Alot of my decsion is based on where I am with multiple homes, and the deal I have gotten for a long time. Along with the fact the DTV has just alwasy worked for us. I do realize there are many out there that have gotten a raw deal out of that company, but I have heard just as many say the same about DISH. For me its whats best for me at the moment.

I havent bought yet but plan too soon. Yes will give fedback good or bad after I do and use.

WOW... 6' on the roof, I dont think I have ever seen that on a personal unit, maybe a film crew or two. I have had them, even back in the day a few 10' in the yard units. Dont miss those monstors one bit. The hardest part about owning one was what to do with the thing when you upgraded to smaller and there was no where to dump them. I did have one 10' All alluminum Chapparel that when I took it down netted me $250 at the salvage yard.

Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #20
When I bought the Winnebago with the 6' dish on the roof the previous owner had never used it.
He told me the story of the first time he TRIED to use it.
He used the wired remote to raise the dish then discovered that he could not maneuver the dish. He had no tools with him so he was forced to leave the campground with the dish extended. He drove VERY slowly to a store where he could buy some tools to disconnect the motors and lower the dish manually. What a sight that must have been.
With no advise on the dishes operation from the previous owner except the dish and receivers manuals, it was a frustrating learning curve. One that was MUCH easier to deal with 40 years ago than would be now.
Old age and bad temperament seem to go hand in hand.
1995 U320C SE 40'
Jeep 4x4 Commander - Limited - Hemi
"The Pack"  Yogi and Diesel our Airedales -  Charlie our Boxer/Akita mix. Gone but NEVER forgotten Jake our yellow Lab.
NRA Law Enforcement Firearms instructor - Handgun/shotgun
Regional Firearms instructor for national Armored Transp. Co.

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #21
Mike in AL,

We had a tailgater with Dish for a few years and it was OK. But, we just stream to our 4K TV from our iPhone not only from a campground but also while underway. Thousands of places to stream for free in just about every country. Works anywhere you have cell reception. $5 more a month gives us Canada and Mexico coverage. Makes navigating in any domestic or foreign city easy with real time traffic. Our bill is $89/mo for both iPhones unlimited.

Pierce
Pierce and Gaylie Stewart
'93 U300/36 WTBI
Detroit 6V-92TA Jake
1140 watts on the roof
SBFD (ret)

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #22
When I bought the Winnebago with the 6' dish on the roof the previous owner had never used it.
He told me the story of the first time he TRIED to use it.
He used the wired remote to raise the dish then discovered that he could not maneuver the dish. He had no tools with him so he was forced to leave the campground with the dish extended. He drove VERY slowly to a store where he could buy some tools to disconnect the motors and lower the dish manually. What a sight that must have been.
With no advise on the dishes operation from the previous owner except the dish and receivers manuals, it was a frustrating learning curve. One that was MUCH easier to deal with 40 years ago than would be now.
Old age and bad temperament seem to go hand in hand.

Picture of the one on my Explorer, was mounted way to the back, and facing forward. The only way I could get it to fit. I had it deployed at my house, getting ready to take a trip. I needed to go fuel, so as I was getting ready, I unhooked the shore power, then drove off. Heard a funny noise, so I stopped. Yup, the dish was straight up, and I ripped the gear drive out (they were 120 volt operated).It was laying over the back of the coach.

Fortunately being a dealer, I went to the shop, and took the motor out of another new unit. I think they were like $1800.00 wholesale for the whole Travelsat 6.5' unit, then another $800.00-$1500.00 for a C Band receiver. Sold the heck out of them.

You guys don't understand how great you have it, with $300.00 systems. But programing with HBO and all was $30.00! C-band had 20+ programers, so it was competitive for programing, and lots of stuff was free.

I installed a 5' crank up one (best made brand) at the FMC rally at Pomona fairgrounds, guys were drunk as a skunk. Next week they called me, to replace the dish face. They went under a overpass with it up!

Later, a complete 5' Moto-sat, fully automatic C-band was $6K installed, sold lots of those in the Thousand Trails parks.

Picture of my display trailer at Thousand Trails Windsor Calif. with 5' crank up, and 5' Motosat automatic. My Southwind and shop van with 5' crank ups at Thousand Trails at Russian River California

Fun Times
Chris

Chris and Tammy White  CDA Idaho
Previous owners 1997 U295 36' 3126 Cat 300 HP Build # 4998
Former Foretravel tech & RVIA certified tech
Former owner Custom Satellite home/RV satellites 
Former owner Vans LTD  van conversions
Unemployed, panhandler, drag racer NHRA #6348

 

Re: Satellite Dish Choice

Reply #23
Mine had the wire dish.
I do admit that I did enjoy the never ending search for TV content. I also enjoyed that the signal was direct to you. If you were watching the national news you saw everything UN-filtered. You would see the news anchors between commercials and hear everything they were saying. Actually this was far more interesting than the show itself.
1995 U320C SE 40'
Jeep 4x4 Commander - Limited - Hemi
"The Pack"  Yogi and Diesel our Airedales -  Charlie our Boxer/Akita mix. Gone but NEVER forgotten Jake our yellow Lab.
NRA Law Enforcement Firearms instructor - Handgun/shotgun
Regional Firearms instructor for national Armored Transp. Co.