Skip to main content
Topic: Starting a dead coach (Read 1579 times) previous topic - next topic

Starting a dead coach

I have a couple problems at least that are stacking up on me, and I'm looking for some guidance as I attempt to crawl out.  I apologize in advance, as this will likely be a wall of text, but I'm just trying to get all this down not just so I remember what has happened, but to make sure I'm not doing anything too dumb.

A couple weeks ago, I posted that my HWH wouldn't go into travel mode.  I got some great feedback and planned to replace a fuse and see where that got me, but we were on our way out of town for a couple of weeks.  I assumed I could pick up where I left off when I returned.

Instead, when we got back I went to the replace the fuse and found that my shore power circuit at the storage seemed to be tripped because there was no read-out on the display of my surge protector.  And the chassis batteries were discharged.  And the engine batteries were discharged. 

Oddly, the extension cord I had hooked up to my cord reel was still live - but I couldn't get the surge protector to come on.  I looked for a reset or signs of a failure, couldn't find anything.  I removed the surge protector and hooked up the shore power line.  After a couple minutes, the system seemed to try to start up.  Some lights in my inverter bay came on, various clicks, and the air compressor tried to fire up - but then the circuit tripped as there must have been a large amp draw from somewhere.  I tried this a couple of times with the same result.

(Incidentally, I plugged the surge protector back in after an hour(?) and it works again)

So I assumed that maybe my best bet was to try to jump the coach.  The first thing I tried was a jump pack - I got the biggest one O'Reilly had on the shelf, a Super Start 1200 peak amp power pack.  Tried to start - wouldn't turn that engine.  We aren't just low, we're dead.

So I put on a battery charger that I've had for years.  Gave it a couple of hours, but it stopped charging at some point since it's not designed to charge loads this large.  So... I picked up a bigger charger that claimed it was RV compatible (whatever that means).  I put it on to charge this morning, and when I went to attempt to start the coach this evening, it still wouldn't turn over.  However, the air compressor had come alive and was running.  And that leads to the next problem.

The compressor was running, but didn't seem to be generating any pressure, and there was air leaking from this connector (attached image).  Here's a video if it helps.  Shared album - Steve Jones - Google Photos  How many failures deep am I now?  Sheesh...

So my current plan is to allow the coach to charge over night.  I disconnected power from the air compressor - it was running non-stop, not creating pressure, and I don't see any value in potentially burning up a motor and slowing down the charging process.

I don't know how old any of my batteries are, so I think I need to be prepared to replace them.  But to do that, I'll need to get it started, raise it up, and block it off so I can pull batteries.  But of course, that means I need to get it started and figure out my air issue.  :o

So my questions:
1. Am I doing anything really dumb yet? 
2. Is getting it started the right first step?
2a. If so, is charging it then using the jump pack (if needed) a good approach?
3. What's up with the air leak? 
4. Any speculation as to why my surge protector might have tripped leading to my batteries draining?

I'm still a new owner and I'm prepared to work on things and get my hands dirty figuring out systems and problems, but this series of issues isn't quite what I expected this early.

Thanks in advance to anyone who has some insight.

-Steve

As an Amazon Associate Foretravel Owners' Forum earns from qualifying purchases.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #1
Steve,

Leave the aux air compressor turned off - it's not your first priority.
What kind of outlet are you using for shore power?  15A, 30A, or 50A?  Hook the shore power extension cord directly to the portable battery charger.
Hook whatever portable battery charger you are using directly to your chassis (engine start) batteries.  Let them charge overnight.
Tomorrow, when the chassis batteries have some charge, try to get your generator started.  If it starts, turn on your inverter/charger and then turn on your boost switch.  Your inverter/charger will supply a much bigger charging current to both battery banks.
After both battery banks are charged up, you should be able to start your engine.
THEN, you can worry about the air leak.  It is probably the dump solenoid valve on the aux compressor air dryer/water separator stuck open.  Simple fix.
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #2
Shore power is 15A. 

Thanks Chuck - that's what I was looking for.  Gonna try that generator in the morning.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #3
Depending on what inverter you have, some will not charge a dead battery, but your inverter may not be that kind and when it went to bulk charge it was probably pulling 20-25 ac amps. Get the generator going first, it doesn't take as much power to get it to turn over. It will be able to run the inverter on bulk charge.
previous 1984 35 ft ORED 250 HP 3208 Cat       
previous 1998 40 ft U295 CAI 325 hp Cummins
previous 2003 40 Ft u320 build #6140 450 Cummins M11.                                                         
1999 Mazda Miata
Ron, Nancy, Tipper the cat, Max The dog
1997 U 270 36 ft build number 5174 8.3 Cummins

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #4
Xantrex Freedom SW 3012

What you describe sounds like what I was seeing - the large amp draw tripped the circuit.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #5

If you leave the portable charger hooked up overnight on the 6 amp setting, hopefully in the morning there will be enough juice in the chassis batteries to crank the generator.  If necessary, you could use that Super Start jump pack to add a little extra juice.  If you try to use the 30A boost or the 100A jump start setting on the portable battery charger, you may trip the 15A circuit breaker on your shore power outlet.  The manual for your battery charger says it can pull 19 amps intermittently - I assume when using the booster settings.  Good luck!

https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/91AQnYGUKWL.pdf

As an Amazon Associate Foretravel Owners' Forum earns from qualifying purchases.
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #6
Does your generator use the chassis batteries or the house batteries to start the generator?

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #7
Does your generator use the chassis batteries or the house batteries to start the generator?

I thought house - but I should be able to use the boost switch in the morning if I try to start it and get nothing, right?
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #8
I believe your generator uses the house batteries to start. I think you want to charge the house batteries overnight with the boost switch off. In the morning try to start the generator with the boost switch still off.

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #9
The fold in the drawing distorts the right-most highlighted vertical line.  But it looks like it is indeed started by house batteries.

I'll give it a go with the boost switch in the morning, I don't have it in me to go to the storage facility tonight, crawl into the back of the storage bay, remove the panel, and hook up the charger to the house batteries. 

I'll give it a go with the boost solenoid in the morning - or will that even close if house batteries are dead?  Looks like it's powered by house batteries.

Sure would be nice if there were convenient charging lugs like there are for the chassis batteries.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #10
Using the boost switch in the morning will be connecting hopefully charged house batteries to likely dead chassis batteries thereby reducing the power available to start the generator.

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #11
Sorry about that - it was my erroneous assumption that the newer coaches started the generator off the chassis batteries.  I thought I read that somewhere...

I'll go spend some "time out" in the corner.  Please ignore everything I said earlier...
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #12
Chuck - I already owe you several tall beers.  Probably even cold ones. 

Bob - I'll try it anyway.  Worst case, I have to do the storage bay crawl and wait a few hours.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #13
Update - having left the charger on the chassis batteries all night, I attempted to start it up.  The engine starts to turn, but not fully, and not enough to start.  So, next I tried to start the generator with boost and my jump pack - still not enough amperage. 

So now I'm charging the house batteries - I'll give it a few hours then try the generator.  For now, I've hit the battery disconnect to make sure everything is off and we'll charge quicker.  I'll probably try again this afternoon.

My house batteries are over 10 yrs old, gel Sonnenschein GF 12 160 V, with Aug 2012 written on the label.  Qty 3.  So I think I'm due.  I'm good with staying with the same setup, gel, but these Sonnenschein batteries seem to be more available in Europe.  I'll stop at my local O'Reilly, but what's the best place to source batteries?  I assume I'm looking for 3 12V gel at roughly 160 Ah each?  Otherwise it's just differences in quality?  I'm in the Houston area.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #14
Generator takes very little power to operate. When I first got my coach i started generator on an old week red top optima battery and operated it on that battery till we drove across the states going home. No other house batteries

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #15
That battery shows it's 196Ah capacity and is very similar in size to an 8D, which is what is in my 03 U320.  The 8d Lifelines I have are 255Ah each.  The page you listed shows that battery at $1200.  The Lifelines with more capacity run in the mid $800's.  If you do replace those batteries, I'd consider an 8D to increase your capacity with the same number of batteries, and these are cheaper.

The Xantrex SW3012 is a good unit, the upgraded model of the SW3000 I have.  That does also seem to have a lithium ion charging capability too, so you could go with lithium batteries if extended boondocking is in your future.  Lithium offers a weight savings and capacity increase, but are more expensive (although you would not need 3 either).  You would need to add a DC to DC charger so your alternator could still charge the house batteries too.  Just depends on your needs really.
Keith
2003 U320 38' #6197

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #16
Progress!  Generator is started, inverter is charging.

I'll let it charge for a couple hours, then I'll try starting the engine and let it run for 30 min.

After that, I have to figure out my air issue.  I know that I have air coming out of my dump solenoid valve on the aux compressor air dryer/water separator - Chuck mentioned that it's probably just stuck open and is an easy fix.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #17
Steve, do you have the Xantrex display?  If so, look for the screen that shows what the charger is doing.  If you can wait for it to get to FLOAT mode, that means the batteries are completely charged as far as the charger knows.

The dump solenoid is a normally open solenoid that takes 12V to close it.  When 12V is applied to run the compressor, it should also close the solenoid orifice.  The orifice has 1/8npt threads in the end of it.  For now, you can just put a pipe plug in there to get the compressor to make pressure in the system.
Keith
2003 U320 38' #6197

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #18
The Xantrex display was in the Absorption mode.  I'll check on it here in another hour or two.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #19
After that, I have to figure out my air issue.  I know that I have air coming out of my dump solenoid valve on the aux compressor air dryer/water separator - Chuck mentioned that it's probably just stuck open and is an easy fix.

The dump solenoid is a normally open solenoid that takes 12V to close it.  When 12V is applied to run the compressor, it should also close the solenoid orifice.  The orifice has 1/8npt threads in the end of it.  For now, you can just put a pipe plug in there to get the compressor to make pressure in the system.

If it's not closing, the easy fix is to either replace the solenoid OR rebuild it with one of Tom's plunger kits.  You can tap on it and it might close, but that's not a long-term solution.

That said, it could also be the bowl itself - that bowl experiences significant temperature stress when it unloads.  They are known for developing stress cracks at the fitting where the solenoid valve attaches, and we've personally seen one that failed catastrophically (2008 Nimbus).

HWH Solenoid Valve Rebuild

HWH Filters and Bowls

BTW, pull the fuse on the aux compressor to prevent continuous running.  You'll overheat the compressor and be looking at a more costly repair.
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #20
The Xantrex display was in the Absorption mode.  I'll check on it here in another hour or two.

Looks like it's still taking 79 Amps, so it will still take a while absorbing.
Keith
2003 U320 38' #6197

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #21
For what it is worth--granted my coach is vastly different from yours, but--if you can't get the batteries you want you shouldn't need a "super" battery to start your coach (unless it is quite cold out).
About six years ago I replaced an 8D start battery with two truck batteries with 900CCA because the 8D wet cell battery available up here in Northern Wisconsin only had a one year warranty. My truck batteries have 5 year warranties, and are still going strong. Haven't had a no-start yet.
Nitehawk,  Demolition Lady, & our NEW master, Zippy the speeding BB cat.
1989 Grand Villa 36' ORED
Oshkosh chassis, 8.2 DD V8
2006 Saturn Vue AWD

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #22
For what it is worth--granted my coach is vastly different from yours, but--if you can't get the batteries you want you shouldn't need a "super" battery to start your coach (unless it is quite cold out).
About six years ago I replaced an 8D start battery with two truck batteries with 900CCA because the 8D wet cell battery available up here in Northern Wisconsin only had a one year warranty. My truck batteries have 5 year warranties, and are still going strong. Haven't had a no-start yet.

Good call.  I have 3 @ 965 CCA ea  right now.  They're $500 ea to replace, I'm sure I could get by with much cheaper.
Steve and Cassi
2007 Foretravel Nimbus 42'

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #23
My U320 has 3 x Group 31 start/chassis batteries.  I went with the $175 Duracell batteries from Batteries Plus.
Keith
2003 U320 38' #6197

Re: Starting a dead coach

Reply #24

Chassis battery's are Optimas and the house side are Lithium.
2002 U320 36' Single axle  MOST MODED IN HISTORY SO MUCH ITS ALMOST ILLIGAL
2 slides ( living room and bedroom)
undisclosed
male
female
genderless
nonbinary
transgendered