Skip to main content
Topic: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting (Read 446 times) previous topic - next topic

U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

I would be most interested in hearing from U240 owners and others with knowledge of "jerky shifting" through gears 1-4 on the Allison trans. The RPM ranges from 1,500-2,000 RPM during the shift. The Caterpillar shop says the rough shifting is "normal" for this engine/trans pairing, but it seems unusual. My U300 with Detroit/Allison shifted smoothly as to be mostly unnoticeable.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #1
Shifting on the Allison 3000 was very much the same on all three of our coaches: Caterpillar 3116, Caterpillar 3126 and Cummins ISL.

Wonder how old the fluid is and if it is Transynd 668?  The better fluids from Allison do shift smoother than the old Dexron.

And, no diagnostic codes, correct.

What was the wire hanging down in one of your earlier posts?

Probably worth disconnecting, cleaning with Deoxit and reconnecting all connections at transmission, ECU and shift pad.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #2
Shifting on the Allison 3000 was very much the same on all three of our coaches: Caterpillar 3116, Caterpillar 3126 and Cummins ISL.

Wonder how old the fluid is and if it is Transynd 668?  The better fluids from Allison do shift smoother than the old Dexron.

And, no diagnostic codes, correct.

What was the wire hanging down in one of your earlier posts?

Probably worth disconnecting, cleaning with Deoxit and reconnecting all connections at transmission, ECU and shift pad.
I first surmised that the broken cord was possibly the throttle position indicator, but the CAT shop said no—they said likely the HWH leveling system. The coach is going to a different shop on Monday and I will post their findings.

As to trans fluid, I do not know what is currently installed but will be replacing fluid and filters in the Allison next week and will use Allison parts and fluid.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #3
As to trans fluid, I do not know what is currently installed but will be replacing fluid and filters in the Allison next week and will use Allison parts and fluid.

Yup, get the filter kit from Allison-- it will have instructions/torque specs.

Buy the 5 gallon pail of 668. That will leave you about one quart left over from the change.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #4
Yup, get the filter kit from Allison-- it will have instructions/torque specs.

Buy the 5 gallon pail of 668. That will leave you about one quart left over from the change.
Thanks Brett—I was just about to ask about the filters and proper fluid spec. The Caterpillar tech said that the fluid was "old" so it will be changed in the days ahead. I hope that smooths out the shifting.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #5
Just throwing this out there but could the idle rpm be too high causing a rough shift,had that happen on a car.
96 U270 BUILD 4810
85 380SL
Drummonds TN.

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #6
Just throwing this out there but could the idle rpm be too high causing a rough shift,had that happen on a car.

From neutral to first only.

And, if idle RPM too high, the Allison will NOT shift into gear.

The shift pad will just flash.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #7
Sounds like you are talking about starting from a stop.  All of my starts from stop are at WOT until speed limit.  At the speed limit I let up and the trans will upshift and it will be a jerk.  First gear shifts at 2000RPM, 2nd has a torque converter lockup, then a shift to 3rd at 2650RPM. 3rd RPM drops to 1900, then winds up to 2650 to shift into 4th.  4th RPM drops to 2000 and then winds up to 2650 again to shift to 5th.  My top speed towing my HHR is 62-63MPH, in 5th the engine is turning 2300RPM.  If I let up on the throttle during the takeoff/start  with speeds less than 40MPH the trans will upshift and it will be strong.
Pat/Blue Angel
1995 U240 36ft
MC# 16511
Build# 4653

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #8
Just throwing this out there but could the idle rpm be too high causing a rough shift,had that happen on a car.
That can certainly be an issue, but in this instance, idle RPM is right where it should be, circa 650-700 RPM.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #9
Sounds like you are talking about starting from a stop.  All of my starts from stop are at WOT until speed limit.  At the speed limit I let up and the trans will upshift and it will be a jerk.  First gear shifts at 2000RPM, 2nd has a torque converter lockup, then a shift to 3rd at 2650RPM. 3rd RPM drops to 1900, then winds up to 2650 to shift into 4th.  4th RPM drops to 2000 and then winds up to 2650 again to shift to 5th.  My top speed towing my HHR is 62-63MPH, in 5th the engine is turning 2300RPM.  If I let up on the throttle during the takeoff/start  with speeds less than 40MPH the trans will upshift and it will be strong.
Good info—I was babying the engine with light throttle on city streets. I also think a trans fluid and filter change will smooth things out as well .Thanks!
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #10
Our U300/Allison HT747 with stock ATF shifts OK on upshifts also with WOT with the final 3rd to 4th shift at highway speeds OK. Not glass smooth but OK. Heading upgrade, the 4th to 3rd shift is OK with 3rd to 2nd harder. The rough shifts are the partial throttle down shifts and the downhill shifts where the coach starts to coast and then suddenly goes into 2nd gear.  The 747 is a transmission used in garbage trucks and is very durable as it may start and stop several times in one block. The 4 speeds on coaches have a pretty good gap between gears so will not shift as smoothly as the 6 speeds with closer ratios. Our larger 6V92TA only turns 2130 rpm max.

I've never seen an Allison that was anywhere close to perfect. We had Allisons on smaller rigs on the FD with the City using Allisons on the small Mercedes buses. They shifted so hard, that they would chip the ring gear in the rear axle third member. Lots of complaints from the riders. Said that the drivers could not shift the transmission ;D . This was the reason they sold all the small buses.

Got to experience the auto/manual Detroit DT12 (12 speed transmission) for a good automatic. Even skip shifts and can use GPS for the right gear for any highway and grade in the U.S.

Pierce

Pierce and Gaylie Stewart
'93 U300/36 WTBI
Detroit 6V-92TA Jake
1140 watts on the roof
SBFD (ret)

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #11
 I don't think they have much tuning for part throttle since most of the applications for these transmissions use the throttle as an on/off switch.

It will be interesting to hear how it shifts with new fluid.

I got to drive a truck with this in it a few months ago. It was so smooth, I wish I could put one in my coach.
9-Speed | Allison Transmission
1991 U300 Side Aisle 6V92 Silver #3897
2004 U320 40' #6246

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #12
The Allison needs to learn how you drive and it will adapt to your driving style.
previous 1984 35 ft ORED 250 HP 3208 Cat       
previous 1998 40 ft U295 CAI 325 hp Cummins
previous 2003 40 Ft u320 build #6140 450 Cummins M11.                                                         
1999 Mazda Miata
Ron, Nancy, Tipper the cat, Max The dog
1997 U 270 36 ft build number 5174 8.3 Cummins

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #13
Our U300/Allison HT747 with stock ATF shifts OK on upshifts also with WOT with the final 3rd to 4th shift at highway speeds OK. Not glass smooth but OK. Heading upgrade, the 4th to 3rd shift is OK with 3rd to 2nd harder. The rough shifts are the partial throttle down shifts and the downhill shifts where the coach starts to coast and then suddenly goes into 2nd gear.  The 747 is a transmission used in garbage trucks and is very durable as it may start and stop several times in one block. The 4 speeds on coaches have a pretty good gap between gears so will not shift as smoothly as the 6 speeds with closer ratios. Our larger 6V92TA only turns 2130 rpm max.

I've never seen an Allison that was anywhere close to perfect. We had Allisons on smaller rigs on the FD with the City using Allisons on the small Mercedes buses. They shifted so hard, that they would chip the ring gear in the rear axle third member. Lots of complaints from the riders. Said that the drivers could not shift the transmission ;D . This was the reason they sold all the small buses.

Got to experience the auto/manual Detroit DT12 (12 speed transmission) for a good automatic. Even skip shifts and can use GPS for the right gear for any highway and grade in the U.S.

Pierce
Wow great info Pierce, thanks. I am beginning to think that new fluid/filters may help this one.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #14
Upgrade to the trans synd fluid if u can
SLC12

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #15
Yes, any Allison dealer will have not only the correct filter kit (both filters plus gaskets and instructions) but also the Transynd 668.  As mentioned, the 5 gallon pail is the most economical way to buy it.

I set the pail up on a ladder and start a siphon into the dip stick tube to fill.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020


Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #17
Yes, any Allison dealer will have not only the correct filter kit (both filters plus gaskets and instructions) but also the Transynd 668.  As mentioned, the 5 gallon pail is the most economical way to buy it.

I set the pail up on a ladder and start a siphon into the dip stick tube to fill.
That's good to know because I was worrying about the fill, but then decided to have the shop do it since it would be in there for a possible turbo leak.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #18
Tell us about the turbo leak?. A picture if soot trail from leak.

And, if hard shifting continues after fluid change, I would sure have the transmission's throttle position sensor checked for proper adjustment. For example, it the throttle position sensor tells the transmission that the engine is at WOT and you are at part throttle, the shifts WILL be harsh.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: U240 CAT 3116 / Allison Shifting

Reply #19
Tell us about the turbo leak?. A picture if soot trail from leak.

And, if hard shifting continues after fluid change, I would sure have the transmission's throttle position sensor checked for proper adjustment. For example, it the throttle position sensor tells the transmission that the engine is at WOT and you are at part throttle, the shifts WILL be harsh.
I should know about the turbo leak , if there is one, sometime tomorrow and will report back.
As to the shifting, I am more and more inclined to think that the TPS is the culprit. In any case, the Trans fluid and filters needed changing anyway and that might help the situation.
1989 Foretravel U300 Grand Villa
Build #3410