Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Topic: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis (Read 2150 times) previous topic - next topic

Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

February 21, 2013, 04:57:17 pm

It is great to see so many newbie's and wannabee's on the Forum, discovering and exploring the FT vs. SOB (Some Other Brand) qualities! And their questions help us all in many ways. It really takes me back to our initial (way conservative) decision making before we threw our hard earned cash into the Foretravel pot.
Longer term FT owners passionately understand the positives and benefits associated with Foretravel ownership, but why is it often so difficult to weed out the Foretravel vs. SOB facts from the fiction? "Back in the day" before the internet and long before the Yahoo and Foreforums, we (I?) wanted to follow some sort of a process to make data gathering more efficient. The process would be much easier today, in the "Information Age", but the attached "common sense process" works even better today in sorting out FT advantages over SOB pitfalls. It's still a lot of work and one must be a compulsive cautionary or conservative decision maker to enjoy it. If you make major spending decisions with the emotional side of your brain instead of the logical side, this won't be your "cup of tea".

I tried to put the attached dissertation into the body of this post but it gets "mangled" in the browser to FoFum transition, therefore it is included as an attached *.pdf file.

Anyway. It's my take on how to explore the benefits of FT vs. SOB ownership (as well as how to learn or continuously improve, following any problem, unexpected event or incident that you may experience). I hope that it may be of some use to you and that I don't bore you to tears with my logical side!

Neal

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #1 – February 21, 2013, 05:42:20 pm

Quote from: Neal Pillsbury – February 21, 2013, 04:57:17 pm

I tried to put the attached dissertation into the body of this post but it gets "mangled" in the browser to FoFum transition, therefore it is included as an attached *.pdf file.

Best translation I can do on short notice.

Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis
It is great to see so many newbie's and wannabee's on the Forum, discovering and exploring the FT vs. SOB qualities! And their questions help us all in many ways. It really takes me back to our initial (way conservative) decision before we threw our hard earned cash into the Foretravel pot.

Longer term FT owners passionately understand the positives and benefits associated with Foretravel ownership, but why is it often so difficult to weed out the Foretravel vs. SOB facts from the fiction? "Back in the day" before the internet and long before the Yahoo and Foreforums, we (I?) wanted to follow some sort of a process to make data gathering more efficient. The process would be much easier today, in the "Information Age", but the following "common sense process" works even better today in sorting out FT advantages over SOB pitfalls. It's still a lot of work and one must be a compulsive cautionary or conservative decision maker to enjoy it. If you make major spending decisions with the emotional side of your brain instead of the logical side, this won't be your "cup of tea".

What follows is a little lengthy, so I apologize in advance and warn off those of you who aren't seriously interested.

Part 1: I had a 37 year career in an industry (Nuclear) where striving for Continuous Improvement and ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS and Failure Mode Effects Analysis (FMEA) was/is a way of life. As a result, we (DW and I) did extensive analysis of FT's vs. SOB's prior to our "Last and First" motorhome purchase in 1998. That analysis has served us well, we've learned a whole bunch more since then and we're as (or more) pleased today than ever.

Part 2: Beyond our own personal enjoyment of our FT, we have thoroughly enjoyed meeting and living full time (6+ months a year) with our many motor homing friends. We especially enjoy "RiverBend - the friendliest Motorcoach Resort in the Nation". One of the many strengths of this resort is that RiverBend has a highly active and non-partisan social network, nicer than any we've experienced anywhere across the nation. The core reason is that RiverBend has always promoted and thrived on volunteerism vs. paid employees (we enjoy volunteered professional level services in the management, restaurant, recreation, maintenance, entertainment areas, etc. - all managed and staffed by owners and long term lessees). Because I enjoy meeting and helping newcomers, I contribute my part by volunteering as a Resort Ambassador/Tour Guide and I have organized/led the Motorcycle Club for several years, spending at least two days (and often more) each week. Brenda does the Library and Craft Shows management and staffing.

Part 3: As a result of plentiful contacts and because I enjoy "wrenching", I frequently hear and become involved with helping resolve SOB coach problems. I'm continually amazed at how fortunate we FT owners are in comparison to the SOB population. Based on a lot of the SOB problems I've seen/become involved with, one would think that FT's would be an easy sell. But it frequently doesn't pan out that way. Even after careful FT and ForeForum ambassadorship, SOB owners end up never seriously evaluating a Foretravel before they trade. They just trade their generic problems (gp's) with Tiffin for Newmar gp's or their Winnebago for Fleetwood gp's or their Travel Supreme for Country Coach or Monaco or SMC or Bluebird gp's or their Newell for Prevost Conversion gp's, etc., etc. Many of their coaches, whether purchased new or used, are several years old now and their "unresolved problems list" is many times longer than their PDI problems list. Some appear to be tens of thousands of dollars shy of final resolution or reasonable satisfaction. Which gets me to the crux of my post:

Part 4: I've long tried to understand why these seemingly successful, intelligent people make such poorly informed/researched decisions on the coaches that they buy.

Of course some are easy to understand in that they are just plain CRAZY-STUPID to reality, or they need to have their GLITZ & BLING at any cost, or they are TOO WEALTHY TO CARE or be bothered, or some, I think, just enjoy being the MARTYR, but I'm more interested in the many others that seem to seriously want "a high quality coach", in FT terms, but never really evaluate a Foretravel, new or used, buying SOB's, loaded with generic problems, for more money, instead. I understand that it can be confusing and can involve a lot of hard work sorting out facts from fiction.

I often conclude that the root cause of THEIR ongoing problems is that many SOB buyers just don't know HOW to do a disciplined comparison analysis, such as a Root Cause (based) Comparison Analysis (RCA) or they just don't want to make the effort, relying entirely on their (or their wife's) whims and emotions instead.
When SOB owners start talking about their disappointments with their coaches, I've sometimes found that helping them do a simple "5 Whys" Root Cause Analysis (RCA) earns more respect and lasting impact than anything else.

Rather than jumping to easy, EMOTIONAL conclusions, using a simple RCA often leads to a very different root cause determination. I urge them to write down a clear problem statement and then ask several levels of WHY? After trying it a few times, they better understand the Root Cause of their problem, getting out of an emotional "quick-judgmentloop" and it helps them find their way out of their SOB "do-loop" problems. To demonstrate the process, here's a fictional (whimsical) example:

Problem Statement: I have to buy a new car, because mine is becoming dangerously unreliable.
I was on my way back home from a trip to town when my car quit, stranding me in the middle of a busy three lane highway.

1. Why did your car quit?
- Because it ran out of gas.

2. Why did it run out of gas?
- Because I didn't buy any gas on my way into town.

3. Why didn't you buy any gas?
- Because I didn't have enough money.

4. Why didn't you have enough money?
- Because I lost it all last night in a poker game.

5. Why did you lose your money in last night's poker game?
- Because I'm not very good at "bluffing" when I don't have a good hand.

Root Cause of the Problem: Bluffing Skills deficiency
Problem Solution: Keep the car (Sometimes you can get to the root cause in fewer than five steps, sometimes it takes more).

Now for a real world, true example:
Problem Statement: I want to use Coach Washing Co. XYZ, but another Coach owner advises " XYZ totaled my NEW coach. Don't ever use them to wash your coach!"

1. Why was your NEW coach totaled?
- Because it caught fire.

2. Why did it catch fire?
- Because XYZ was power washing my engine.

3. Why was XYZ power washing your engine?
- Because I pointed out to them that I had a buildup of dirt on one side of the engine.

4. Why was there a buildup of dirt?
- Something was leaking.

5. Why was something leaking?
- Because a fuel return line fitting was improperly crimped (at, or for, the factory?) and had a small leak.

6. How did that lead to XYZ starting a fire? (Why is exchangeable with What, Where, How and When)

- The poorly crimped return fuel hose was forced out of the fitting during the pressure washing. Fuel then got into the electronics below the leak and the electronics shorted out. The sparking electronics combusted raw diesel fuel. Fuel continued to siphon out of the full fuel tank, further fueling the fire. Bolt-cutting-off the battery cables at the batteries finally stopped the arcing and the fire stopped reigniting. Flames were higher than the roof of the coach for many minutes before the fire was eventually turned and brought under control.

Root Cause of Problem: Defective crimp of a fuel line fitting (for, or at, the SOB factory?) on a new coach production line.

Problem Solution: XYZ is perfectly acceptable to wash/detail a coach. If you do not have the skills, use a reputable diesel repair shop to address engine leaks and (steam) clean your engine.

You get my point. Doing some quick, rudimentary Root Cause Analysis (RCA) can often get you beyond the owner's emotions and closer to the actual cause of a problem.

Before we bought our coach we were definitely having a hard time sorting out the "wheat from the chafe" with all of the multiple brands and owners that we were talking to. I eventually came around to using the more laborious but more common sense nuclear industry learning techniques (every problem, incident or adverse event is a PERFECT opportunity to learn from and improve safety and quality).

Thus, I started asking coach owners a standard "warm-up" question: "If you had to chose one, what thing do you like the most about your coach?" Then, if they were obviously amiable and wanted to continue: "If you had to chose one, what problem has caused you the most grief with your coach?" And then, as appropriate, start detailing that problem with the "Why's", to try to get as close to a good Root Causes as you can. Some conversations, as expected, were duds while the more fruitful ones went on for hours and even years as we bumbled along to our decision. Of course, while it's still fresh, write down some notes or the details will become lost in a serious search.

If some of you chose to use this approach, hopefully, some interest in RCA might be passed on to SOB owner's and they in turn might become more interested in FT's, and see a reasonable way to sort out the "facts vs. fiction"/"SOB's vs. FT's". Eventually that might lead to even more gains in the FT vs. SOB explorations.

It strikes me as amazing that we FoFums devote much (most?) of our energies and imagination to continuously tweaking and personalizing our Foretravels. In contrast, many of our SOB brethren are so thoroughly consumed in tedious "do-loops", trying to prioritize and work down their on-going problems list to a tolerable level, that they have no creative energies or inclinations left for anything else. And, many seem to take for granted that all brands are created equal in terms of endless problems. Others seem to feel that they just have a "lemon" or they are having a bit of "hard luck". They never see that there ARE significant differences in design and construction quality, SOB vs. FT, even when it is directly pointed out to them.

I talked with an SOB Owner, yesterday, who was blaming Camping World for several on-going AC associated problems;

- Nine months old, high end Newmar,

- Failed rear air conditioner internals replaced by the original Newmar sales and service center (Warranty),

-Motor failed again,

-Next replaced (no Warranty) by Camping World (100°F+ weather and many miles from Newmar),

-Original model AC motor/compressor internals were no longer available (per CW),

- CW installed a complete replacement AC that was not compatible with the installed AC controller (a two vs. three speed motors issue) and CW plus Newmar couldn't figure out how to reconfigure,

-AC controller changed out at another Newmar sales and service center,

- But there, Newmar discovered that the original installed motor power wiring (gauge) was not compatible with the new AC unit installed by Camping World (was likely the root cause of the original AC motor failures......running voltage, at the motor, was too low in some or all speeds because the wiring was inadequate to begin with?),

- Newmar installed new, proper gauge wires,

-Now the ceiling is damaged and remains unsightly,

- The overhead lights in the bedroom and the backup camera don't work and there's a three week wait until the next available Newmar service date.

-One unhappy SOB owner, blaming CW, about eight months into this problem, still professes to be a Newmar fan,

-He has a LONG list of other, unresolved problems dating back to his new coach PDI!

Anyway. That's my take on how to explore the benefits of FT vs. SOB ownership (as well as how to learn or continuously improve, following any problem, unexpected event or incident that you may experience).
I hope that this may be of some use to some of you and that I didn't bore you to tears!
Neal

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #2 – February 21, 2013, 05:52:03 pm

Quote from: Barry Beam – February 21, 2013, 05:42:20 pm

Best translation I can do on short notice.

Thanks Barry,
I still don't understand why I have so much difficulty making the copy transition from MS Word, through any of my Browsers (FF, IE, Chrome), to a paste into FoFums, myself
Neal

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #3 – February 21, 2013, 06:07:25 pm

Neal and Barry, I love it. I think all of us are salesmen for FT and every time I talk with a wannabe I run into the same dialog that you have. I do not have the best looking, most upgraded coach but after years of exposure and with the info from this and the old Yahoo site I THINK that I will be able to keep the old girl on the road for a long time to come. I would really like to see some sort of data on how many 18 year old SOB's are still rolling. Even with some parts getting hard to find the FT quality still allows me ( and us ) to keep em going.
JMHO
Gary B

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #4 – February 21, 2013, 06:10:29 pm

Neal. I have also had trouble at times converting a document from MS Word into the forum. I use Google Chrome also.
My method, Type it in Word but save it as a plain text doc. Then copy and paste to FF BUT, before you POST IT save it as a DRAFT. Then reopen and edit if needed and then post. On any long document I do this, probably not necessary for the short reply.
Gary B

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #5 – February 21, 2013, 06:19:09 pm

No matter what brand of anything one buys, there is always the possibility of getting a piece of junk. There is probably a similar probability of getting something that is absolutely perfect. Most items will fall somewhere between the two extremes. When one buys a brand new coach, one should expect that there will be some problems (after all, imperfect people build them), but that those problems should be taken care of fairly quickly and professionally. Buying a used coach, though, is a completely different issue.

When one buys a used coach, as we must, looking at coaches that have a reputation for high quality is just the starting point. How well the coach has been maintained is just as important as starting with a good foundation. For us, another filter was the owners forum. We wanted to buy a brand that has a fair number of owners "getting their hands dirty" as they maintain their coaches. There are some brands where the only "tool" the owners have is a credit card with an extremely high limit.

We're looking at 'Birds, Foretravels, and Newells. Tiffins and Newmars were originally on our list, until we found out that they weren't really competing with the three on our short list. As near as we can tell, those three were more or less head-to-head competitors, with the Foretravel being the lowest priced of the three, although not by much. I'm pretty sure that we will be well pleased with whatever we end up with. The coach we buy will be one of those three brands, well maintained, and priced in our price range. We're actively searching, and we know the right coach is out there. Whether we find it today or next year, we'll find it.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #6 – February 21, 2013, 06:20:57 pm

Gary, take a look at PPL. Scroll to the bottom of the DP list, and see what you see. Not much.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #7 – February 21, 2013, 06:39:56 pm

It strikes me as amazing that we FoFums devote much (most?) of our energies and imagination to continuously tweaking and personalizing our Foretravels. In contrast, many of our SOB brethren are so thoroughly consumed in tedious "do-loops", trying to prioritize and work down their on-going problems list to a tolerable level, that they have no creative energies or inclinations left for anything else. And, many seem to take for granted that all brands are created equal in terms of endless problems.

Neal,
Gotta say I enjoyed the above a lot, seems as you were talking to me directly, as that about fits my energys.
Maybe I am just lucky, but in the past 4+ years, this has been a trouble free coach.
Thanks for the posting.
Dave M

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #8 – February 21, 2013, 07:54:53 pm

Quote

I have also had trouble at times converting a document from MS Word into the forum.

Quote

I still don't understand why I have so much difficulty making the copy transition from MS Word

First the good news is this issue is being worked on and in a future revision of the forum software it will be much improved. Now future and paid software means when its ready, and future for free / open source software is as people have time to work on it and its ready ... meaning $:-\$

Why this is so difficult is that all of these programs speak different languages.

When you copy from Word to the clipboard it is copied it on the clipboard as rich text data (my guess)

When you then paste it in to a browser window, the browser says I don't speak rich text so I'll convert it to HTML as best I can and however I want. Each browser (and browser revision) will do this conversion as it likes, meaning the HTML will be different for each browser.

Then the forum software goes, well I don't really speak fluent HTML, nor do I store posts in that format, so I'll convert it to my language (BBC) as best I can

So its a game of tin can telephone, and a great looking post in Word can get pretty mangled by the time all these translations are done. The new software update is much much better in doing this translation, its just not ready yet!

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #9 – February 21, 2013, 08:30:07 pm

Quote from: Steve – February 21, 2013, 07:54:53 pm

......................................The new software update is much much better in doing this translation, its just not ready yet!............................

Thanks Steve. I intuitively suspected that, but having it in words is much more comforting.
No rush.
Coping mechanisms working fine and we all appreciate the GOLDEN GEESE!
Neal

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #10 – February 21, 2013, 08:42:31 pm

When we looked at all the great coaches at the show, lots of lights and mirrors, I thought "What will it look like in 15 years?" Having seen a 15 year old Foretravel as well as the SOBs it was an easy decision to make. Just how many SOBs go back to the factory to be updated? That is the true, real world test.

Keith

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #11 – February 21, 2013, 08:42:46 pm

Just so those doing detailed research get a true representation, my FT has not been anywhere near trouble free. In fact, it has given me about the same amount of trouble and needed repairs as my previous '06 Monaco coach. Being an '07 coach, some of this I expect but too many items have been a result of poor assembly and QC.

In my humble opinion, the best thing Foretravel has going for it is that it is a smaller operation where service and sales work closely with customers and will address problems. The bigger outfits just can't give that level of service when the sales force are RV dealerships primarily in the business to sell units and sell them quickly.

I think this is part of the mystic of why so many return to FOT and grow loyal to the brand.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #12 – February 21, 2013, 08:48:56 pm

Brrving,

But how much trouble is the Foretravel and how much the parts manufactured by others? If everyone uses Dometic a/c units for example that should be a wash for comparison purposes. It's build and design quality that matter. Does the coach have good enough "bones" to be long lasting?

Keith

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #13 – February 21, 2013, 09:43:57 pm

Quote from: Keith and Joyce – February 21, 2013, 08:48:56 pm

Brrving,

But how much trouble is the Foretravel and how much the parts manufactured by others? If everyone uses Dometic a/c units for example that should be a wash for comparison purposes. It's build and design quality that matter. Does the coach have good enough "bones" to be long lasting?

Keith

Keith,
You've got the idea!
If the root cause is in a universal Dometic AC model, then many brands may likely have the problem. If Dometic made a proprietary model for coach brand XYZ, then the field of influence is greatly reduced. If the Root Cause is undersized power wiring or the coach company can't or won't produce engineered wiring drawings or the coach company is simply unresponsive to the problem or there is no FoFums-type support, then these are entirely different root causes or failure modes effects that may not be as easily lived with.
Without tracking down an accurate Root Cause, one is still dealing more with emotions than facts.

Quote from: kb0zke – February 21, 2013, 06:19:09 pm

.......................As near as we can tell, those three were more or less head-to-head competitors, with the Foretravel being the lowest priced of the three, although not by much..................................

David,
I'm not interested in bashing any brands at all, BUT I am willing to share what I have for factual knowledge.
Send me a PM if you have any interest.
Neal

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #14 – February 21, 2013, 10:50:36 pm

Our U300 is 20 years old but the drawer glides still work like new, the closet doors don't sag, in short, I'm always pleasantly surprised when I have not been inside for a week or two of how together it is. Under the skin, the plumbing, electrical wiring are well organized with thoughful care taken in assembly. As the others have mentioned, the running gear, appliances, air conditioning are either RV standard or HD gear found on trucks and buses. Ratios, engines, brakes have been sized well for the weight of the coach.

Sure, there are things about the coach I can question, but only occasionally, not on a daily basis like several other major brands. I still remember a Eugene, OR salesman hitting a kitchen drawer bottom when it suddenly popped out onto the floor.

Unless you can afford a well done bus conversion, a Foretravel is at least equal to a couple of other high end coaches and well above the crowd. And as for the bus conversions, it's hard to find a model that can be lived with day after day without feeling you belong (or are living) in a Las Vegas casino.

Outside of a belt, air bag and a tire, nothing has failed in 25,000 miles and 3 years plus of ownership. Lots of small upgrades but not because of failures.

Pierce

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #15 – February 22, 2013, 12:43:34 am

We recently attended a relatively small RV show in Spokane, WA. Lots of "light" trailers that seemed pretty flimsy. Several DPs that did not seem as nice as our 1993 FT. Some pickup campers that were, in a word, huge!!!

Really, after all was said and done the only RVs at this show that appeared to us to be built well enough to last 20 years were the Airstream trailers.

Several $200,000 plus motor homes. I could not find any access to the engine. Rear bathrooms are nice but I walked around the back and could not find any way to the engine unless I laid down on the floor and scooted in on my back. (I didn't actually try it... and I could be wrong about that, actually.)

Some of these rigs had 5 televisions sets. One on each side of the "salon", one over the front, one in the bedroom, and one in the "basement".

Almost everything from a teardrop to a 45' DP had slides. One pickup camper had 3 slides (one on each side and one to the rear) and an island kitchen!!!

Pretty much of an eye-opener.

Craig

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #16 – February 22, 2013, 12:15:44 pm

Neal, I have a 10 year old 40' Winnie DP that has been a good coach over the last 3 years, but I'm very impressed with what I read about the FT coaches and I think my next coach will be an FT. I'm unable to open your decision analysis attachment and I'm very interested in seeing it. Is it attached as a pdf? Is there another way that I can get a copy.

Thanks,

Pete

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #17 – February 22, 2013, 12:29:00 pm

Quote from: PeteP – February 22, 2013, 12:15:44 pm

Neal, I have a 10 year old 40' Winnie DP that has been a good coach over the last 3 years, but I'm very impressed with what I read about the FT coaches and I think my next coach will be an FT. I'm unable to open your decision analysis attachment and I'm very interested in seeing it. Is it attached as a pdf? Is there another way that I can get a copy.

Thanks,

Pete

Pete, I have put the text of it below.
Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #18 – February 22, 2013, 03:41:26 pm

Quote from: brrving – February 21, 2013, 08:42:46 pm

In my humble opinion, the best thing Foretravel has going for it is that it is a smaller operation where service and sales work closely with customers and will address problems. The bigger outfits just can't give that level of service when the sales force are RV dealerships primarily in the business to sell units and sell them quickly.

The lack of knowledgeable ( qualified) service facilities ( as far as mods go) can also be a bad thing. I've had some work done on my FT at a place in central FL ( new desk, outside TV and extra storage cabinet, new radio and re-plumb the wet bay) and at a place in Jacksonville, FL (rebuild and tile the entry steps and install a new awning over the slide) and the techs could not figure their way around to open the slide - and one guy couldn't even start the thing because the slide wasn't "locked" closed. Had to tell him over the phone how to get it closed. That has caused me to determine that if I ever need any more major work modification done ( probably not) I will drive the 1000 miles from FL to MOT in TX where I know the coach will be in good hands.

I have no problem with regular oil changes, Aqua Hot maintenance, etc. with local facilities though.

I too find it amazing how long lasting and durable these coaches can be and are - and how much money people will spend ( I have put $15K "personalizing" mine in less than 18 months and the person I bought it from had spent $30K updating it before it was sold to me... and the owner before HIM had a $22K paint job done at Extreme Graphics!) to update them... but they drive incredibly well and are a unique motor home. I also knew when I bought my FT that I was going to spend a few bucks to "make it mine" to fit our needs.

Getting on the road can always hold surprises for us no matter which brand you drive though. Is it going to start? Will the slide come in? Will the jacks work? What's THAT noise??? Heck, I had those questions in my brand new Tiffin when I had IT. Like my FT much better

Unfortunately I can't afford a new one so I'll just keep updating mine for awhile

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #19 – February 22, 2013, 03:52:59 pm

Quote from: Keith and Joyce – February 21, 2013, 08:48:56 pm

Brrving,

But how much trouble is the Foretravel and how much the parts manufactured by others? If everyone uses Dometic a/c units for example that should be a wash for comparison purposes. It's build and design quality that matter. Does the coach have good enough "bones" to be long lasting?

Keith

Keith,

Yes good point. Several issues have been supplier parts, but others have been build issues (i.e. water leaks in multiple areas of the coach). I was expecting higher quality control in a "top" line manufacturer.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #20 – February 22, 2013, 08:17:47 pm

When we began our research more than two years ago, we were advised to look ONLY at high quality coaches, even if that meant getting an older coach. Since we don't have our Foretravel yet, I can't say from personal experience that the advice was good, but it sure seems that way. Granted that any coach can be abused and/or neglected, it seems to me that starting with a higher quality coach will generally pay off in the end.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #21 – February 22, 2013, 11:44:27 pm

I love the look on people's faces when I show them, with a light push, how easy our bathroom door closes--and on a 24 year old coach yet!! Quality and design endures!

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #22 – August 15, 2014, 07:21:46 pm

Well I'm reviving this year and a half old thread since I've compared 3-4 SOBs in factory tours and RV shows. I saw Barry's analysis, but is there something that can provide a pro/con chart vs. an SOB or a spreadsheet of the FT in an analysis regarding all the mechanical issues you would think of, i.e., chassis, engine, trans, A/C, suspension, service, slides, etc. Specifically "why" FT are better than SOBs.

Thanks for any help or direction where to find this.

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #23 – August 15, 2014, 07:32:27 pm

There is a school of thought that such spread sheets are used by most to justify a decision already made. Â I'm just sayin'

It's in the same category that you have a meeting and everyone is to throw out ideas and no one is allowed to criticize.

They sound good. But...

best, paul

Re: Foretravel vs. SOB Decision Analysis

Reply #24 – August 15, 2014, 07:38:54 pm

Here is the best I can advise--- my 1990 U280 is a go anywhere, never stop machine, it never breaks, and it's still worth more than I paid for it! All the doors close without dragging, it is quiet on the road ( you have to listen carefully to tell if the Cat 3208T is running) and it is economical to operate. I don't think you can beat them, and if you ever want to sell it--- someone will buy it! What more could you ask for?

Affiliate Notice