Skip to main content
Topic: Airing tires from onboard hose. (Read 3531 times) previous topic - next topic

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #100

Jim, Interesting suggestion. Not sure about our available space. Will have to check out the dimensional specs.

Are you using this as a total replacement for the FT OEM aux compressor equipment?
2002 U270, 36' WTNS, Build # 6030, Cummins 400 ISL.
Wheelchair accessible modifications by ForeTravel, Braun UVL lift.

2001 Dodge IMS RampVan, M&G tow brakes, Sterling tow bar.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #101

Jim, Interesting suggestion. Not sure about our available space. Will have to check out the dimensional specs.

Are you using this as a total replacement for the FT OEM aux compressor equipment?
My OEM Thomas is still there and working. This system is separate and plumbed to wet tank, but has a crossover with a valve to my slide/hwh leveling line incase the Thomas goes out. You probably could use it as a replacement, footprint is smaller than the Thomas.
Jim C.
coachfree, previous 1997, 1999, 2000, and 2003 Foretravels.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #102

Amazon link to the compressor Jim recommended:

Amazon.com: Viair 45040 450C Air Compressor Kit: Automotive

Keith

As an Amazon Associate Foretravel Owners' Forum earns from qualifying purchases.
Keith, Joyce & Smokey the Australian Cattle Dog
1995 U320 SE Extreme 40' WTBI Build # 4780, with a Honda CR-V hopefully still following behind.
Motorcade # 17030
FMCA # F422159

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #103

I don't get it, unless it's speed you're after to air-up above 85 psi. It requires the engine running, just like our onboard!
As an Amazon Associate Foretravel Owners' Forum earns from qualifying purchases.
1993 U-240 "La Villa Grande"..CAT 3116 w/ Pacbrake PRXB...Allison 3060 6-speed..
Previous: 1983 Airstream 310 turbo diesel, 1979 Airstream 280 turbo diesel
                                      Build # 4297
                                      PNW natives
                      Home base:  'Cactus Hug' (Ajo, Arizona)
                        DW Judy & Chet the wonder dog
                        Full-Timers 'Sailing the asphalt sea'

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #104
I don't get it, unless it's speed you're after to air-up above 85 psi. It requires the engine running, just like our onboard!
Mike, the Viair will go to 150 psi, I have mine set to 120, enough to fill tires to 115psi.
Jim C.
coachfree, previous 1997, 1999, 2000, and 2003 Foretravels.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #105
Size comparison.
Jim C.
coachfree, previous 1997, 1999, 2000, and 2003 Foretravels.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #106
Been awhile getting back to the forum. To identify our aux air compressor required finding someone able to wriggle into the basement alongside the wheelchair lift. Very little space available.

Update on aux air compressor in our 02 U270. Neal Pillsbury correctly named our aux air system. From his earlier post:

" In model year 2002, FT started using the Thomas TA4101 12Vdc, 1/3 HP, 100 psig (max.), auxiliary air compressor.  I believe that is what you should find in your coach.  The reason they did this was due to the need for a higher duty rating and a more robust compressor when slides were added to the coaches."

Pictures attached. Yes we have the Thomas 4101. (even though we do not have any slides) The desiccant container is visible as are two water traps. Neal, is this the Wilkerson filtration system you mentioned?

Newbie question: Are there separate desiccants/filtration systems for the engine air compressor and the aux Thomas compressor?

Is the Thomas a good unit? Is it strong enough to air the suspension to travel mode without damaging itself, overheating etc. (I suspect the answer is no. Isn't the aux unit only designed for maintaining level and slide operation...True/False?) I might consider running it more often if there were no issues using the aux compressor to achieve travel mode and airing tires. It would be nice to avoid running the Cummins and disturbing our park neighbors. Could make our departure from campsites a bit quieter without any extra diesel exhaust as well.


A. "Newbie question: Are there separate desiccants/filtration systems for the engine air compressor and the aux Thomas compressor?"

Yes: They are distinct, separate systems.  The main (engine) air/braking system Haldex (Midland Grau) desiccant and coalescing filter tower is mounted on the engine frame.  The auxiliary Thomas compressor Wilkerson filtration and desiccant bowls are mounted at the aux. compressor.

B. The desiccant container is visible as are two water traps. "Neal, is this the Wilkerson filtration system you mentioned?"

Yes:  Your pictures show the Wilkerson System drying components; (2 dry bowls and the desiccant bowl) that are used to strip moisture from the Thomas TA4101 auxiliary air compressor exhaust stream.  While some readers may not understand or condone going to the extra effort of avoiding moisture in their air systems/tires, my experience in power plants has shown me the folly of not attending to that detail.  In an air system, one either attends to moisture-free air up front or one has to pay the price, in much more costly terms, down the road.

The nuisance of the Foretravel/Thomas TA4101 compressor/Wilkerson drying components auxiliary air system design is that the drying components are sized for and the design assumes a reasonably tight air system. The operation of the relief valve and automatic blowdown solenoid also often fail and thus detract from system reliability. The desiccant, while easy to change if the desiccant bowl is easily accessible, is expensive (but there are several threads on how to minimize that factor —  Desiccant option for the HWH system . So, with a minimally sized design, if you don't correct your air leaks, you soon exhaust exhaust the desiccant and the rest of the air system components start to suffer.

C. "Is the Thomas a good unit? Is it strong enough to air the suspension to travel mode without damaging itself, overheating etc."

Absolutely yes:  The 12 Vdc Thomas (and not mentioned in this thread before, Gast) brand units are industrial/commercial application standards for medium duty air systems.  They are rugged, durable, high (%) duty cycle, reliable standards.  They use high quality cast iron frames with excellent heat transfer and their designs employ long life components that are rated to last 6,000 hours before minor rebuild and 12,000 hours before major overhaul.  In a coach air system (that is kept reasonably tight and leak free), that is more than (2), 30 year coach lifetimes with a 2 minute auxiliary tank (replenishment) pump up once per day and a 15 minute pump up (of all coach air systems), EVERY day, before getting underway.  Minor and major rebuild kits are expensive, but they reflect the component quality level and are readily available.

Prevost conversions, that have much higher needs than FT's because of their pocket doors, gen sets on air suspensions, air flush toilets, higher pressure air bags, etc., use Thomas and Gast compressors.  When they need more volume, they step up to 2 cylinder Thomas and Gast compressors first and then to 115/240 VAC compressors next. 

There are other light to low/medium duty options, like the VIAIR units.  But what isn't being said about the VIAIR's is that they are primarily focused on marketing/cosmetics whereas Thomas' (and Gast's) are focused on robust longevity and durability.

The VAIR units are widely used in applications where mobility is of primary importance such as in off-roading tire re-inflations (slow, but a decent, mobile backup to the premium Power Tank (CO2) choice), where peak ceiling pressures are compatible with non adjustable hysteresis characteristics, or in hardwired applications where appearance is of paramount concern and longevity is of secondary importance such as in air horn add-ons, show cars with trick pneumatic suspensions and where the air compressors themselves are an intentional part of the visual "candy", etc.  The Thomas and Gast compressors are decidedly "Plain-Jane, Industrial" by comparison.

There are plenty of reasons for any of the options.  Just make sure that you stay focused on DRY, CLEAN AIR.  Speed of air-up, ceiling pressure, hysteresis (difference between compressor set and reset pressures), looks, and durability choices abound, but unfiltered, wet air should never be one of the choices.

HTH,
Neal
The selected media item is not currently available.
Neal (& Brenda) Pillsbury
'02 U320 SPEC, 4200, DGFE, Build #5984
'04 Gold Wing
'07 Featherlite 24'
'14 Jeep Grand Cherokee Summit
MC #14494
Exeter, NH & LaBelle FL
Quality makes the Heart Soar long after Price is Forgotten

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #107

A. "Newbie question: Are there separate desiccants/filtration systems for the engine air compressor and the aux Thomas compressor?"

Yes: They are distinct, separate systems.  The main (engine) air/braking system Haldex (Midland Grau) desiccant and coalescing filter tower is mounted on the engine frame.  The auxiliary Thomas compressor Wilkerson filtration and desiccant bowls are mounted at the aux. compressor.

B. The desiccant container is visible as are two water traps. "Neal, is this the Wilkerson filtration system you mentioned?"

Yes:  Your pictures show the Wilkerson System drying components; (2 dry bowls and the desiccant bowl) that are used to strip moisture from the Thomas TA4101 auxiliary air compressor exhaust stream.  While some readers may not understand or condone going to the extra effort of avoiding moisture in their air systems/tires, my experience in power plants has shown me the folly of not attending to that detail.  In an air system, one either attends to moisture-free air up front or one has to pay the price, in much more costly terms, down the road.

The nuisance of the Foretravel/Thomas TA4101 compressor/Wilkerson drying components auxiliary air system design is that the drying components are sized for and the design assumes a reasonably tight air system. The operation of the relief valve and automatic blowdown solenoid also often fail and thus detract from system reliability. The desiccant, while easy to change if the desiccant bowl is easily accessible, is expensive (but there are several threads on how to minimize that factor —  Desiccant option for the HWH system . So, with a minimally sized design, if you don't correct your air leaks, you soon exhaust exhaust the desiccant and the rest of the air system components start to suffer.

C. "Is the Thomas a good unit? Is it strong enough to air the suspension to travel mode without damaging itself, overheating etc."

Absolutely yes:  The 12 Vdc Thomas (and not mentioned in this thread before, Gast) brand units are industrial/commercial application standards for medium duty air systems.  They are rugged, durable, high (%) duty cycle, reliable standards.  They use high quality cast iron frames with excellent heat transfer and their designs employ long life components that are rated to last 6,000 hours before minor rebuild and 12,000 hours before major overhaul.  In a coach air system (that is kept reasonably tight and leak free), that is more than (2), 30 year coach lifetimes with a 2 minute auxiliary tank (replenishment) pump up once per day and a 15 minute pump up (of all coach air systems), EVERY day, before getting underway.  Minor and major rebuild kits are expensive, but they reflect the component quality level and are readily available.

Prevost conversions, that have much higher needs than FT's because of their pocket doors, gen sets on air suspensions, air flush toilets, higher pressure air bags, etc., use Thomas and Gast compressors.  When they need more volume, they step up to 2 cylinder Thomas and Gast compressors first and then to 115/240 VAC compressors next. 

There are other light to low/medium duty options, like the VIAIR units.  But what isn't being said about the VIAIR's is that they are primarily focused on marketing/cosmetics whereas Thomas' (and Gast's) are focused on robust longevity and durability.

The VAIR units are widely used in applications where mobility is of primary importance such as in off-roading tire re-inflations (slow, but a decent, mobile backup to the premium Power Tank (CO2) choice), where peak ceiling pressures are compatible with non adjustable hysteresis characteristics, or in hardwired applications where appearance is of paramount concern and longevity is of secondary importance such as in air horn add-ons, show cars with trick pneumatic suspensions and where the air compressors themselves are an intentional part of the visual "candy", etc.  The Thomas and Gast compressors are decidedly "Plain-Jane, Industrial" by comparison.

There are plenty of reasons for any of the options.  Just make sure that you stay focused on DRY, CLEAN AIR.  Speed of air-up, ceiling pressure, hysteresis (difference between compressor set and reset pressures), looks, and durability choices abound, but unfiltered, wet air should never be one of the choices.

HTH,
Neal
http://beamalarm.com/Documents/thomas_ta-4101_dc_specifications.html
Neal, think this is the problem with the Thomas for airing up the tires, unless your tires require less than 100 psi.
For the rare times I need to inflate my tires to 115 psi, I do not think the "low/medium duty" Viair is going to be a deal breaker for me. It is rated for continuous  duty. From a search of the forum, it appears the Thomas, even if rated for 6000 or 12000 hours, is not overly reliable, as there are many threads on this and other forums about their replacement.
Jim C.
coachfree, previous 1997, 1999, 2000, and 2003 Foretravels.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #108
It also looks like Mike J needs to change his disaccant on that 12V system
Richard & Betty Bark & Keiko our Golden Doodle
2003 U320T 3820 PBDS
Build # 6215
MC # 16926
2016 Chevrolet Colorado 4X4 diesel

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #109
Thomas TA-4101 DC Specifications
Neal, think this is the problem with the Thomas for airing up the tires, unless your tires require less than 100 psi.
For the rare times I need to inflate my tires to 115 psi, I do not think the "low/medium duty" Viair is going to be a deal breaker for me. It is rated for continuous  duty. From a search of the forum, it appears the Thomas, even if rated for 6000 or 12000 hours, is not overly reliable, as there are many threads on this and other forums about their replacement.
Jim C,

Not a problem.  As I said, to each his own.

I use a (CO2) Power Tank because I can top off all eight coach tires plus four trailer tires in less than 15 minutes, on a bad day.

Out of curiosity, I have used a close friend's VIAIR.
Then, for quite some time, I imagined that I couldn't achieve my required front axle target of 115 psig — on just one tire — in over 15 minutes of trying. 
Then the audible cues finally dawned on me and I subsequently proved that if I was starting at greater than 110 psig in the tire, I first had to connect the VIAIR to the tire, then I had to momentarily let the "sensed pressure" (teed valving arrangement) in the tire down below 108 psig (in order to achieve VIAIR compressor reset) and then the VIAIR would pump the tire up to 115 psig in about 8 minutes (as I recall).  Of course a reservoir tank would alleviate this but then the whole tank would need to be cycled below 108 psig occasionally in order to get the VIAIR to "kick-In".

At any rate, if I didn't have the Power Tank, for some reason, I would still use the Thomas to bring the needed tires up to 100 psig.  Then I'd use the coach service air system to top off, because that would be much faster.

I don't agree that the Thomas and Gast compressors are unreliable.  Every failure that I've personally seen or read about (if there were sufficient details) was also accompanied by air system abuses (uncorrected, long term air leaks and continuous or near continuous aux. air compressor running without corrective actions being taken. 

The Thomas and Gast compressors are continuous-run-rated at 100 psig @72 degrees F,  just like the VIAIR.  But, to my knowledge the Thomas cannot be adjusted to greater than 100 psig.  The duty cycle of the VIAIR's, at least the ones I've seen and used, drop off as one goes higher than 100 psig and one needs to manually interpret and compensate for that.  Even the industrial grade 150 psig VIAIR's have a 33% duty cycle at higher pressures (run for ten minutes, then shut off and let cool down for 20 minutes).  VIAIR Internal, self thermal protection cuts in if one exceeds the internal, unadjustable VIAIR limits.

Not a problem, DWMYH,
Neal
The selected media item is not currently available.
Neal (& Brenda) Pillsbury
'02 U320 SPEC, 4200, DGFE, Build #5984
'04 Gold Wing
'07 Featherlite 24'
'14 Jeep Grand Cherokee Summit
MC #14494
Exeter, NH & LaBelle FL
Quality makes the Heart Soar long after Price is Forgotten

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #110
 Read the specs. 450C Compressor | VIAIR Corporation
Had an bad protection valve on my coach and would leak down to 0 psi in 24 hours. Have used the 450c to bring it back up to 115 psi many times, not quickly, took maybe 15 minutes, but did it every time. Maybe you are looking at a different compressor, but the 450c is rated at 100% duty cycle, when it craps out, like my Thomas did on a previous coach, I will certainly post it. By the way, not positive, but think Newell changed from Thomas/Gast compressors to Jun-Air some time ago.
I am an old guy, but if new technology comes along, I am willing to try it out, and if it's better, use it. 
Jim C.
coachfree, previous 1997, 1999, 2000, and 2003 Foretravels.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #111
Anyone ever check out the "California air tools" compressors,they are 110 volt.

Reply to post 18,Roger if you are using air from the engine air compressor you should not have to use any filter or seperator,if
you actually catch oil or water you have a problem,if using it with outside air then that's another story.
96 U270 BUILD 4810
85 380SL
Drummonds TN.

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #112
Anyone ever check out the "California air tools" compressors,they are 110 volt.
I did - not a happy experience.  See Reply #20 in thread kinked below:

110V Aux Air Compressor Install
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Airing tires from onboard hose.

Reply #113
John,  I use the oil/water separator with my onboard 200 psi 120v DeWalt compressor when adding air to tires or the leveling system. Pretty handy for bike tires and anything else that needs air too.

110V Aux Air Compressor Install
Roger Engdahl and Susan Green
2001 U320 3610 #5879 (Home2) - 2014 Jeep Cherokee or 2018 F150
Hastings, MN