Skip to main content
Topic: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ** (Read 17028 times) previous topic - next topic

Re: Hydraulic pump failed while traveling **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #175
Have to keep this post or  trend alive and in every buddy's mind
Rick & Hilda looking forward to full- timing one day for now couple of months at a time
1999 U270 3602
Built number  5530.  Feb 1999            Motorcade  number 18438
8.3 Cummins Allison six speed with brake  retarder
Purchased Nov 28 2019

Re: Hydraulic pump failed while traveling **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #176
***  UPDATE From the original Poster ***

Rick fully agree.

I was waiting on a bit more information before I posted an update on QCC's status. But will do so with what I know.

I spoke with Simone @QCC about the satus of the rear pump housings that affect all 9 of the discontinued pumps, here was here reply on that.

" Purchasing is moving forward with placing the order for the rear housings. After speaking with the gentleman at Foretravel and learning that the other pump that is used in the coaches uses standard shafts there did not seem to be any reason to delay moving forward with the covers "

The unique tapered shafts for the 41188 are still at the request for quote stage.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Hydraulic pump failed while traveling **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #177
I wonder why a tapered shaft was necessary?  My coach isn't close now so can't look. 
"Not so  long ago we were a nation of risk takers, riding five million pounds of  thrust straight into space."  Joe Gresh
Chuck Pearson
1996 U295
2018 Can Am X3 TurboRS

Re: Hydraulic pump failed while traveling **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #178
The taper and keyway locates a hub for the pulley to mount, where as a straight shaft would not fix the location of the pulley.
1999 40 ft. U-320 wtfe build 5563 Chuck & Lynda's "Rollin' Inn"  2030 watts solar
prev. mh's 71 GMC 5 yrs. 73 Pace Setter 1 yr. 78 Vogue 5 yrs 81 FTX 40ft all electric 18 yrs. 1996 Monaco Signature 3 yrs.
2014 Grand Cherokee Overland
Dream as if you will live forever. Live as if you will die today.  James Dean

Re: Hydraulic pump failed while traveling **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #179
I wonder why a tapered shaft was necessary?
The taper and keyway locates a hub for the pulley to mount, where as a straight shaft would not fix the location of the pulley.
Photo below showing tapered shaft (from Reply #143 in this thread).
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #180
Knowing somewhat how Foretravel did things,think they used whatever was availible,your point taken craneman but look at all
the truck and car pulleys that are pressed on a straight shaft.
96 U270 BUILD 4810
85 380SL
Drummonds TN.

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #181
Knowing somewhat how Foretravel did things,think they used whatever was availible,your point taken craneman but look at all the truck and car pulleys that are pressed on a straight shaft.
Agree.  The pump designers could have just as easily made the shaft straight (no taper) with a shoulder (and a keyway) to locate the pulley.  This is the way the hydraulic pump shaft on our coach is shaped.  Don't ask me which design shape is stronger.  By the way, OEM shafts for my Vickers V10 pump are still readily available on eBay, unlike the hellish situation Mike (the OP) has had to deal with.

Vickers By Eaton (374338) 3/16" Keyed V10 Shaft Assembly for Single Vane...
1993 U280 SE 40' WTBI, Build: 4359
C8.3 300hp, 6-Speed, Exhaust Brake
960 watts on the roof (6 x 160)
Sorento (or BOLT) on a Kar Kaddy SS
"Nature abhors a vacuum"

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #182
I wonder why a tapered shaft was necessary?  My coach isn't close now so can't look. 
You might wanna check and see if yours is the 41188.....If its belt driven, it probably is. As to date on the research, NO other pump  was used for a belt driven application in our vintage years, Unless maybe it was a Vickers V10. The Vickers V10 is also obsolete as a complete unit, but parts are still out there for it.

If yours is the 41188 you might want to get in touch with the recommended contact as well.

I cannot emphasize enough......the next person that has a failure on a 41188....all your possible wealth will not buy you a fix.....THERE ARE NO PUMPS OR PARTS,....YET, but there might be if the demand is there. QCC is working toward a resolution, but its been made pretty clear that will probably be a limited run resolution.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #183
The straight or tapered is a non issue because failure was on the thick end, not in the tapered area. The keyway IMO localized stress contributing to failure point. Regardless if semi reasonable priced  I like others will purchase a replacement pump to carry and probably never use ( ISM direct drive mount) but will help collectively promote a demand for at least another run of these pumps. It would be a wonderful time for them to incorporate a resolution to prevent this from happening in the future on the new pump line, but that may be a whole new bag worms also who knows

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #184
I cannot emphasize enough......the next person that has a failure on a 41188....all your possible wealth will not buy you a fix.....THERE ARE NO PUMPS OR PARTS,....YET, but there might be if the demand is there. QCC is working toward a resolution, but its been made pretty clear that will probably be a limited run resolution.

Hopefully QCC comes through.  In the mean time, no need to stress quite so much.  As I mentioned back on page 4, shafts can be made if it comes to that. 
Dave and Kelli
1997 U295 40' Build #5188 CSGI
1995 U240 36' Build #4621 SBID-SOLD
2006 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #185
The straight or tapered is a non issue because failure was on the thick end, not in the tapered area. The keyway IMO localized stress contributing to failure point. Regardless if semi reasonable priced  I like others will purchase a replacement pump to carry and probably never use ( ISM direct drive mount) but will help collectively promote a demand for at least another run of these pumps. It would be a wonderful time for them to incorporate a resolution to prevent this from happening in the future on the new pump line, but that may be a whole new bag worms also who knows
Scott is spot on, the failure in my case was in the meat of the shaft not the tapered section. And continued support from those that have ANY pump on the list only benefits all of us. But all of this continued forum talk of what type of shaft it is, why they used that shaft, why did it fail, etc..... is  sort of irrelevant....the shaft failed, I'm am by no means the first and will not be the last. They are not going to change the design, and no parts are available at this moment in time.

If you don't want to be part of a resolution then don't....But it is in every Diesel pusher coach owners best interest, to determine what they have in their personal coach. IF one of the affected pumps is on your personal coach, it is in YOUR best interest to make that contact with Simone at QCC....maybe take the lead DSD has shown.


Hopefully QCC comes through.  In the mean time, no need to stress quite so much.  As I mentioned back on page 4, shafts can be made if it comes to that. 
I personally, no longer have stress on this subject. BUT the next person to suffer the same failure at the present state of sourcing, will have much more stress than I ever thought of.....unless of course QCC continues as they already have on the rear housings for the 9.... Unless you personally are willing to step and up and manufacture those shafts, good luck finding anyone that will. And if you do, you surely would have to lie about the application to get it done.

 I might add, 3 of the hydraulic shops refused to do rebuilds and warrant such, EVEN though I was getting the shafts direct from QCC...I was never going to ask someone to do what I can do myself, but I did ask....why would they not warranty you might ask? all 3 said the same thing, they refused to warranty any item associated with a vehicular safety/Steering system, and really did not even want to to do the rebuild at this level..

As I stated earlier, I fully agree with you, and I agree this is stupid at a new sort of level, but in this sue happy world it has become what it has become and not a damn thing we can do about it. 99% of owners would NEVER be able to go the shaft approach, as they would be reliant on someone doing the work for them that is either going to refuse, or refuse to warranty.
The complete pump approach is the more logical approach for the masses.

.As stated I can provide the technical blueprint if anyone wants to take on that en devour.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #186

 I might add, 3 of the hydraulic shops refused to do rebuilds and warrant such, EVEN though I was getting the shafts direct from QCC...I was never going to ask someone to do what I can do myself, but I did ask....why would they not warranty you might ask? all 3 said the same thing, they refused to warranty any item associated with a vehicular safety/Steering system, and really did not even want to to do the rebuild at this level..

I think you'll find that because this is related to steering, it becomes an NHTSA issue if there's a failure, and that's why shops will not take on replicating/replacing the shaft as/with an aftermarket option.  Similarly, FT did not issue a recall on the dry PTO because it didn't affect steering, only cooling fans.  The only workable solution for parts will be OEM, which means QCC, or finding an alternative entire hydraulic pump.  We and Foretravel are very fortunate that forum members were able to convince QCC that this is worth bringing parts back into production.
Learn every day, but especially from the experiences of others. It's cheaper!  - John C. Bogle

2000 U320 36' non-slide / WildEBeest Rescue
2003 U320

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #187
I tend to think the liability/ warranty issues are more to do with owner supplied parts than anything else, which I get. Those same shops, will gladly make you a new power steering hose though!! I guess it depends on what part of the world you are in. Here in Yuma a small independent hyd shop doesn't have a problem with a rebuild or a re engineering of the whole system, of course they are independent, may take them a lot of round to it time @ 135.00 per hr. Which don't work when you be broke down.
Bruce, Linda, and Macy
Zoey RIP 1/20/19
1999 U295 40' build #5400
2017 silver Jeep Wrangler, 1260 watts of solar on top
Moving around the country

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #188
Mike, thank you for all your time and efforts on this. I just read through it quickly, but I will need to go back and read it with a morning coffee. I have an 03/295/ISL400; I will check the numbers, but odds are my pump is also affected.

I'd be in line to purchase spare parts and a new spare pump as soon as available.

In the meantime, I wanted to add something about the "green" belt and the jumping tensioner. Mine does that from time to time for the last 8 years, but it only happens during winter months when the temperature goes below 45-50 degrees. So, I use belt conditioner, and that solves the bouncing issue when it's cold outside. I have been using that heavy-duty "green" belt for 8 years now (change the belt about every 5-6K miles).

I mentioned this to Keith Risch; he was curious to find out if a slightly shorter belt could help. However, since belt conditioner solves the bouncing issue, I am thinking a softer belt may be better to use.
Al
Former 2003 GV U295 (6230) (2015 - 2025)
Former 94 GV U225 (2013-2016)

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #189
If vibration is any part of the shaft failure then the harmonic balancers deserve a looksee,there are posts from years ago about
failures and replacing,there are sites with pictures to compare yours to,we have the 8.3 12 valve and replaced ours years ago,
made a slight difference and was easy to do yourself.
96 U270 BUILD 4810
85 380SL
Drummonds TN.

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #190
If vibration is any part of the shaft failure then the harmonic balancers deserve a looksee,there are posts from years ago about
failures and replacing,there are sites with pictures to compare yours to,we have the 8.3 12 valve and replaced ours years ago,
made a slight difference and was easy to do yourself.

Agree, and easy to check.

Just start the engine and verify that the belt is running smoothly/not loading/unloading.

A failed harmonic balancer OR failed belt tensioner could certainly contribute to shaft failure.

A good video on belt tensioners by Gates Corp: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8pQT3YZAwo

Obviously, run-out in the crankshaft pulley/harmonic tensioner could cause the same loading/unloading. 

As could the pulley bolted to the crankshaft if any run-out.

All this is easy to check with engine idling.

BTW, this also applies to all accessories.  Really hard on bearing in alternator, A/C compressor, water pump-- basically anything belt driven.  Smooth is good, loading/unloading NOT.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #191
Quote from: mkc1962 link=msg=479219
Unless you personally are willing to step and up and manufacture those shafts, good luck finding anyone that will. And if you do, you surely would have to lie about the application to get it done.
Will QCC have to lie about what the shafts are for when they seek bids from machine shops to make them?  My nephew mentioned that he remembers bidding quite a few jobs like this from QCC but only "winning" 1 or 2 because some other company underbid them. 
Just think of the different parts involved in the hydraulic/steering system mentioned in this thread.  If the manufacturer of every piece of the puzzle had to guarantee that it would never fail, nothing would get made.
Again, I applaud your efforts and hope that QCC offers the pumps again.  Just saying that if they don't, there are other options.
Dave and Kelli
1997 U295 40' Build #5188 CSGI
1995 U240 36' Build #4621 SBID-SOLD
2006 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #192

In the meantime, I wanted to add something about the "green" belt and the jumping tensioner. Mine does that from time to time for the last 8 years, but it only happens during winter months when the temperature goes below 45-50 degrees. So, I use belt conditioner, and that solves the bouncing issue when it's cold outside. I have been using that heavy-duty "green" belt for 8 years now (change the belt about every 5-6K miles).

I mentioned this to Keith Risch; he was curious to find out if a slightly shorter belt could help. However, since belt conditioner solves the bouncing issue, I am thinking a softer belt may be better to use.
Al

Do NOT change belt lengths, even if they will fit. The load on the belt is figured with the tensioner at a certain point in it's arc.  A friend broke his crankshaft on his blown motor. He put a smaller belt on thinking it would be better.  Turned out the increase load the shorter belt put on the crank caused it to break.
2014 ih45  (4th Foretravel owned)
 1997 36' U295 Sold in 2020, owned for 19 years
  U240 36' Sold to insurance company after melting in garage fire
    33' Foretravel on Dodge Chassis  Sold very long time ago

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #193
Mike,
Did you ever find a new (not overhauled) pump?
Sometimes o/h parts are just someone else's problem.
John Duld
1995 U320C SE 40'

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #194
Mike,
Did you ever find a new (not overhauled) pump?
Sometimes o/h parts are just someone else's problem.

I put a new shaft and seal kit in my Pump, then bought another shaft/seal kit as a spare. I searched all net sources as well as ALL national RV/BUS salvage yards, none were to be had. Though these pumps could be rebuilt on the spot IF you have a shaft, Id prefer to have an entire assembly.

At this moment in time, and during my search there are NO new pumps anywhere to be had. And I called dozens or sources. Even last known manufacturer QCC no longer had any to sell.
That is why I started down the path of working with QCC to continue to source. They only in January of this year discontinued the 9 pumps, as they no longer had any of the rear housings, and had no plans to order any more as they felt those pumps were no longer in need anywhere. When the last of the shafts sold, they now cannot even build a pump as they dont have the rear housings or the shafts. This being for the 41188

As stated earlier, the rear housings are now on order to them, and the shafts are still out for quotes. They agreed to continue to source due to the requests they received from here at FF as well as others I Pointed at the situation.
Myself and many others have stated we would buy complete pumps IF made available again.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #195
[quote author=mkc1962 link=msg=479219 Unless you personally are willing to step and up and manufacture those shafts, good luck finding anyone that will. And if you do, you surely would have to lie about the application to get it done.

Will QCC have to lie about what the shafts are for when they seek bids from machine shops to make them?  My nephew mentioned that he remembers bidding quite a few jobs like this from QCC but only "winning" 1 or 2 because some other company underbid them. 
Just think of the different parts involved in the hydraulic/steering system mentioned in this thread.  If the manufacturer of every piece of the puzzle had to guarantee that it would never fail, nothing would get made.
Again, I applaud your efforts and hope that QCC offers the pumps again.  Just saying that if they don't, there are other options.

QCC would not have to do anything but state the facts as they are the last known manufacturer of the complete assembled pumps....just stating in all my efforts, the only way I or anyone else like me or you, would be able to have shafts manufactured is to not tell directly what its for. 3 Hydraulic repair shops and 8 national suppliers of Hydraulic pump components ALL refused to take part in anything due to the system it is tied to. Probably because I was not a final manufacturer requesting it.
Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #196
At the end of the day, hopefully QCC will produce these pumps. If you break one currently you are dead in the water. All he legal who will do what doesn't matter Sure be nice to have a complete assembly in stock in the spare parts bay, along with a pulley and .adapter. All the rest of the stuff doesn't matter when you are down in the middle of BFE. A lot of  things can break on these  old coaches but mobility wise most pieces for the power train are available. While I do have a new shaft and seal kit for the 41188, I would rather not have to rebuild it beside the road . I will still purchase a complete assy if they come available, much easier to replace  when down. It's great that through the efforts of Mike and a bunch of FT owners, and Simone that QCC is trying to get these pumps back in production.
Bruce, Linda, and Macy
Zoey RIP 1/20/19
1999 U295 40' build #5400
2017 silver Jeep Wrangler, 1260 watts of solar on top
Moving around the country

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #197
As I asked much earlier in this thread, has anyone been able to get the pump specs from Foretravel.

Hydraulic pumps are not rocket science.  Knowing flow and PSI at given RPM (have to look at pump pulley diameter vs crank pulley diameter when discussing pump RPM) could lead to a current replacement.

Many years ago, I went through this exact kind of issue.  We were in Fort Davis State Park one cold December (snow on the ground) and the hydraulic pump "puked" several gallons of fluid on start up.  A call to Foretravel revealed that our hydraulic pump was no longer available. BAD NEWS!

But, they did have a replacement "new style" pump, but it required a new pressure regulator to bring PSI into OE specs.  Oh, and new hoses and hose routing.  In Fort Davis, TX-- not so much.

The bad news, it was really cold (in the 20's), so no fun working under the coach.  The good news is that by driving slowly and stopping to let the engine cool (never got over 205 degree) F and going substantially downhill we got to  Alpine TX. Small, friendly town.  Found a nursery (closed for the winter) a block from a big NAPA store who made a lot of hydraulic hoses for the ranchers in the area.  Measured the many hoses needed and their hose guy came over to see what fittings/ends were needed on each.  A day later we were back on the road.

I have to believe there are alternative pumps that would meet the OE specs, but will likely require interest from Foretravel Corp in assisting owners of older coaches. That has not necessarily proven true in the past.  Hopefully it will now.

No question, this is a distant "Plan B" vs all the hard work being spearheaded by Mike in getting production back on the OE pump.
Brett Wolfe
EX: 1993 U240
Moderator, ForeForum 2001-
Moderator Diesel RV Club 2002-
Moderator, FMCA Forum 2009-2020
Chairman FMCA Technical Advisory Committee 2011-2020

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #198
This topic may have temporally saved us from disaster, because of Mikes findings, info and the video I realized that there should be no movement of the tensioner pulley.
Per the forum info ordered a new pulley and green HD belt and just installed them. Now it runs with no movement sparing the pump from the added pulsating lateral load on the pump shaft/ bearings.
Tried to add a video but I guess it's not possible.
Thanks again Mike !
David & Emma Roche
Dino (Golden Doodle)
1999 U270 WTFE 36' Build # 5534
Xtreme "Lights, Stripes & Roof"
Motorcade# 18321
Dayton, Ohio
Towd: Jeep Grand Cherokee
Two Townie Electra Bikes

Life is made to enjoy, the Foretravel helps!

Re: Hydraulic pump Failed **ALL FORETRAVEL OWNERS SHOULD READ**

Reply #199
As I asked much earlier in this thread, has anyone been able to get the pump specs from Foretravel.

Hydraulic pumps are not rocket science.  Knowing flow and PSI at given RPM (have to look at pump pulley diameter vs crank pulley diameter when discussing pump RPM) could lead to a current replacement.

Many years ago, I went through this exact kind of issue.  We were in Fort Davis State Park one cold December (snow on the ground) and the hydraulic pump "puked" several gallons of fluid on start up.  A call to Foretravel revealed that our hydraulic pump was no longer available. BAD NEWS!

But, they did have a replacement "new style" pump, but it required a new pressure regulator to bring PSI into OE specs.  Oh, and new hoses and hose routing.  In Fort Davis, TX-- not so much.

The bad news, it was really cold (in the 20's), so no fun working under the coach.  The good news is that by driving slowly and stopping to let the engine cool (never got over 205 degree) F and going substantially downhill we got to  Alpine TX. Small, friendly town.  Found a nursery (closed for the winter) a block from a big NAPA store who made a lot of hydraulic hoses for the ranchers in the area.  Measured the many hoses needed and their hose guy came over to see what fittings/ends were needed on each.  A day later we were back on the road.

I have to believe there are alternative pumps that would meet the OE specs, but will likely require interest from Foretravel Corp in assisting owners of older coaches. That has not necessarily proven true in the past.  Hopefully it will now.

No question, this is a distant "Plan B" vs all the hard work being spearheaded by Mike in getting production back on the OE pump.


Brett,

I have obtained ALL specs for anything needed on this 1 pump, I posted all of that early on in this thread. EVEN with all that info when I made attempts to contact ALL those contacts, they all kept giving me the same reply due to legal liability of a safety system. Trust me......MANY YEARS AGO, Is much different than the present day.
36 years of my career partly was spend ordering,sourcing and engineering other ways or replacements. I know very well how to build my own systems. BUT, when nobody at your vendors will take part for the same reason they all keep stating, your dead in the water.

I agree there has to be a better way, but all my efforts could not find anyone to help me find that path. Simone and I spent a few hours one day trying to find another that they still offer that would meet those specs, and they did not have one. FOT is taking part in this solution, but think that will only be to the level of maybe keeping some parts on hand.

All the specs needed to source a better way.
https://www.foreforums.com/MGalleryItem.php?id=5034
https://www.foreforums.com/MGalleryItem.php?id=5033

If you only want to make your own shaft
https://www.foreforums.com/MGalleryItem.php?id=5032

Mike in AL
2001 U295
8.3 ISC 350
Build 5918